Brothers BBQ

2402 NY-32, New Windsor
(845) 534-4227

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Baby Back Ribs Mac and Cheese Baked Beans
Brothers Smoked Brisket
Complementary Cornbread
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Brisket Pulled Pork
Mama's Shrimp Grits
Macaroni and Cheese
Smoked Baked Beans
Chopped BBQ Plate
1 Piece Cornbread

Menu

Appetizer
Boneless Wings
Buttermilk fried boneless chicken chunks tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and homemade blue cheese dressing
Smoked Wings
Chicken wings hickory smoked until juicy and tender, then deep fried 'til crispy and tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and homemade blue cheese dressing
Nachos
Tortilla chips, topped with our BBQ meat of the day, smothered with Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, topped with smoked Pico de Gallo, and sour cream. Ask your sever for the meat of the day!
Sticky Ribs
Our St. Louis ribs smoked low n slow and caramelized in our house BBQ sauce
Uncle Bo Shrimp
Gulf shrimp seasoned with our house rub grilled then glazed with BBQ sauce served with our horseradish cream sauce.
Hungry Helpers
Beaufort Shrimp
Gulf shrimp seasoned with our house rub grilled then glazed with BBQ sauce served with our horseradish cream sauce.
Sausage Cheese Plate

Soup/Salad
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, and homemade cornbread croutons, tossed with our homemade Caesar dressing.
Dads Iceburg
Just like dad made at home, a hunk of iceberg smothered with blue cheese dressing, chopped tomatoes, and apple wood smoked bacon
Brothers Greens
Mixed Greens and Romaine topped with diced tomato, onion, Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, served with homemade balsamic vinaigrette
Greek Salad
Chili
Chicken Noodle Soup

Burger
Classic
8oz blend of porterhouse, chuck, and brisket burger, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and your choice of cheese Served on a brioche bun, with French fries. Add apple wood smoked bacon $2
Porko Burger
8oz blend of porterhouse, chuck, and brisket burger, topped with cheddar, apple wood smoked bacon, pulled pork, fried onion strings, and our famous BBQ sauce. Served on a brioche bun, with French fries.
Stuffed Burger
Smokehouse
Big Tex

Sandwich
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Our smoked until tender pork pulled to order, served on a brioche bun.
Brisket Sandwich
Our tender pepper-crusted hickory smoked brisket sliced and piled high on a brioche bun.
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Buttermilk marinated chicken breast, fried golden brown, topped with apple wood smoked bacon and cheddar, served on a brioche bun.
Shrimp Po Boy
BIG BOY Sandwich
Can't decide? Don't, get them all. Pulled pork, brisket, sausage, and apple wood smoked bacon, stacked high and topped with our BBQ sauce. Served on a brioche bun.
Chopped BBQ Sandwich
Smoked pork chopped up and dressed with our eastern North Carolina vinegar based sauce, topped with homemade coleslaw and pickles, served on a brioche bun.
Gunslinger
Rooster Sandwich
House marinated chicken breast grilled and glazed with BBQ sauce, served on a brioche bun.
Bro Ribber
Frankie Boy

From Our Pit
2 Meat Combo
Choose two of your favorite smoked meats: pulled Pork, brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, chopped BBQ, or sausage.
3 Meat Combo
Choose three of your favorite smoked meats: pulled pork, brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, chopped BBQ, or sausage.
Brothers Smoked Brisket
Pepper-crusted and smoked low and slow for over 15 hours, until perfectly tender and juicy. Sliced to order.
Brothers Legendary Half Rack Ribs
Your choice of Baby Back or St. Louis ribs seasoned with our house dry rub smoked and slow for over 5 hours until they're juicy, tender and almost fall of the bone.
Pulled Pork Plate
Our super tender smoked pork, hand-pulled to order
Brothers Legendary Full Rack Ribs
Your choice of Baby Back or St. Louis ribs seasoned with our house dry rub smoked and slow for over 5 hours until they're juicy, tender and almost fall of the bone.
Uncle Dave
A sampler of our most popular smoked meats: ribs, pulled pork, brisket, smoked chicken, and sausage.
Pound of Brisket
Smoked Yard Bird
Half chicken brined for 12 hours, then rubbed and smoked until juicy and tender.
Pulled Pint
Texan Smoked Sausage
Straight from the South Side Market in Elgin Texas these sausages are specially handcrafted for us. A duo of Texas style beef sausage and Jalapeno Cheddar Sausage smoked then kissed on the grill.
Chopped BBQ Plate
A North Carolina staple, what the brothers grew up on. Our fresh smoked pork chopped and dressed with our eastern North Carolina vinegar based sauce.
Chopped BBQ Pint
Whole Smoked Chicken

Southern
Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken
Just like our Great Aunt Edna used to make for us, its crispy, juicy, and fried to order, a brothers favorite served with your choice of two sides
Aunt Caroline's Fried Shrimp
Gulf shrimp dredged in seasoned flour, fried to perfection, and served with your two sides
Smoken Rooster Entree
Our house marinated chicken breasts grilled and glazed with BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of two sides.
Mama's Shrimp Grits
Gulf shrimp sautéed with bacon, peppers, and onions, served over our cheesy grits. Just like when we were kids

Sides
1 Piece Cornbread
Extra BBQ Sauce
Mac N Cheese
Fries
Big Jay's Collard Greens
Potato Salad
Yams
Cole Slaw
Bottle BBQ Sauce
Green Beans
Smoked Baked Beans
Grits

Desserts
French Toast Bread pudding Ala Mode
Brownie Sundae

Kids Menu
Kids Nuggets
Kids hot dog
Cheese Burger
Kids Ribs
Grilled Cheese
Mac & Cheese
Kids Ice Cream
Kids Hot Fudge Sundae

NA Beverages
Sweet Tea
V Pina Colada
Soda
Apple Juice
Espresso
Kids Soda
Milk
Orange Juice
Cranberry
Coffee
Hot Tea
Bottled Water
Cappuccino

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+57 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+56 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Food was excellent, zero complaints! It wasn't very busy, I thought the server could have been a little more attentive. There was an Asian street cooking show playing on the big screen which was a little odd. Not my first visit and will absolutely be back for more!! 😋
February 2026
This is now my go-to spot for dinner after a day skiing in the Catskills. The barbecued meats, sauce, and sides are delicious, the service is friendly and attentive (we could tell Amanda genuinely wanted us to have a great experience — Thanks!), and the location is the perfectly convenient halfway point on the drive back to the city. There is a full bar, easy parking, and a few large TVs for any games that might be of interest on any given night.
January 2026
Brothers Barbecue blows your mind. From the fiery wings smoked to perfection, to the beers from the tap, the atmosphere and the waitstaff are beyond reproach. Go there and ask for Cayla’s section, for she will guide you through a meal that tickles your tastebuds, and leaves you wishing your stomachs could fit more food in it.

The roving Manager Brandon is an amazing character that is great with a story, or anecdotes to assist in making a great evening reach...
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

McDonald's - 2639 NY-32
Fast Food, Burgers, Coffee & Tea
Citrus Restaurant - NY, 1004 NY-94
Indian, Thai, Vegan, Vegetarian
Dunkin' - 1002 NY-94
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee

Brothers BBQ

2402 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 534-4227