Pizza was awesome! Staff was super warm and welcoming as soon as you walk in ! If you are vegan, this is a must stop! Calling all VEGANS!!!! Everything there is amazing. I got the meat handlers's pizza with hot peppers added on it and it was definitely by far. The best vegan pizza I've had. The dough and crust of the pizza was super flavorful and cooked perfectly. The sauce was amazing and of course, all the fixings that went on it. Definitely coming back. Well I actually did walk back to let them know how great their pizza was. Pizza Mia, see you soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Louisa Tucciariello
It's a Pizza shop.I have had much better
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Edward Renninger
Lived in NYC for 16 yrs. Best cheese slice I’ve had in years.
See Ams
Undercooked and unappetizing margarita pizza
Andy P
This pizzeria reminds me of the old school pizzeria you come to know and love as a New Yorker. The owner is hands on with his establishment. And he knows exactly what’s he’s doing! I need to come here more often because their food and pizza is just that good. Today I decided on a chicken Ceasar wrap and I asked the woman that picked up the phone if she recommended it and she said it’s the best and she also recommended the buffalo wrap too! Super friendly and helpful, She was on point! I asked for light sauce and cheese on my wrap, lemme tell you it was the best wrap I’ve had in a long time it was warm and perfect I could not be happier! It’s hard to find good food around here and I hope pizza Mia stays around forever! Quality food for the price! Give them a try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rebekah Nicolle
I am so happy I found some vegan pizza in the area! Such a great pizza as well as amazing vegan garlic knots! It’s been so long since I’ve felt normal since becoming allergic to dairy almost 11 years ago so I’m so glad that this restaurant has made some vegan options so everyone has something to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Albert Schermerhorn
Great variety, owner, service, pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Selection of Pizza Slices
John Disciglio
I recently called this restaurant to ask what slices they had available on the counter as i was looking to purchase a certain one before they sold out of it. The girl who answered the phone told me they did and I gladly offered to pay for the 4 slices over the phone and I would be there to pick it up in 10 minutes.
She very forwardly told me she wouldn’t do that and won’t save slices unless I purchase an entree. Despite the unfriendly attitude, I still decided to give them a chance and order the slices in person. When I arrived I tried to provide some kind advice that they should consider allowing customers to pay for slices over the phone as I do this with almost every pizzeria in the area and the worst case scenario would be I don’t show up and they still get paid. She reverted back to her unfriendly attitude and replied “yeah i won’t save slices for anybody”.
I don’t write this to bash the resturaunt as they serve great pizza but for the owner to consider changing his policy and having a word with the young lady about the way she talks to customers. Previous reviews also mention workers at the counter not being friendly to customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Lady Lovely
Wow this place has really gone down hill. They are not welcoming at all and the owner seems rather snippy. Pizza was soggy in the center. I like how much sauce they use but it would be better with some seasonings
Food: 1
Service: 1
Christina Wemette
Luigi chicken sandwich is the best sandwich I have ever had with balsamic glaze and pesto I wish I would have taken a picture YUM 😋
We've been really happy with the pizzas we've ordered from here, I customize the special I get kind of a lot 😄, and they've always been really, really nice about the changes, and it's always been correct. We've only gotten takeout, but the women we've spoken to on the phone have all been extremely polite, very patient, and conscientious about getting my order right. They also have a great Thursday night takeout deal, on pasta entrees, and we both enjoyed our meals. I had veal marsala, my husband had lasagna. I appreciate that they use high quality salad dressings, as well. Really good Philly steak grinders.
Service: 5
Gustavo Lopez
Best Pizza in Orange County. Trust me, I've tried them all. Flavorful & fresh. Do yourself a favor and order any pizza fresh & thank me later. Best sauce, best cheese, best experience. Hasn't changed the ingredients like everyone else is doing just to save a buck. 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🤞👍🙌👐🤌🤌🤌🤌🤌🤌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evie Hernandez
Visiting the area came here after it being recommended to me. He had rave reviews. I wasn’t greeted with the warmest welcome. As I’ve never been here before I was looking over the menu and boards on the walls. I saw the “instagram famous knot crust pizza,” that sounded so good so I ordered it. The girl at the resister was really rude stating I couldn’t just order it right then and there, that I had to call at least 24 hrs ahead. There was no signage saying this. I ended up just ordering a couple of slices and a pepperoni pinwheel (which ended up being my favorite thing). Would I come again? Not really. But overall the flavors of the food were good.
Pizza was awesome! Staff was super warm and welcoming as soon as you walk in ! If you are vegan, this is a must stop! Calling all VEGANS!!!! Everything there is amazing. I got the meat handlers's pizza with hot peppers added on it and it was definitely by far. The best vegan pizza I've had. The dough and crust of the pizza was super flavorful and cooked perfectly. The sauce was amazing and of course, all the fixings that went on it. Definitely coming back. Well I actually did walk back to let them know how great their pizza was. Pizza Mia, see you soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a Pizza shop.I have had much better
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Lived in NYC for 16 yrs. Best cheese slice I’ve had in years.
Undercooked and unappetizing margarita pizza
This pizzeria reminds me of the old school pizzeria you come to know and love as a New Yorker. The owner is hands on with his establishment. And he knows exactly what’s he’s doing! I need to come here more often because their food and pizza is just that good. Today I decided on a chicken Ceasar wrap and I asked the woman that picked up the phone if she recommended it and she said it’s the best and she also recommended the buffalo wrap too! Super friendly and helpful, She was on point! I asked for light sauce and cheese on my wrap, lemme tell you it was the best wrap I’ve had in a long time it was warm and perfect I could not be happier! It’s hard to find good food around here and I hope pizza Mia stays around forever! Quality food for the price! Give them a try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am so happy I found some vegan pizza in the area! Such a great pizza as well as amazing vegan garlic knots! It’s been so long since I’ve felt normal since becoming allergic to dairy almost 11 years ago so I’m so glad that this restaurant has made some vegan options so everyone has something to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great variety, owner, service, pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Selection of Pizza Slices
I recently called this restaurant to ask what slices they had available on the counter as i was looking to purchase a certain one before they sold out of it. The girl who answered the phone told me they did and I gladly offered to pay for the 4 slices over the phone and I would be there to pick it up in 10 minutes.
She very forwardly told me she wouldn’t do that and won’t save slices unless I purchase an entree. Despite the unfriendly attitude, I still decided to give them a chance and order the slices in person. When I arrived I tried to provide some kind advice that they should consider allowing customers to pay for slices over the phone as I do this with almost every pizzeria in the area and the worst case scenario would be I don’t show up and they still get paid. She reverted back to her unfriendly attitude and replied “yeah i won’t save slices for anybody”.
I don’t write this to bash the resturaunt as they serve great pizza but for the owner to consider changing his policy and having a word with the young lady about the way she talks to customers. Previous reviews also mention workers at the counter not being friendly to customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Wow this place has really gone down hill. They are not welcoming at all and the owner seems rather snippy. Pizza was soggy in the center. I like how much sauce they use but it would be better with some seasonings
Food: 1
Service: 1
Luigi chicken sandwich is the best sandwich I have ever had with balsamic glaze and pesto I wish I would have taken a picture YUM 😋
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Some of the best pizza you can buy in newburgh
Vodka slice with fresh mozzarella was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We've been really happy with the pizzas we've ordered from here, I customize the special I get kind of a lot 😄, and they've always been really, really nice about the changes, and it's always been correct. We've only gotten takeout, but the women we've spoken to on the phone have all been extremely polite, very patient, and conscientious about getting my order right. They also have a great Thursday night takeout deal, on pasta entrees, and we both enjoyed our meals. I had veal marsala, my husband had lasagna. I appreciate that they use high quality salad dressings, as well. Really good Philly steak grinders.
Service: 5
Best Pizza in Orange County. Trust me, I've tried them all. Flavorful & fresh. Do yourself a favor and order any pizza fresh & thank me later. Best sauce, best cheese, best experience. Hasn't changed the ingredients like everyone else is doing just to save a buck. 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🤞👍🙌👐🤌🤌🤌🤌🤌🤌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visiting the area came here after it being recommended to me. He had rave reviews. I wasn’t greeted with the warmest welcome. As I’ve never been here before I was looking over the menu and boards on the walls. I saw the “instagram famous knot crust pizza,” that sounded so good so I ordered it. The girl at the resister was really rude stating I couldn’t just order it right then and there, that I had to call at least 24 hrs ahead. There was no signage saying this. I ended up just ordering a couple of slices and a pepperoni pinwheel (which ended up being my favorite thing). Would I come again? Not really. But overall the flavors of the food were good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Loading...