Cosimo's

1217 NY-300, Newburgh
(845) 567-1556

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Brick Oven Magrarehtta Pizza with Grilled Mushrooms and Sauteed Onions
Spicy Fennel Sausage Wood Fired Pizza
Margherita Pizza with Fennel Sausage
Truffle Portobello Flatbread
Polpette Chef’S Meatballs
Spicy Fennel Sausage Pizza
Polpette Chef's Meatballs
Jones Farm Carrot Cake
Spicy Chicken Fusilli
Burrata Garlic Bread

Menu

Appetizers
Antipasto Misto
House made mozzarella, soppressata, proscuitto di Parma, Grana Padano, roasted Red Peppers, marinated artichokes, Italian long hots, olives, honey, grilled bread.
Arancini
Italian rice balls, prosciutto, manchego, peas, pomodoro.
Caprese
Sliced house made mozzarella, vine ripened tomatoes, torn basil, EVOO, fire roasted peppers.
Crispy Mozzarella
Prosciutto di Parma, wrapped mozzarella, Italian bread crumbs, tomato basil sauce.
Fried Calamari
Seasoned calamari, spicy pomodoro sauce.
Meatball Appetizer
Short rib, brisket, veal, pork, Calabrian chili, herbed ricotta, pomodoro, grilled bread.
Jumbo Shrimp Baguette
Charred scallion and parmigiano gratinato, spicy scampi sauce.
Tuna Tartare
Diced yellowfin tuna, chopped arugula, lemon, calamata olives, avocado, red onion, pine nuts crostini.
Waffle Potatoes with Gorgonzola
Rosemary garlic fries and creamy gorgonzola sauce.
Burrata Garlic Bread
Grilled baguette, garlic chili butter, burrata, roasted heirloom tomato.
Stuffed Portobello
Roasted portobello mushrooms, caramelized shallots, spinach, roma tomatoes.

Brick Oven Flatbreads
Prosciutto & Fig Flatbread
Port soaked fig jam, prosciutto di Parma, gorgonzola and mozzarella cheese, baby arugula, balsamic glaze.
Truffle Portobello Flatbread
Portobello mushrooms, goat cheese, truffle oil, mozzarella, baby arugula, shaved parmigiano.

Carne
Crispy Skin Chicken
Boneless half chicken, marsala portobello mushrooms, mashed potato, baby spinach.
The Chicken Parm
Pan fried bell & Evans chicken breast, baked with tomato basil sauce, burrata, mozzarella & parmigiano, served with rigatoni pomodoro.
Braised Short Ribs
Cherry pepper glaze, Italian street corn polenta, broccoli rabe.
Double Cut Pork Chop
Herb crust, sliced and served with skillet potato and Agrodolce peppers.
Eggplant Parm
Pan fried eggplant, baked with tomato basil sauce, burrata, mozzarella & parmigiano, served with rigatoni pomodoro.
Herbed Roasted Chicken
Brined local chicken, red hot potato, sauteed baby spinach, pan jus.
Steak and Frites
Certified black angus beef, garlic and parmigiano fries. Hotel butter aioli.

Pasta
Gnocchi
Wild mushroom, spinach, caramelized shallots, roasted cherry tomatoes, sherry brown butter.
Grilled Chicken Penne
Roma tomatoes, homemade pesto, grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, arugula, kalamata olives.
Spicy Chicken Fusilli
Fusilli grande, grilled chicken, spicy scallion cream sauce, fontina cheese.
Chicken Francaise
Egg battered chicken breast, lemon butter sauce, spaghetti, parmigano.
Pasta Della Nonna
Rigatoni, crushed meatballs, tomato basil suace,, melted mozzarella.
White Clam Sauce
Linguini pasta, crisp garlic, white wine, fresh herbs.
Al Pomodoro
Spaghetti, San Marzano tomato sauce, heirloom cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, EVVO.
Shrimp Sautee
Malfadine, calamata olives, sauteed shrimp, blistered heirloom cherry tomatoes, touch of pesto & shaved parmigiano.
Ravioli Con Mozzarella
Oven baked cheese ravioli, tomato basil sauce, melted mozzarella.
Rigatoni Alla Buttera
Rigatoni, sweet sausage, peas, rosemary, tomato cream sauce.
Sausage & Ricotta Fusilli
Fusilli grande,roasted peppers, plum tomato sauce, sauteed onions, artisanal sausage, herbed ricotta.
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Pappardelle pasta, sauteed shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, fiery plum tomato sauce.
Shrimp Cappellini
Pan-seared jumbo shrimp, toasted garlic, fiery cherry tomato broth.
Sun-Dried Tomatoes Alla Vodka
Sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms, sauteed onions, vodka tomato cream sauce penne pasta.

Sandwiches
CBO Burger
8 oz. black angus burger, jalapeno smoked bacon, wood fired Bermuda onion, provolone, chef's mayo, Italian bun.
Grilled Eggplant Sandwich
Marinated eggplant, sun-dried tomatoes, arugula, goat cheese, grilled piadina bread.
Pan Fried Tomato Fresca Sandwich
Breaded vine ripened tomato, prosciutto di Parma, fresh mozzarella, house pesto, grilled baguette.

Pesce
Citrus Basil Salmon
Broccoli rabe, tuscan white beans, citrus basil emulsion.
Grilled Swordfish
Lemon scallion pan potato, salmorigilio, Mediterranean olive & tomato salad.
Seared Tuna
Arugula, house pickled onion & cucumbers, sweet tomatoes, charred Fresno mayo.
Herb Baked Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp, garlic and herb crumbs, charred scallion wild rice, sauteed baby kale.

Soups & Salads
Honey Ginger Salad
Grilled chicken, Napa cabbage, cilantro, julienned carrots, spring onion, greens, crispy wontons, flamed sugar peanuts, honey ginger dressing.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce and seasoned croutons tossed in our Caesar dressing, topped with shaved Parmesan.
Grilled Chicken Paillard Salad
Flash grilled pesto basted chicken topped with field greens, red onions, tomatoes, prosecco vinaigrette and shaved pecorino.
Harvest Salad
Hudson Valley apples, dried cranberries, walnuts, feta, radicchio, romaine, black currant vinaigrette.
House Salad
Mixed greens, red onions, julienned carrots, cucumber, honey balsamic vinaigrette.
Kale & Beet Salad
Roasted heirloom beets, baby kale, pistachio, goat cheese, champagne vinaigrette.
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Contains pork. Hearty tuscan bean soup with ditalini pasta and parmigiano.
Pizza Insalata
Wood fired pizza crust, crisp romaine, marinated tomatoes, red onion, shaved Pecorino Romano, balsamic vinaigrette.
Romano Chicken Chop Chop Salad
Romaine, Romano crusted chicken, chickpeas, egg, tomato, bacon, creamy parmigiano dressing.

Wood Fired Pizza
Broccoli Pie Pizza
Broccoli florets, garlic puree, mozzarella, ricotta sauce, Pecorino Romano.
Margherita Pizza
San marizano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, evvo.
Eggplant Pizza
Breaded eggplant, burrata, long hot peppers, tomato basil sauce, basil, parmigiano.
Grilled Chicken Artichoke
Caramelized onions, artichoke pesto, calamata olives, fontina and mozzarella cheese.
Meatball Pizza
Sliced meatballs, san marzano tomato sauce, herbed ricotta cheese, mozzarella.
Nick's Pie Pizza
Calabrese soppressata, marinated sun-dried tomatoes, baby kale, pecorino and fresh mozzarella.
Southwestern Pizza
Chili chicken, green onion, fresh tomato,, mozzarella and sharp cheddar blend, pickled Fresno peppers, avocado ranch.
Spicy Fennel Sausage Pizza
Hot peppers, wood fired onions, tomato basil sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese.
Spinach & Bacon Pizza
Herbed ricotta, mozzarella cheese, fresh tomatoes baby spinach, local bacon.
Wild Mushroom Pizza
Heirloom cherry tomatoes, gorgonzola dolce, mozzarella, parmigiano, thyme oil.
NY Style Pizza
Pomodoro sauce, shredded mozzarella.

Sides
Italian Street Corn Polenta
"Polpette" Chef's Meatballs
Baby Spinach with Toasted Garlic
Broccoli Rabe with Toasted Garlic
Brussels Sprouts
Charbroiled Spicy Italian Sausage
Charred Scallion Wild Rice
Lemon Scallion Pan Potato
Mashed Potatoes
Red Hot Potato
Skillet Potato
Tuscan Fries
Tuscan White Beans
Cauliflower

Desserts
Cheese Cake
NY style cheese cake, amarena cherries.
Pizzeppole
Fried pizza dough balls, cinnamon sugar, caramel sugar.
Berries
Macerated berries, house made lemon custard, shortbread shell, whipped cream.
Tiramisu
Espresso soaked lady fingers, amaretto-mascarpone cream, shaved dark chocolate.
Traditional Cannoli
Warm Chocolate Lava Cake
Individual chocolate souffle, Jane's cappuccino crunch ice cream.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: facebook
+33 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+32 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Cosimo’s is a great place to have a nice semi-fancy Italian dinner. Their service is excellent, and the food is top notch. I ordered the linguini with clams and white wine sauce and my cousin ordered the pasta with butter and shrimp. Both of our dishes were fantastic. The shrimps were nice and juicy, and the white wine sauce pairs perfectly with the clams and made for a delicious pasta. Their vast wine selection is also a huge pro of Cosimo’s. It’s also in a prime location...
August 2025
We were in the area to visit our son at West Point and took him to dinner here. Great place! The food was excellent, and I am not surprised given how packed the parking lot was. The menu is primarily Italian, but they also have a great NY Strip, seafood and desserts. Great place for a nice sit down dinner.
August 2025
This used to be our go to Italian local spot…they usually have great food…I only order either chicken francaise or penne a la vodka with grilled chicken…Lately (last 2-3 times) something’s off with the chicken….Definitely not fresh, temp is off compared to the noodles (alot colder)n tastes like it’s old or reheated smh…I would ask them about the chicken b4 u order it…I must say they our waitress was Great!
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Smoothie King - 1221 NY-300 Suite 101
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Vegan
Jersey Mike's Subs - 1223 NY-300 Suite 203
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food, Pet Friendly
Pizza 300 - 1208 NY-300
Pizza, Italian

Cosimo's

1217 NY-300, Newburgh, NY 12550
(845) 567-1556