Stella’s Pizzeria

283 Broadway, Newburgh
(845) 795-8608

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dwayne Baxter

They treat people very badly avoid this location

Dwayne

I asked for well done wings and they were grossly undercooked and I asked for another blue cheese and I didn't have the 50 cents for it..they made a big deal about a 50cent blue cheese after I spent almost $20 on wings..the lady came from around the counter and checked my bag to see if I had two..I couldn't believe it..never going back .I suggest you avoid this spot if you can!

Brianna Gray

Pizza tastes great, good crust, and service was nice!

Zachary Ford

Super freindly!

Plum Dubios

The pizza just isn't great tbh
Like pretty bad

T. Eva

I eat here as often as possible I love their speedy service, they're always polite and the food is done correct.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul Vest

A friend of mine said to stop by when get a chance cause the food is delicious. So we did. I had the chicken alfredo with spinach was awesome. The meal was prepared just right.
Make the trip you wont be disappointed!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cameron Marzola

Excellent pizza and very friendly staff! A++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Griselle Davila

I will never go there again! They charge me $9.99 for door dash services when I went in person to pick up my food! Makes no sense! If you got a mystery door dash charge after ordering from them then they charged for services not used! Never again!
Bring the original owners back Please! Smh

Damion Noel

They are so ridiculously slow that if you want more than a single slice you just go someplace else.

Service: 1

Mankynd Wilson

Great place now that new owners took over.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

James Livengood

Delivery driver here please have drivers confirm and complete pickups before they leave the restaurant. It's frustrating to see a large fare for a short trip and be told that multiple people tried to pick it up. The order was clearly stolen by the driver after they picked it up then proceeded to cancel the pickup. It hurts the drivers and the customers who order the food (and a lot of times are not refunded by uber, doordash, etc.) Thank you.

Maddy Gillespie

They even carry the food to the car

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Me Blah

Great pizza ?

George Carbonero

Excelent delicious ? good pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...