Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant
2885 Main St, Newfane
(716) 778-9069
Customers' Favorites
Baked Ziti with Meatball
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Spinach Bread Formaggio
Garlic Toast Supreme
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmesan
Meatball Ponzone
Pizza Sandwich
Steak Ponzone
Menu
Photos
+43 photos
+42 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Pizza is phenomenal! Went outside my comfort zone tonight and tried the baked haddock...it was microwaved fish, rubbery, and hard. It was stuck on the plate and so hot it needed to sit 10+ minutes before it was edible. I think they ultimately never made my order as my husband got a pizza and they brought his out at least 10 minutes before mine. 😳 You're safe if you stick with Pizza! 🍕
I always forget about going to Newfane when we eat out.
I had forgotten how excellent this restaurant is!
I had Seafood Alfredo and my husband had broiled butter haddock.
They were both cooked to perfection!
That's coming from an Alfredo SNOB. 😂
The bread served with dinner was astounding as well..
Prices are extremely reasonable and the food was great. Our server was also excellent.
I highly recommend that...
I had forgotten how excellent this restaurant is!
I had Seafood Alfredo and my husband had broiled butter haddock.
They were both cooked to perfection!
That's coming from an Alfredo SNOB. 😂
The bread served with dinner was astounding as well..
Prices are extremely reasonable and the food was great. Our server was also excellent.
I highly recommend that...
We brought our grandchildren here after going to Olcott Carousel Park. It was the nicest restaurant, a wonderful waitress, brought coloring books and suggested a small pizza for them! We loved the french fries, home made! The perfect end to our outing! Thank you!
You May Also Like
Scruples - 2875 Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill
The Brookside - 2990 Lockport Olcott Rd
![]()
American, Wraps, Burgers