The Old Castaways

405 Shore Rd, New Windsor
(845) 237-7323

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Daniel Zimmerman

I found it quite pleasant

Jay Semloh

Old school!

Heather Casanova

Ladies watch your man around the bartender on Sundays she doesn’t care if he’s married or taken.

Felix Santiago

Good blue collar bar

Desmond Smith

Great place. Food and drinks are good. KARAOKE is great! Eric and Corey are great bartenders.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

stefanie m

This bar has seen great improvements recently! The food and atmosphere are great for a local bar. The outdoor space that the owner created is inviting in the warmer weather. The bartenders are good, but Eric was the best! He’s friendly, provides good service and is very personable. His attention to the customers he’s serving at the bar is outstanding especially on busy weekend nights. We go when he’s there for the best service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Menzie

Great local bar. Beer is cold and people are nice

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Jon Delfini (Jon)

Good place to go but the lighting on that pool table is terrible.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Robert Dentato

As long as you stay away from mixed drinks, it's a great place. They're overpriced and watered down.

Herman L

The bar s friendly! All the bartenders are excellent. I go there with my wife to eat. Great food! Visit our local bar. Here you are like home without the cleaning

Parking: Spacious lot! A bus can fit here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Fries, Wings

Michael Lee

I am banned for life, by the woman who said "you were singing to the music, and talking to people!!" And she went on to call me a "drunk person", and to cruelly announce that it was "a bar" ; not a place for "talking to people" abput my misding chindten, or "singing" along with the jukebox, and that she "don't care!" about missing children.Before that I had a few pleasant conversations about the food there,vand saw some very friendly and warm faces:I have gone there since my childhood.There is a picture that is supposedlye: I was there, and did look similar, and I have discovered that I have an identical twin, who grew up in Wyoming; Niko said there is a third who also lived in Newburgh, but I have not yet seen him.This pub,band it's patrons are cool; there were a handful of very mean people there that nightOh well; I can add it to the many other groceries, libraries, pubs, restaurants, parks, bus stations, and two whole entire cities that I am recently and permanently banned for life from, including Brandywine PA; it is called mobbing, hazing, gangstalking, shunning, discrediting, blackballing, and and black-listing.This is a hometown favorite pub;God bless everyone.Yes, I did say a bad word as I was threatened cruelly and physically by her boyfriend to "leave!"Recommended; twenty stars; a "good" hometown place with nice steamers for a buck !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Todd Leavitt

Great little place to hang out. Food was awesome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

Davin Gray

It felt like being in your rich friend's basement bar. Which is exactly what I want.

Vegetarian options: Pickle chips are great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: French Fries, Wings

Davin

It felt like being in your rich friend's basement bar. Which is exactly what I want.

Vegetarian options: Pickle chips are great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: French Fries

M Union

Awesome local bar

Loading...