Whenever in Newburgh this is a must stop. Great food, friendly service in a clean atmosphere at affordable prices!
Jeff VanZandt
Costagliola's was definitely authentic Italian done very well... everything made fresh....will definitely miss taking my son there...good luck on your next venture
Ken Daniels
went there this evening around 7 30pm,i had heard that the food was great, i have to honestly say i was dissapointed, i asked for garlic bread,i got spmething not even italian bread and it was stale, the minestrone spup was over cooked and mushythe chicken parm was ok but the sauce was raw and uncooked, not authentic, and pretty pricey for poor quality sorry not a fan
Jenisia Nieves
Excellent customer service!! Food was delicious!! Definitely will be back
Stu Berger
Probably the best Italian food I have ever had.
Kathy Andrews
Food was great, our waitress was great. Celebrated my retirement.
Flower Girl
The food here is delicious and we will be returning very soon!
Carmine DeFalco
Great atmosphere, superior friendly service, extraordinary food, homemade pastas (literally like my grandma’s & I am 68), outstanding bread, and wonderful espresso. This was our first visit...we are from North Jersey about 1hr ride...will be back. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience and for being able to easily accommodate our party of 12! Carmine DeFalco
Raul Molestina
Never got to taste the food. The young lady in the front stood on her phone the whole time and older lady was bringing out all the food alone. When the younger girl finally look away from her phone and saw we were still waiting she looked upset. Also The ceiling had alot of stains.
kbloom4647
We stopped on our way through Newburgh, NY and were pleasantly surprised when we stopped for dinner at Costagliola’s Little Italy. The food was fantastic. We loved the soups, minestrone and pasta fazool. Both were light and very flavorful. Without question the best we’ve ever tasted. The entrees we decided on did not disappoint. The broccoli with penne pasta, olive oil and garlic was superb. The veal parmigiana was wonderfully tender, covered with a terrific tomato sauce and plenty of melted mozzarella cheese. You will not be disappointed if you decide to visit.
Came from out of town. Delicious food, great service, really nice people. Highly recommend the stuffed shrimp.
Bob Markel
Great homemade Italian food
Samantha Weck
Came here with my family tonight. We've been before and the food is always good. Tonight our waitress Ida (I apologize if I spelled the name wrong) was absolutely amazing. She was super nice and gave us quick service despite being such a large group. I highly recommend coming here for Italian food.
Whenever in Newburgh this is a must stop. Great food, friendly service in a clean atmosphere at affordable prices!
Costagliola's was definitely authentic Italian done very well... everything made fresh....will definitely miss taking my son there...good luck on your next venture
went there this evening around 7 30pm,i had heard that the food was great, i have to honestly say i was dissapointed, i asked for garlic bread,i got spmething not even italian bread and it was stale, the minestrone spup was over cooked and mushythe chicken parm was ok but the sauce was raw and uncooked, not authentic, and pretty pricey for poor quality sorry not a fan
Excellent customer service!! Food was delicious!! Definitely will be back
Probably the best Italian food I have ever had.
Food was great, our waitress was great. Celebrated my retirement.
The food here is delicious and we will be returning very soon!
Great atmosphere, superior friendly service, extraordinary food, homemade pastas (literally like my grandma’s & I am 68), outstanding bread, and wonderful espresso. This was our first visit...we are from North Jersey about 1hr ride...will be back. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience and for being able to easily accommodate our party of 12! Carmine DeFalco
Never got to taste the food. The young lady in the front stood on her phone the whole time and older lady was bringing out all the food alone. When the younger girl finally look away from her phone and saw we were still waiting she looked upset. Also The ceiling had alot of stains.
We stopped on our way through Newburgh, NY and were pleasantly surprised when we stopped for dinner at Costagliola’s Little Italy. The food was fantastic. We loved the soups, minestrone and pasta fazool. Both were light and very flavorful. Without question the best we’ve ever tasted. The entrees we decided on did not disappoint. The broccoli with penne pasta, olive oil and garlic was superb. The veal parmigiana was wonderfully tender, covered with a terrific tomato sauce and plenty of melted mozzarella cheese. You will not be disappointed if you decide to visit.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is always good and you get a lot.
Came from out of town. Delicious food, great service, really nice people. Highly recommend the stuffed shrimp.
Great homemade Italian food
Came here with my family tonight. We've been before and the food is always good. Tonight our waitress Ida (I apologize if I spelled the name wrong) was absolutely amazing. She was super nice and gave us quick service despite being such a large group. I highly recommend coming here for Italian food.
Very good customer service, good meals as well