Brothers BBQ

2402 NY-32, New Windsor
(845) 534-4227

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jen Blanco

I don't like to give bad reviews after visiting an establishment only 1x knowing how it can negatively effect a business and bad days can happen from time to time. This isn't entirely the case here. I wish I took pictures as soon as we actually opened and saw our orders. Honestly, we were too in shock with how little food was in each container and the amount of $ we just spent for it that it didn't cross my mind to snap a picture until after everyone started eating and commenting how things tasted. You couldn't even smell the food once you opened the containers which you'd expect with flavorful smoked BBQ (definitely not a good 1st impression).

It's not acceptable to be spending $92 to only end up having everyone still hungry afterwards and not 1 person could say they even enjoyed the small portions they had. The only saving grace and reason for 2 stars VS 1 was the corn bread which was actually delicious. Our order: Brisket sandwich with Mac- extremely dry. I could barely swallow it. Brisket was crumbling out of the bun every bite and tasted like it was seasoned with just pepper. The Mac has potential, but it kind of tasted like it was made in a large batch the day before and reheated in the microwave. My daughter barely ate her burger and fries which is her go-to. Said the burger didn't taste right. The most mind blowing part that took the cake in this experience was the fact that for a second, we thought they messed up my husband's order and gave us 2 children's babyback rib orders by accident. The $30 2 meat combo was a joke for the price- 3 ribs and 2 small pieces of fried chicken the size of a large chicken wing! Both had barely any meat on the bones and below average flavor. I've seen more food on a plate with an appetizer sampler for half the price! You'd be better off ordering a kids rib and kids chicken for $18 than the $30 combo. The side of yams were basically mush in sugar water. The kids ribs had 2 ribs and a handful of mushy, over salted fries. Maybe our expectations were too high based on reviews, but overall we were left underwhelmed, disappointed and hungry afterwards. Based on our experience anyways, it definitely wasn't worth the $ spent.

Food: 2

Bethany Perry

Good service, great food!

ultrra traa

This is crazy good. Wife and I got a king’s plate or something… oh yeah Eat Like A King for 80 bucks and couldn’t finish it…. Ribs are falling off the bone, chicken, brisket, chopped bbq everything was so incredibly tender and perfectly smoked and their BBQ taste fantastic. Downed it with some pilsner and we were on our way. A perfect meal. Oh yeah and side plates are huge and sides ljke baked beans and mac n cheese were absolutely out if this world 10/10, would recommend!!! Amanda was fantastic lots of love to her !

David Chen

Warm, inviting staff and genuinely the best BBQ for miles around. I kid you not, the brisket plate with the house BBQ sauce is one of the best meats that I ever had. Also, the cornbread is incredible. If only I didn’t live so far 😩

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

George Dgheim

Amazing service and very friendly and welcoming environment! We got the brisket sandwich and pulled pork sandwich! Both with delicious flavor. Brisket was a little tastier. Their homemade sauce was a good addition to the pulled pork for extra flavor!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edwin Diaz

I’ve lived 5 minutes away from this place for the 4 years. I must say the food was amazing the cornbread is so soft a yummy. Omg. Service is great and the place is so nice inside. Also my waitress Cayla was on point with our order and very kind. Definitely recommend it’s a must try.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

odetta bailey

I ordered the eat like a king meal. There were large portions of ribs, chicken,brisket, and chopped BBQ. I also had the coleslaw which was tasty and fresh along with the macaroni and cheese. Everything tasted good, I'll definitely go back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca Ross

Cayla was a wonderful service . We sat at the bar and had the chicken with carmelized bb sauce and the brisket. Cole slaw, Mac n cheese and baked beans sides. All was in readily delicious. ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Drew Hein

Our server Cayla was fantastic! And the food was delicious. Would highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brothers Smoked Brisket, XL Cornbread, 3 Meat Combo

Alyxandra Michele

Drove an hour and 30 minutes to try this BBQ and it was wonderful!! Our server, Kristen, was friendly, attentive and very nice. Food came out fast and hot. Practically got a whole meal of leftovers to go. Delicious Mac and cheese!! Definitely will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vanessa Lipsett

First time in this restaurant on a Sunday. The staff were very nice. Service was awesome. Food was out quickly, didnt have to wait for long. Everything was delicious, especially the yams! The restrooms were very clean. From start to finish, I have no complaints. Can't wait to go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Eat Like a King

Ly Tran

Food was good, service was not good. The people there were not welcoming at all! They did not even gave water at the table. Will not be returning here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Vincent Russio

Cayla and Aiden were great! Food was good, great Sunday meal

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Campione

Great food for a great price. Reccomend to everyone 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Frankie Matos

The food here never fails! My girlfriend and family come here on a regular and we absolutely love it! The atmosphere and service is great! Definitely gotta give a shout out to server Amanda!!!!!! She’s the og and always taking care of us and serving with love and such a great character that it makes us always want to come back to Brothers Barbecue!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...