Waited 15 minutes past our reservation to be seated, and then, after getting us water and telling us about the specials, our waiter never came back - after a half hour we left money on the table for the Pellegrino and walked out
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 1
Dawn Calle
Was here for a party of 16 last night with real Italians. Everyone agreed some of the best Italian food we had. The food was family style and delicious. The service was impeccable. The music was perfect. Thank you so much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Fabian
This place is really awesome, all-around. Food is fresh and delicious and service is very accommodating. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Batg
There is a new waiter that was rushing through the specials. He has an accent and I noticed he lost all tables when reciting the specials. When I asked him to repeat something he seemed aggravated. This is my favorite restaurant, and I know this would not be acceptable to the owners based on the professionalism of the other wait staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Anderson
My favorite Italian restaurant in Newburgh!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Inna Morozova
Amazing food , great service. The food was delicious and well prepared and served .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Sciaraffa
Not worth the price. Make sure you ask how much the specials are !!! Food and service were good but not 260.00 for 2 people good.we did not even have alcohol and the price was still this high. Never again.
Tracy Kral
OOMMGGG.. father's day dinner with my parents was just amazing! SOO glad we chose to go here. service, food, ambiance is INCREDIBLE. its a complete experience. BETTER than Arthur Ave in bronx, we had the lobster ravioli, the mushroom ravioli, and the lamb paparadele . Deserts too, 🫠 There's a ton of food that they consider specials that the waiter riddled off to us.It was more than the actual menu itself. Cannot wait to go back. It's worth every penny. They even have an outdoor patio area by the lake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barry Hermelee
The fish I had was excellent. However, the vegetable, specifically, broccoli, tasted like overcooked rubber. In view of the fact that this is a fine dining restaurant, it is an excusable to have a vegetable that I would not serve to my pet!!! In view of this fact, I unfortunately would not recommend this restaurant!!!!
Walking into IL Cenacolo feels like stepping into a warm Italian family home—inviting, cozy, and full of charm. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, making the whole experience even more enjoyable.
I've wanted to eat here since I was a kid, and it was absolutely worth the wait. Everything is made in-house with the freshest ingredients, and you can truly taste the quality in every bite.
I don’t usually eat eggplant, but I tried the eggplant appetizer with ricotta and sauce—and I can’t stop thinking about it. The eggplant was cooked perfectly, the ricotta was silky and flavorful, and the sauce was just perfection (which is rare to find).
Unique menu, amazing food, great service. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charlie Wiggins
We were at Il Cene Colo last night for my wife’s birthday. We heard so many wonderful things about the restaurant we couldn’t wait to eat there. The place was packed. Which was a good sign.
There were 4 of us. Not one of us enjoyed our dinner. I had the bolognese with pappardelle. The noodles were mushy and the sauce was like something you’d get at a diner. My wife had the Veal salvia. She said it was like eating dog food. I tasted hers and it was awful. Our friends each had ravioli. One was filled with spinach and the other 4 cheese. Neither of them enjoyed their meal at all. In total we had 4 pasta entrees and one glass of wine. The bill came to $166.00 with tax. Really??? We all were in the mood for dessert but were afraid to order it based on how bad the meals were.
You can understand if one person doesn’t like their meal but when everyone at the table had the same experience that’s not a good sign.
I will say that the service was excellent! So take my advice and stay away from this over rated and way over priced restaurant. Save your money and go to your favorite pizzeria instead.
Ann Marie
celebrated with close friends yesterday, 💛 💓 💗 💖 never disappointed with the food quality, presentation, quantity or flavor. not to mention service, ambiance and staff.
Oresti Tsonopoulos
Enter another era in Cenacolo, old school Italian American fun. For me it's all about the antipasti platter and the martinis, though the grappa and espresso are solid as well with a slice of juicy carrot cake for dessert. Entrees were a little underwhelming to be honest but I think the kitchen was too busy and undercooking all of the proteins. Truffle pasta was fun and delicious, but I'd be happy to hang out with the antipasti and grappa for hours. Grazie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christina Francesconi
This place is never a disappointment service is always great the waiter does an exceptional job remembering all the specials lol always impressed by that food is out of the world and ambience is cozy ! Do yourself a favor and try them you won’t be upset you did 😋👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼
Waited 15 minutes past our reservation to be seated, and then, after getting us water and telling us about the specials, our waiter never came back - after a half hour we left money on the table for the Pellegrino and walked out
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 1
Was here for a party of 16 last night with real Italians. Everyone agreed some of the best Italian food we had. The food was family style and delicious. The service was impeccable. The music was perfect. Thank you so much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is really awesome, all-around. Food is fresh and delicious and service is very accommodating. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There is a new waiter that was rushing through the specials. He has an accent and I noticed he lost all tables when reciting the specials. When I asked him to repeat something he seemed aggravated. This is my favorite restaurant, and I know this would not be acceptable to the owners based on the professionalism of the other wait staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite Italian restaurant in Newburgh!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food , great service. The food was delicious and well prepared and served .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not worth the price. Make sure you ask how much the specials are !!! Food and service were good but not 260.00 for 2 people good.we did not even have alcohol and the price was still this high. Never again.
OOMMGGG.. father's day dinner with my parents was just amazing! SOO glad we chose to go here. service, food, ambiance is INCREDIBLE. its a complete experience. BETTER than Arthur Ave in bronx, we had the lobster ravioli, the mushroom ravioli, and the lamb paparadele . Deserts too, 🫠
There's a ton of food that they consider specials that the waiter riddled off to us.It was more than the actual menu itself. Cannot wait to go back. It's worth every penny. They even have an outdoor patio area by the lake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The fish I had was excellent. However, the vegetable, specifically, broccoli, tasted like overcooked rubber. In view of the fact that this is a fine dining restaurant, it is an excusable to have a vegetable that I would not serve to my pet!!! In view of this fact, I unfortunately would not recommend this restaurant!!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Walking into IL Cenacolo feels like stepping into a warm Italian family home—inviting, cozy, and full of charm. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, making the whole experience even more enjoyable.
I've wanted to eat here since I was a kid, and it was absolutely worth the wait. Everything is made in-house with the freshest ingredients, and you can truly taste the quality in every bite.
I don’t usually eat eggplant, but I tried the eggplant appetizer with ricotta and sauce—and I can’t stop thinking about it. The eggplant was cooked perfectly, the ricotta was silky and flavorful, and the sauce was just perfection (which is rare to find).
Unique menu, amazing food, great service. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were at Il Cene Colo last night for my wife’s birthday. We heard so many wonderful things about the restaurant we couldn’t wait to eat there. The place was packed. Which was a good sign. There were 4 of us. Not one of us enjoyed our dinner. I had the bolognese with pappardelle. The noodles were mushy and the sauce was like something you’d get at a diner. My wife had the Veal salvia. She said it was like eating dog food. I tasted hers and it was awful. Our friends each had ravioli. One was filled with spinach and the other 4 cheese. Neither of them enjoyed their meal at all. In total we had 4 pasta entrees and one glass of wine. The bill came to $166.00 with tax. Really??? We all were in the mood for dessert but were afraid to order it based on how bad the meals were. You can understand if one person doesn’t like their meal but when everyone at the table had the same experience that’s not a good sign. I will say that the service was excellent! So take my advice and stay away from this over rated and way over priced restaurant. Save your money and go to your favorite pizzeria instead.
celebrated with close friends yesterday, 💛 💓 💗 💖 never disappointed with the food quality, presentation, quantity or flavor. not to mention service, ambiance and staff.
Enter another era in Cenacolo, old school Italian American fun. For me it's all about the antipasti platter and the martinis, though the grappa and espresso are solid as well with a slice of juicy carrot cake for dessert. Entrees were a little underwhelming to be honest but I think the kitchen was too busy and undercooking all of the proteins. Truffle pasta was fun and delicious, but I'd be happy to hang out with the antipasti and grappa for hours. Grazie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is never a disappointment service is always great the waiter does an exceptional job remembering all the specials lol always impressed by that food is out of the world and ambience is cozy ! Do yourself a favor and try them you won’t be upset you did 😋👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...