Brothers BBQ

2402 NY-32, New Windsor
(845) 534-4227

Recent Reviews

Sort by
J Palvarez

Really good bbq. Nachos are excellent. Fried chicken is good too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Paige D

Cayla was an excellent server! Enjoy her energy and she was very attentive šŸ«¶šŸ»

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sali Kilmer

Only one word necessary for the food….YUM. And the service by Kayla….fantastic! Everyone in our group of 10 was 1000% satisfied with our delicious meals and great service. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Bucci

Cool vibes and good bbq. Big portions and fun options. Gotta have an appetite!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Al Alberto

We've been coming here for a few years now and never have been let down. Brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, mac n cheese, potato salad, cornbread always yummy. Service always attentive. Best barbecue food in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David L

Cayla deserves a raise. And the food is incredible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Raymandi Garcia

I wanted to share our experience at Brothers Barbecue today. While the food was excellent, our concern lies with the service. Our waitress was friendly and attentive, but unfortunately, the manager's behavior left a negative impression.

Despite the restaurant being half empty, the manager complained about large groups arriving. I would understand his concern if there was a wait, but that wasn't the case.

What bothered me more was the apparent disparity in treatment. When white customers arrived, the manager didn't complain or instruct his staff to strictly enforce charging for large sides.

Unfortunately, this experience made me feel unwelcome and discriminated against. As someone who loves visiting Brothers Barbecue, I'm hesitant to return after today's encounter.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 2

Antoinette Ortiz

Our Waitress Cayla was so personable and amazing. Very attentive. The food was amazing as well. Love this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

katelyn welton

Our server Cayla was super nice and helpful. Love that she was so friendly with my son. Definitely had a good time! Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda

Had a great experience! We had an awesome waitress - Kayla. If you go, definitely ask for her section. She was super friendly, very helpful with suggestions, and overall a pleasure to talk to. Not to mention, the food here is always delicious! Great job, Kayla! Can’t wait to come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Essence Asepphen

I'm giving my most honest opinion strictly about the service and food. The atmosphere? Pretty much dead—nothing memorable there.

Now, onto Brothers BBQ. I'm so frustrated because once again: THIS IS NOT SOUTHERN BBQ. Honestly, it’s not even BBQ period.

I ordered the 2-meat combo with two sides—Southern Style Green Beans and Candied Yams. These should be easy wins. For nearly $29, I expected way more food and way more flavor.

Here’s what I got:

2 sausages

2 tiny slices of brisket That’s the whole ā€œ2-meat combo.ā€ šŸ˜’šŸ™„

The Sausage:

Old. Period. You can taste when BBQ beef sausage isn’t fresh—the texture’s dry and crumbly, the casing is rubbery instead of snappy, and there’s no juiciness. It didn’t taste like it just came off the grill. More like it was cooked yesterday, shoved in the fridge, and microwaved before serving. The smoky flavor? Muted. The bite? Flat. Where's the soul?

The Brisket:

Edible, but bland. No depth, no seasoning. Just... there.

The Sides (aka: ā€œle garbĆ”geā€):

Let me choose my words carefully so I don't offend tew much...

Southern Style Green Beans — steamed green beans with zero flavor. That’s it. Not even a whisper of seasoning. How is that Southern?! You put steamed green beans in a cup and called it a day. šŸ¤¦šŸ½ā€ā™€ļø

Candied Yams — whew chile. The yams had nothing on them but water and sugar. No cinnamon, no nutmeg, no butter, no brown sugar, no vanilla extract, no orange zest—NOTHING. Just plain sugar water drowning overcooked yams. Like... y’all couldn’t add something?! Anything?! Where’s the flavor layering? Where’s the love?

Final Thoughts:

I wouldn’t go back to Brothers BBQ. At all.
And if you're wondering—no, Handsome Devil isn’t better. Actually, it might be worse. At least Brothers BBQ remembers salt exists. Handsome Devil cooks like they’re allergic to it. Their potato salad is so bland and pale, it looks like it gave up halfway through life.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chuck R

If you love BBQ, you gotta stop in

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Gina Oswald

The pulled pork sandwich was great! The staff is very welcoming and kind.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandra Herbert-Berg

Amanda was an awesome server. She knew what I needed before I asked. Her interaction with the other coworkers and people dining made the atmosphere so comfortable. She is an asset to the restaurant. We will return for sure…great food and atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim Hultgren

Amanda was excellent! The food outstanding! We ordered the family meal ā€œEat Like the Brothersā€ - we had 5 people and couldn’t finish it all-it was awesome food! Some of the best bbq and I’m from Iowa!😊

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...