This was a great find when we went to Brotherhood winery. Food and service were fantastic. I wish i lived closer. We will definitely make an excuse to go back!
Katelyn
The smoked meats on the charcuterie board were phenomenal. We loved all of the character and charm as well as the history of the building. The owner Tom and his wife were so kind and attentive. We got dessert to go but they still brought out ice cream for my boyfriend's birthday! When in NY we will definitely be back to visit.
Anand Mundra
This is a classy place, the kind nearly impossible to find anymore, especially in the bigger cities. Excellent food, wonderful service and the personal touch that makes the difference. If you’re in Newburgh or anywhere nearby, go here.
Vegetarian options: They had a very tasty gnocchi.
Parking: Their own lot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Barton
Incredible atmosphere, friendly service, delicious and inventive menu. The cucumber martini was the most refreshing cocktail I've ever had and the homemade local pasta was out of this world. Make sure you have room for the bacon and caramel bread pudding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Olivia Barton
We had an absolutely fantastic time at such a cute quant restaurant. Wait staff was extremely attentive, the atmosphere was so cute, but honestly the most amazing part was the food! Absolutely delicious! The crab cakes were out of this world, short ribs were delectable, we cut the filet mignon with a butter knife, the drinks were absolutely out of this world. INCREDIBLE! If I could give this place 10 Stars I would!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cara Mortillo
Just an awesome place! Food was absolutely delicious, the service was stellar, the drinks were incredible. The atmosphere was cozy and beautiful. Definitely worth a visit!!!! You have to try the crab cakes, and the desserts???? Perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Sosa
Great people Great vibes Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custard, Barrel Steak, St Louis Ribs, Creme Brulee, Irish Onion Soup
sj williams
Had lost a bet on our presidential election, and the North Plank Road Tavern was picked by the victorious two. We were given a brief history of the place, but were given an even better meal. We were pleasantly pleased from the beginning to the end. And since it was on my dime, they ordered whole nine yards! Which was quite reasonable as well. Although my candidate didn't win, we all scored an amazing time. Will certainly return to this hidden gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Cheesecake, Grilled Salmon, Creme Brulee
Long Ho
Myself and 6 other friends stopped by for dinner recently. While our server was amazing and the food was great, there was an incident that left a bad taste in our mouth. One of our friends was showing a short video on his phone to another friend of ours. He passed his phone directly to our other friend; the volume was barely audible to the rest of the table (there was also music playing in the background of the dining room) and it was a short clip. We were told by one of the staff (maybe the owner) that it was disruptive. Again, it was barely audible to the rest of the table. This was towards the end of the meal where we had no issues until that point. We were disappointed at how we were singled out and reprimanded. We did bring it up to him later on and he said his wife informed him of the issue - so we were basically ostracized by someone who wasn't there firsthand to see if indeed we were being loud. Disappointing.
Pretty bad food, Tartare was grey, crab salad tasted out of a can and was a small little bit for an appetizer. Beef Wellington was grey and sent back and then brought back mooing and was brought back again and still was horrible. Was told the Wellington is tough to cook, don't put it on your menu If you can't cook it. Irish onion soup tasted like the alcohol wasn't cooked out of it. Pretty bad food, crème brûlée was overcooked. Good wine selections though....
Larry
Great evening the food and staff are just great!! Loved the Caesar salad to the filet and the coffee to finish up a wonderful evening.
Juls P
Amazing food over the top atmosphere need to try this dessert it is off the hook
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Randy
Lovely venue (we sat outside on a lovely day) and all the dishes were delish and the service friendly.
This was a great find when we went to Brotherhood winery. Food and service were fantastic. I wish i lived closer. We will definitely make an excuse to go back!
The smoked meats on the charcuterie board were phenomenal. We loved all of the character and charm as well as the history of the building. The owner Tom and his wife were so kind and attentive. We got dessert to go but they still brought out ice cream for my boyfriend's birthday! When in NY we will definitely be back to visit.
This is a classy place, the kind nearly impossible to find anymore, especially in the bigger cities. Excellent food, wonderful service and the personal touch that makes the difference. If you’re in Newburgh or anywhere nearby, go here.
Vegetarian options: They had a very tasty gnocchi.
Parking: Their own lot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible atmosphere, friendly service, delicious and inventive menu. The cucumber martini was the most refreshing cocktail I've ever had and the homemade local pasta was out of this world. Make sure you have room for the bacon and caramel bread pudding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had an absolutely fantastic time at such a cute quant restaurant. Wait staff was extremely attentive, the atmosphere was so cute, but honestly the most amazing part was the food! Absolutely delicious! The crab cakes were out of this world, short ribs were delectable, we cut the filet mignon with a butter knife, the drinks were absolutely out of this world. INCREDIBLE! If I could give this place 10 Stars I would!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just an awesome place! Food was absolutely delicious, the service was stellar, the drinks were incredible. The atmosphere was cozy and beautiful. Definitely worth a visit!!!! You have to try the crab cakes, and the desserts???? Perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great people
Great vibes
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custard, Barrel Steak, St Louis Ribs, Creme Brulee, Irish Onion Soup
Had lost a bet on our presidential election, and the North Plank Road Tavern was picked by the victorious two. We were given a brief history of the place, but were given an even better meal. We were pleasantly pleased from the beginning to the end. And since it was on my dime, they ordered whole nine yards! Which was quite reasonable as well. Although my candidate didn't win, we all scored an amazing time. Will certainly return to this hidden gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Cheesecake, Grilled Salmon, Creme Brulee
Myself and 6 other friends stopped by for dinner recently. While our server was amazing and the food was great, there was an incident that left a bad taste in our mouth. One of our friends was showing a short video on his phone to another friend of ours. He passed his phone directly to our other friend; the volume was barely audible to the rest of the table (there was also music playing in the background of the dining room) and it was a short clip. We were told by one of the staff (maybe the owner) that it was disruptive. Again, it was barely audible to the rest of the table. This was towards the end of the meal where we had no issues until that point. We were disappointed at how we were singled out and reprimanded. We did bring it up to him later on and he said his wife informed him of the issue - so we were basically ostracized by someone who wasn't there firsthand to see if indeed we were being loud. Disappointing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great old tavern to have a gourmet meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pretty bad food, Tartare was grey, crab salad tasted out of a can and was a small little bit for an appetizer. Beef Wellington was grey and sent back and then brought back mooing and was brought back again and still was horrible. Was told the Wellington is tough to cook, don't put it on your menu If you can't cook it. Irish onion soup tasted like the alcohol wasn't cooked out of it. Pretty bad food, crème brûlée was overcooked. Good wine selections though....
Great evening the food and staff are just great!! Loved the Caesar salad to the filet and the coffee to finish up a wonderful evening.
Amazing food over the top atmosphere need to try this dessert it is off the hook
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lovely venue (we sat outside on a lovely day) and all the dishes were delish and the service friendly.
Great food & nice people.
Parking: Small parking lot behind building.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Charcuterie Board, Creme Brulee, Seared Scallops, Irish Onion Soup
Loading...