The Barile Planet Pizza Family Restaurant is one of the bellissimo restaurants in the country. It's where I fold a lot of pizza boxes by the bunch in a bulk. They come in different sizes, like the 10s, the 12s, the 14s, the 16s for the Neopolitan Pizza, and the 16 ½s for the Sicilian pizza. In fact, the piéce-de-resístance is the 18s for the Neopolitan Pizza, the large size better than any other pizzeria's in America. At the end of every job day, I get a free pizza and 1-2 two-liter sodas on the go. That's how I came to treat the owner Nick Barile like he is my Italian godfather.
James Oetzel II
I've enjoyed Planet Pizza for almost 30 years. First the Monroe location, now from the Newburgh location.
Tanya
Beautiful restaurant but the pizza slices are overpriced and tasteless. Threw the take-out menu away as I won't be back. Absolutely mental charging 9.50 for 2 slices of pepperoni pizza.
Sarah Oomen-Gailie
The pizza guy just stares at you as you eat . The pizza came out burnt and they still served it to us. The taste was not good
Steven
Charges 4% using a credit card/debit. Any place doing this should not be in business. It’s 2025. Nobody carries dirty cash.
Johnetta Simmons
Ordered a large pie w/ sausage and peppers. And a slice of Sicilian. $ 35 Are you kidding me? Delivery gets here., driver doesn't have a pen. Get the pizza box is bent. Grease all over the bag with the siscilian in it.Call about price before I even look at pizza. Get off the phone because I got nowhere. The pizza is cold and undercooked( mind you 45 minutes I'm 2 miles away.) I have been ordering pizza from here for 15 years. Never again!!! Whoever is running this place now needs to be replaced.
Samantha Rodriguez
The pizza and garlic knots were soooooo GOOD!!! And delicious! Great service too.
TRC941
Pizza right from Yonkers! Great pizza, heros, pasta...basically everything on the menu is bomb! Been eating here for about 4 years now and wish I found it sooner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Mozzarella Cheese Sticks, Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, Chicken Cutlet Hero, Chicken Marsala, Wings, Grandma Sicilian Pizza, Beef Patty with Cheese, Tomato & Basil Pizza, Large Pie
Rebecca Kaplan-Fisher
This was a delightful find. We were staying in the area and Google maps led us to this pizza place. So, so delicious ? Was made perfectly to our request and tasted great. Hands down the best cheese steak I've had in years. So very happy with this experience ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pie
Luanne Pross
We order from this place at least once a week I prefer to have my pizza with a little crunch to it not doughy when I asked for that yesterday I got very burnt Sicilian pizza for a change when I received it and took it home opened it to find it was burnt to a crisp I also order the wings well done never happens when I can I always tip the delivery person well as I can and if I don’t I pick it or have some pick it up as the case yesterday I don’t know I am so disappointed how could you not know you burnt the pie did you forget it or was it deliberate won’t be ordering that pie anytime soon not from there anyway. I would be embarrassed to serve this.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Buffalo Chicken with Bleu Cheese Pizza
First time ordering from this pizzeria. Ordered a large pie, meatballs, mozzarella sticks, the chili calamari, and beef patty. Spent $83, wouldn’t order from here again or recommend. The calamari which was almost $20 was so over cooked it was like rubber. The mozzarella stickers were also severely over cooked as the beef patties were too. The pizza was ok but had no sauce on it. The meatballs were very good but not worth being a returning customer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Madera Creative
To whom this may concern, I will Update the ratings once I get an answer:
Why is it your policy to NOT put cheese on your garlic knots? I am always ordering the cheese on the side, then putting them in my oven to achieve the cheesy garlic taste my taste buds yearn for. This is a genuine question…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wings
J J
Hands down the best pizza in the area. The plain slice and buffalo slice are top notch
Tina Williams
First time stopping by this shop. Just so happens I left my wallet at work and only have my phone to use for tap. I order tap my phone receive my pizza and head out the door to eat in my car. My phone tells me my card was declined and the gentleman never said anything and still gave me the pizza. I call my bank get everything straightened out and I go back inside to pay. I asked why he didn’t say anything he said he didn’t want to embarrass me. I will be returning great pizza and spectacular customer service. Thank you.
The Barile Planet Pizza Family Restaurant is one of the bellissimo restaurants in the country. It's where I fold a lot of pizza boxes by the bunch in a bulk. They come in different sizes, like the 10s, the 12s, the 14s, the 16s for the Neopolitan Pizza, and the 16 ½s for the Sicilian pizza. In fact, the piéce-de-resístance is the 18s for the Neopolitan Pizza, the large size better than any other pizzeria's in America. At the end of every job day, I get a free pizza and 1-2 two-liter sodas on the go. That's how I came to treat the owner Nick Barile like he is my Italian godfather.
I've enjoyed Planet Pizza for almost 30 years. First the Monroe location, now from the Newburgh location.
Beautiful restaurant but the pizza slices are overpriced and tasteless. Threw the take-out menu away as I won't be back. Absolutely mental charging 9.50 for 2 slices of pepperoni pizza.
The pizza guy just stares at you as you eat . The pizza came out burnt and they still served it to us. The taste was not good
Charges 4% using a credit card/debit. Any place doing this should not be in business. It’s 2025. Nobody carries dirty cash.
Ordered a large pie w/ sausage and peppers. And a slice of Sicilian. $ 35
Are you kidding me? Delivery gets here., driver doesn't have a pen. Get the pizza box is bent. Grease all over the bag with the siscilian in it.Call about price before I even look at pizza. Get off the phone because I got nowhere. The pizza is cold and undercooked( mind you 45 minutes I'm 2 miles away.) I have been ordering pizza from here for 15 years. Never again!!! Whoever is running this place now needs to be replaced.
The pizza and garlic knots were soooooo GOOD!!! And delicious! Great service too.
Pizza right from Yonkers! Great pizza, heros, pasta...basically everything on the menu is bomb! Been eating here for about 4 years now and wish I found it sooner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Mozzarella Cheese Sticks, Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, Chicken Cutlet Hero, Chicken Marsala, Wings, Grandma Sicilian Pizza, Beef Patty with Cheese, Tomato & Basil Pizza, Large Pie
This was a delightful find. We were staying in the area and Google maps led us to this pizza place.
So, so delicious ?
Was made perfectly to our request and tasted great.
Hands down the best cheese steak I've had in years.
So very happy with this experience ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pie
We order from this place at least once a week I prefer to have my pizza with a little crunch to it not doughy when I asked for that yesterday I got very burnt Sicilian pizza for a change when I received it and took it home opened it to find it was burnt to a crisp I also order the wings well done never happens when I can I always tip the delivery person well as I can and if I don’t I pick it or have some pick it up as the case yesterday I don’t know I am so disappointed how could you not know you burnt the pie did you forget it or was it deliberate won’t be ordering that pie anytime soon not from there anyway. I would be embarrassed to serve this.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Buffalo Chicken with Bleu Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
First time ordering from this pizzeria. Ordered a large pie, meatballs, mozzarella sticks, the chili calamari, and beef patty. Spent $83, wouldn’t order from here again or recommend. The calamari which was almost $20 was so over cooked it was like rubber. The mozzarella stickers were also severely over cooked as the beef patties were too. The pizza was ok but had no sauce on it. The meatballs were very good but not worth being a returning customer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
To whom this may concern, I will
Update the ratings once I get an answer:
Why is it your policy to NOT put cheese on your garlic knots? I am always ordering the cheese on the side, then putting them in my oven to achieve the cheesy garlic taste my taste buds yearn for. This is a genuine question…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wings
Hands down the best pizza in the area. The plain slice and buffalo slice are top notch
First time stopping by this shop. Just so happens I left my wallet at work and only have my phone to use for tap. I order tap my phone receive my pizza and head out the door to eat in my car. My phone tells me my card was declined and the gentleman never said anything and still gave me the pizza. I call my bank get everything straightened out and I go back inside to pay. I asked why he didn’t say anything he said he didn’t want to embarrass me. I will be returning great pizza and spectacular customer service. Thank you.
Loading...