Hoagie Barmichaels

1101 River Rd, New Windsor
(845) 561-8600

Recent Reviews

Shawn Hobson

Went for St.Pats day 2nd year in a row. Whoever does the cooking does an EXCELLENT job on the corned beef. The place was packed but this particular day parking was crazy and there was an accident in the parking lot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

David Rein (GlobalTechGuy)

If you’re looking for a great hole in the wall, old school, bar and grill, this is the place to go. The bartenders are friendly. The food is fantastic. The owner always has a smile and the people that hang out there are just the salt of the Earth.Also, the bar menu is great! Everything on it is yummy and highly recommended.Parking: The parking lot is easily accessible. Also, in the winter they always make sure the snow is cleared before they open. Never have any problem parking here except for maybe when it’s crowded.Wheelchair accessibility: The side door is wheelchair accessible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steamed Clams, Loaded Tots, Blackened Chicken Salad with Mojito Dressing, Hoagie Burger, Fried Chicken Club, Chicken Philly Sandwich Special, Wings and Coconut Shrimp Special, Shrimp Patty Burger Special, Potato Skins, Sweet Potato Fries, Burgers, Blackberry BBQ Burger, Cajun Chicken Alfredo, Pulled Pork Sandwich, Quesadillas, Wings, Philly Cheese Steak, Spicy Garlic Wings, Breakfast Quesadilla, Tacos

Samuel Terhaar

Nice place, the bartender a little strange

Rose Garland

Lovely little pub and lovely staff.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 4

796tiffanyl

Great stop in for a drink. Just down the road from the water front area. Great food and full bar. Sports style atmosphere with friendly service and faces. Music plays, people hang. Would definitely stop in again!

William Davis

A quintessential neighborhood bar with character and good folk. Service was cheerful, friendly, and attentive!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Frank “IL Tesoro” Aloshi

The bartender Vicky who is seasoned made my late lunch. Great mixologist.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anton or Frank

The bartender Vicky who is seasoned made my late lunch. Great mixologist.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fast Freddie Mascitelli

Great old bar had a great hamburger fair prices great bartender will be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dana F

Great atmosphere, choose your own music, games to play

David M.

our experience last week was different than others who posted here. Id sadly rate it poor!!The bar is narrow with a low ceiling and thus very noisy.Its poorly equipped to have music as they are stuffed in a back room.The poor bar tender, was bartender,order taker,order delivererer....which we can assure you doesn't not work. Litterally no table service.The smoking area out side basicly drafts those sitting at the last 3 tables let alone the over powering smell of nicotine.2 couples briefly sat at out table; and left. we had 2 drinks but no food....and left.It might be a good spot for a small group. parking is very limited. we parked by the garbage units and some client graciously parked the entryway closed.All in all a really bad experience but i salute the bar tender woman for keeping her cool.

A G

1st time visit here. Stopped in for a quick bite in between shopping. Food was great and beer cold. Friendly bartender. Definitely will be back. Thx

Grial L

1st time visit here. Stopped in for a quick bite in between shopping. Food was great and beer cold. Friendly bartender. Definitely will be back. Thx

Mary Fiero

LOVED IT!!!! It was pretty quiet when we came in, stools all packed with (based on their knowledge of the bartenders name, I assume) regulars! The beautiful Katrina was so lovely and accommodating! The music was great, the pool table was open so my boyfriend and I played a few games and ended up playing a few with some friendly patrons! I got to do some dancing, and singing! We had a blast tonight. I highly recommend to first timers looking for a fun hangout spot with good vibes! Thanks for the memories. <3

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This Guy

This place is always great. Bartenders are great. Owner is hands on and cares. Great local bar with excellent bar food. Highly recommended!

Load More