Best pizza i’ve ever had. A bunch of unique options, fasts service, and very tasty food. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knot Pizza, Slice of Pizza, Bread Knots
Bill Brennan
FANTASTIC pizza! My wife and I haven't stopped talking about it since we had it. We had 4 different slices, and each of them was great. Can't recommend this place enough
CLE2JAX LLC
Super disappointed, all those “voted best” signs should definitely be taken with a grain of salt!!!! I paid almost 40 bucks with tip for a large pepperoni because they had no more slices for 4 people. Paid way more than 4 two slice specials and didn’t get the drinks, just because they toasted dough doesn’t make it worth a damn, glad it’s a hard to find place, I would go to Dominos before this hole again
Alexiz Guerrero
Good place I enjoyed here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Ray Pak
Great classic pizzeria. They have a great selection of vegan pies, though as others have said, it's a bit hard to find. They're just written on a piece of paper. A bit pricey but no more than other vegan pizzas. Would definitely check it out if you're in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chad Zykoff
I recently stayed at a local hotel and happened up this place that had the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. I tried their garlic knots too, must be a NY thing, but they are a must. I’ll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Tu
As a long-time NY Metro resident, I came across this gem. The pizza here is definitely top 3 of all time. Real NY style with the most amazing pepperoni ever. If you live close by, Pizza Mia is a MUST TRY.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Bates
Thank you for going above and beyond to serve my family in short notice. You're special garlic knot crust was the best we've ever had and you quickly became our favorite pizza restaurant. Thank you for being above amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
L M
My 1st time ordering a pie because everyone says its such an amazing pizza. All i ordered was a cheese pie. It couldnt get any easier than that. All i got was a burnt pie with a bunch of red sauce and a sprinkle of cheese....Just horrible!
Erik Stagg
Eat here multiple times every time I am in town. Incredible pizza and service. Get the grandma pizza!!
Hey I gotta tell ya , I LOVE this place ! I get their grandma pizza at least once a week! Amazing sauce! Tasty crust!!! Very friendly staff! Give it a try you won’t be disappointed! 🤌🏻💯
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J. Wilson
Great pizza spot, definitely recommend if you like authentic pizza taste.
Jason Korpics
Was going here every Friday until they handed me this hard as a rock over cooked thing. This pie should have been tossed and remade and most certainly not handed to a regular customer. Will be going somewhere else, quality and consistency are key.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Matt Bjorke
The kind of small pizza shop dreams are made of!! Delicious pizza and several options. I live in Tennessee but was craving “real pizza” from the NY area and I have never been more pleased!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dorothy Bartomeo
My order from Uber Eats just arrived, and I'm SCREAMING because this is so good. 3 kids approve! I have been STUCK in Middletown for over 10 years without having real pizza. They saved my taste buds. They legit have the best pizza outside of NYC, period.
Now for the 411 on what we got;
1 Large Cheese Pizza Pie - please remember I'm telling you that this came from Newburgh to Middletown and was still phenomenal. Their sauce tastes very, very good. It has a crisp herbiness that is refreshing - but not covered in chunks of herbs. It's in the sauce itself. A very proper sauce. Definitely a good blend of cheeses and the right blend. Not greasy, and very crispy crust.
2 Orders of Garlic Knots with sauce - These are the right size, shape, and flavor. They're covered in garlic goodness and they're crisp on the outside, tender on the inside. Their dough is also very tasty.
1 Family Size order of French Fries - I had 3 kids waiting on these fries, and they're all gone. The older 2 grabbed the container after trying them. They took a long ride to get here and we loved them. Good flavor, right texture, and the kids approve!
Best pizza i’ve ever had. A bunch of unique options, fasts service, and very tasty food. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knot Pizza, Slice of Pizza, Bread Knots
FANTASTIC pizza! My wife and I haven't stopped talking about it since we had it. We had 4 different slices, and each of them was great. Can't recommend this place enough
Super disappointed, all those “voted best” signs should definitely be taken with a grain of salt!!!! I paid almost 40 bucks with tip for a large pepperoni because they had no more slices for 4 people. Paid way more than 4 two slice specials and didn’t get the drinks, just because they toasted dough doesn’t make it worth a damn, glad it’s a hard to find place, I would go to Dominos before this hole again
Good place I enjoyed here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Great classic pizzeria. They have a great selection of vegan pies, though as others have said, it's a bit hard to find. They're just written on a piece of paper. A bit pricey but no more than other vegan pizzas. Would definitely check it out if you're in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently stayed at a local hotel and happened up this place that had the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. I tried their garlic knots too, must be a NY thing, but they are a must. I’ll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a long-time NY Metro resident, I came across this gem. The pizza here is definitely top 3 of all time. Real NY style with the most amazing pepperoni ever. If you live close by, Pizza Mia is a MUST TRY.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thank you for going above and beyond to serve my family in short notice. You're special garlic knot crust was the best we've ever had and you quickly became our favorite pizza restaurant. Thank you for being above amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My 1st time ordering a pie because everyone says its such an amazing pizza. All i ordered was a cheese pie. It couldnt get any easier than that. All i got was a burnt pie with a bunch of red sauce and a sprinkle of cheese....Just horrible!
Eat here multiple times every time I am in town. Incredible pizza and service. Get the grandma pizza!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Hey I gotta tell ya , I LOVE this place ! I get their grandma pizza at least once a week! Amazing sauce! Tasty crust!!! Very friendly staff! Give it a try you won’t be disappointed! 🤌🏻💯
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza spot, definitely recommend if you like authentic pizza taste.
Was going here every Friday until they handed me this hard as a rock over cooked thing. This pie should have been tossed and remade and most certainly not handed to a regular customer. Will be going somewhere else, quality and consistency are key.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
The kind of small pizza shop dreams are made of!! Delicious pizza and several options. I live in Tennessee but was craving “real pizza” from the NY area and I have never been more pleased!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My order from Uber Eats just arrived, and I'm SCREAMING because this is so good. 3 kids approve! I have been STUCK in Middletown for over 10 years without having real pizza. They saved my taste buds. They legit have the best pizza outside of NYC, period.
Now for the 411 on what we got;
1 Large Cheese Pizza Pie - please remember I'm telling you that this came from Newburgh to Middletown and was still phenomenal. Their sauce tastes very, very good. It has a crisp herbiness that is refreshing - but not covered in chunks of herbs. It's in the sauce itself. A very proper sauce. Definitely a good blend of cheeses and the right blend. Not greasy, and very crispy crust.
2 Orders of Garlic Knots with sauce - These are the right size, shape, and flavor. They're covered in garlic goodness and they're crisp on the outside, tender on the inside. Their dough is also very tasty.
1 Family Size order of French Fries - I had 3 kids waiting on these fries, and they're all gone. The older 2 grabbed the container after trying them. They took a long ride to get here and we loved them. Good flavor, right texture, and the kids approve!
Overall, we can't wait to order from them again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...