Wilson's Pizza Shop
2730 Main St, Newfane
(716) 778-9651
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I placed a larger order for my bridal party, Wilson's could not have made a better impression!! The best/ proper chicken finger pizza, and the stinger practically vanished. 10/10 remains the most consistent pizza in town.. .If I could only get it shipped.... leftovers became breakfast, lunch, and late night snacking too! Thankful for such a wonderful addition to our weekend.
Superb pizzas, both deep dish and thin crust! Had both. Crusts were perfect! We normally don’t eat the crust but it was so delicious, we ate it all. Thin crust is firm, so can be picked up without sagging at all. Toppings were first class. Cozy atmosphere, super-friendly dudes, everything from scratch, will customize pizzas. Love this place and will be our go-to pizza source going forward. Delicious, fresh tiramisu as well. Don’t miss this gem!!
I came here to say I wish I could leave them unlimited reviews and I get to leave a new one bc this is a new email. I was very late for my order. And my pizza is still so hot and so fresh. Seriously love Wilson’s. Thanks for always keeping our family fed. 🥰 prob eat too much pizza but oh well. It’s too good not to. lol 😂 love Wilson’s forever the best pizza around.
You May Also Like
Open Air Bar - 2720 Maple Ave
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar, Beer Bar
Food King Chinese Restaurant - 2764 Main St
![]()
Chinese, Asian, Cantonese, Vegetarian