Pizza right from Yonkers! Great pizza, heros, pasta...basically everything on the menu is bomb! Been eating here for about 4 years now and wish I found it sooner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Mozzarella Cheese Sticks, Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, Chicken Cutlet Hero, Chicken Marsala, Wings, Grandma Sicilian Pizza, Beef Patty with Cheese, Tomato & Basil Pizza, Large Pie
Rebecca Kaplan-Fisher
This was a delightful find. We were staying in the area and Google maps led us to this pizza place. So, so delicious ? Was made perfectly to our request and tasted great. Hands down the best cheese steak I've had in years. So very happy with this experience ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pie
Luanne Pross
We order from this place at least once a week I prefer to have my pizza with a little crunch to it not doughy when I asked for that yesterday I got very burnt Sicilian pizza for a change when I received it and took it home opened it to find it was burnt to a crisp I also order the wings well done never happens when I can I always tip the delivery person well as I can and if I don’t I pick it or have some pick it up as the case yesterday I don’t know I am so disappointed how could you not know you burnt the pie did you forget it or was it deliberate won’t be ordering that pie anytime soon not from there anyway. I would be embarrassed to serve this.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Buffalo Chicken with Bleu Cheese Pizza
Greenlight Express Corp.
Excellent service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jen Schupp
First time ordering from this pizzeria. Ordered a large pie, meatballs, mozzarella sticks, the chili calamari, and beef patty. Spent $83, wouldn’t order from here again or recommend. The calamari which was almost $20 was so over cooked it was like rubber. The mozzarella stickers were also severely over cooked as the beef patties were too. The pizza was ok but had no sauce on it. The meatballs were very good but not worth being a returning customer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Madera Creative
To whom this may concern, I will Update the ratings once I get an answer:
Why is it your policy to NOT put cheese on your garlic knots? I am always ordering the cheese on the side, then putting them in my oven to achieve the cheesy garlic taste my taste buds yearn for. This is a genuine question…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wings
J J
Hands down the best pizza in the area. The plain slice and buffalo slice are top notch
Tina Williams
First time stopping by this shop. Just so happens I left my wallet at work and only have my phone to use for tap. I order tap my phone receive my pizza and head out the door to eat in my car. My phone tells me my card was declined and the gentleman never said anything and still gave me the pizza. I call my bank get everything straightened out and I go back inside to pay. I asked why he didn’t say anything he said he didn’t want to embarrass me. I will be returning great pizza and spectacular customer service. Thank you.
Phasia Crocker
How do you serve food so horrible? Lived around the street for the longest and always pass by when I go to the dollar store. I finally tried it and this screams disappointment. You have to do better, this is the meatball you are serving people that is worst than high school lunch. When you cut into the meatball, it’s hard and the taste is horrible, not even heat could make it better. For the price, you guys have to provide better food. You’ve definitely lost a perspective customer. I wish the food was as good as the service.
The Caesar salad taste disgusting and the pizza is subpar. I don’t recommend.
Alex Berwick
I have a sever dairy allergy, I struggle with eating any Italian food in general. I expressed to them that I would like to have pizza, they were open with me and worked with me to adjust my meal to what i wanted. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE try the salad pizza with marinara sauce (because the regular pizza sauce has dairy). Also add the grilled chicken! there is something different about the grilled chicken there, the flavor is delicious. This order is my go to and I look forward to this meal every week!
Really solid pizza spot in Newburgh. No complaints, their garlic knots are huge and tasty. Also like the vegetable Stromboli
William Clark
So today I went inside to get 2 slices of pizza and this is my usual and the man with the baldness hair pushed to front charged me extra 50 cent more then before then charged me for a small cup of blue cheese which I always get and over charged me for a soda. And that was hurtful since I come regular and I will never go again. He was nasty as well when I said forget it sir I’m not paying all that extra for two slices good luck ! Don’t eat there thanks
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Ron Goode
Super impressed. I ordered via GrubHub and the store promptly called me to tell me that the app had overcharged me and that they’d reduce the price on my order but that I would still be getting the same amount of toppings. I was impressed that someone actually took the time and effort to fix something that would cost them money, but they did.Then I got the pizza and I was shocked at how heavy it was. most pizzas are pretty small these days and rather thin and I end up being unsatisfied. But this pizza felt like it weighed 5 pounds. The toppings were plentiful, and the cheese was nice and stretchy like in the commercials. The pizza was very good and I’ll have plenty of leftovers.Well worth the price and I would definitely order again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Andrew D.
They are located in the Mid Valley Mall, 39 North Plank road Newburgh NY, 12550.I always get the traditional Stromboli, which is a meal in itself. I also order the chicken Straciatella soup. It is loaded with noodles and spinach and egg.The staff is nice and welcoming.There room for handicap seating and parking in the parking lot.
Wheelchair accessibility: They are handicap accessible and has handicap parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Felix Reyes
Best Old School Pizza in the Hudson valley no question about it enough said ?
Parking: 200+
Kid-friendliness: Great food for the kids especially the picky ones LOL
Pizza right from Yonkers! Great pizza, heros, pasta...basically everything on the menu is bomb! Been eating here for about 4 years now and wish I found it sooner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Mozzarella Cheese Sticks, Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, Chicken Cutlet Hero, Chicken Marsala, Wings, Grandma Sicilian Pizza, Beef Patty with Cheese, Tomato & Basil Pizza, Large Pie
This was a delightful find. We were staying in the area and Google maps led us to this pizza place.
So, so delicious ?
Was made perfectly to our request and tasted great.
Hands down the best cheese steak I've had in years.
So very happy with this experience ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pie
We order from this place at least once a week I prefer to have my pizza with a little crunch to it not doughy when I asked for that yesterday I got very burnt Sicilian pizza for a change when I received it and took it home opened it to find it was burnt to a crisp I also order the wings well done never happens when I can I always tip the delivery person well as I can and if I don’t I pick it or have some pick it up as the case yesterday I don’t know I am so disappointed how could you not know you burnt the pie did you forget it or was it deliberate won’t be ordering that pie anytime soon not from there anyway. I would be embarrassed to serve this.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Buffalo Chicken with Bleu Cheese Pizza
Excellent service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
First time ordering from this pizzeria. Ordered a large pie, meatballs, mozzarella sticks, the chili calamari, and beef patty. Spent $83, wouldn’t order from here again or recommend. The calamari which was almost $20 was so over cooked it was like rubber. The mozzarella stickers were also severely over cooked as the beef patties were too. The pizza was ok but had no sauce on it. The meatballs were very good but not worth being a returning customer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
To whom this may concern, I will
Update the ratings once I get an answer:
Why is it your policy to NOT put cheese on your garlic knots? I am always ordering the cheese on the side, then putting them in my oven to achieve the cheesy garlic taste my taste buds yearn for. This is a genuine question…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wings
Hands down the best pizza in the area. The plain slice and buffalo slice are top notch
First time stopping by this shop. Just so happens I left my wallet at work and only have my phone to use for tap. I order tap my phone receive my pizza and head out the door to eat in my car. My phone tells me my card was declined and the gentleman never said anything and still gave me the pizza. I call my bank get everything straightened out and I go back inside to pay. I asked why he didn’t say anything he said he didn’t want to embarrass me. I will be returning great pizza and spectacular customer service. Thank you.
How do you serve food so horrible? Lived around the street for the longest and always pass by when I go to the dollar store. I finally tried it and this screams disappointment. You have to do better, this is the meatball you are serving people that is worst than high school lunch. When you cut into the meatball, it’s hard and the taste is horrible, not even heat could make it better. For the price, you guys have to provide better food. You’ve definitely lost a perspective customer. I wish the food was as good as the service.
The Caesar salad taste disgusting and the pizza is subpar. I don’t recommend.
I have a sever dairy allergy, I struggle with eating any Italian food in general. I expressed to them that I would like to have pizza, they were open with me and worked with me to adjust my meal to what i wanted. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE try the salad pizza with marinara sauce (because the regular pizza sauce has dairy). Also add the grilled chicken! there is something different about the grilled chicken there, the flavor is delicious. This order is my go to and I look forward to this meal every week!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Really solid pizza spot in Newburgh. No complaints, their garlic knots are huge and tasty. Also like the vegetable Stromboli
So today I went inside to get 2 slices of pizza and this is my usual and the man with the baldness hair pushed to front charged me extra 50 cent more then before then charged me for a small cup of blue cheese which I always get and over charged me for a soda. And that was hurtful since I come regular and I will never go again. He was nasty as well when I said forget it sir I’m not paying all that extra for two slices good luck ! Don’t eat there thanks
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Super impressed. I ordered via GrubHub and the store promptly called me to tell me that the app had overcharged me and that they’d reduce the price on my order but that I would still be getting the same amount of toppings. I was impressed that someone actually took the time and effort to fix something that would cost them money, but they did.Then I got the pizza and I was shocked at how heavy it was. most pizzas are pretty small these days and rather thin and I end up being unsatisfied. But this pizza felt like it weighed 5 pounds. The toppings were plentiful, and the cheese was nice and stretchy like in the commercials. The pizza was very good and I’ll have plenty of leftovers.Well worth the price and I would definitely order again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
They are located in the Mid Valley Mall, 39 North Plank road Newburgh NY, 12550.I always get the traditional Stromboli, which is a meal in itself. I also order the chicken Straciatella soup. It is loaded with noodles and spinach and egg.The staff is nice and welcoming.There room for handicap seating and parking in the parking lot.
Wheelchair accessibility: They are handicap accessible and has handicap parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Old School Pizza in the Hudson valley no question about it enough said ?
Parking: 200+
Kid-friendliness: Great food for the kids especially the picky ones LOL
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Full Monti Hero, Baked Rigatoni Bolognese, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice, Garlic Bread, Meatballs, Chicken Marsala, Buffalo Wings
Loading...