Made by Lilis bake shop
1160 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon
(631) 392-1500
Customers' Favorites
Dulce De Leche Cheesecake on a Stick
Nutella Stuffed Cookie Dough
Red Velvet Cake in a Jar
Creme Brulee- In Ramekin
Peanut Butter Explosion
Rainbow Cookie Cupcake
Cheesecake Party Pack
Espresso Creme Brulee
Red Velvet Cheesecake
S'Mores Lava Cookie
Fall treats 🍃
family size banana pudding tub
Flavor of the month
S'mores lava cookie
2 layers of s'mores cookieS stuffed with marshmallows graham crackers and Hershey kisses chocolate chips baked to perfection and drizzled with Hershey chocolate sauce
Turtle pumpkin pie cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in toasted pecans drizzled with Caramel then sprinkled with cinnamon and nutmeg
S'mores cookie
A giant 5oz of summer deliciousness
Peanut butter explosion
Layered chocolate genoise, rich & velvety peanut butter mousse, topped with brownie bits, peanut butter chips, drizzled in fudge
English Toffee Cheesecake
Dulce de leche York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in Heath english toffee bites drizzled with Caramel salted caramel and sprinkled with Sea salt
Nutella stuffed cookie dough
2 layers of gooey and buttery cookie dough stuffed with Generous amount off Nutella and loaded with Hershey chocolate kisses
Individual size Banana pudding
New York Style cheesecake creations
Cheesecake party pack
A dozen of our top seller cheesecake slices
Dulce De Leche Cheesecake
A cookie crust holds a velvety dulce de leche cheesecake, topped with dulce de leche mousse and chocolate shavings
Lili's cheesecake
A layer of chocolate chip brownie with a layer of smooth cheesecake topped with whole Oreo and covered with chocolate cookie dough
Marble ganache cheesecake slice
Plain cheesecake slice
Our famous New York cheesecake
Rainbow slice
Our famous cheesecake baked with rainbow sprinkles 🌈
Oreo cheesecake slice
Our famous cheesecake baked with Oreo chunks
Marble ganache cheesecake
Red velvet cheesecake
Triple chocolate cheesecake
Coconut cheesecake slice
Strawberry cheesecake
The dirty cheesecake 🤯 (cheesecake on a stick)
Cotton candy cheesecake
NY style cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milkl chocolate rolled in Cotton candy rock bites covered with cotton candy and drizzled with white chocolate
Fruity Pebbles cheesecake
NY style cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered with fruity pebbles rainbow sprinkles and drizzled with sweet condensed milk
The exotic cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in shredded coconut and drizzled with Brazilian condensed milk
snickers bar cheesecake
Dulce de leche York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered in snickers bites and drizzled with our homemade salted caramel sauce
PB and jelly time cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered with creamy peanut butter and homemade strawberry jam
Allergy shot cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered with crushed hazelnut and drizzled with Nutella
Oreo dream cheesecake
New York oreo cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered with crushed Oreo drizzled with home made chocolate and white chocolate sauce
Campfire cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in graham crackers crumbs and covered with homemade torched marshmallows and drizzled with Hershey chocolate syrup
Reese's cup cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in crushed Reese's peanut butter pieces and drizzled with Reese's peanut butter sauce
Triple chocolate cheesecake
Marble ganache New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate topped with brownie bites rolled in chocolate sprinkles and drizzled with chocolate sauce
Raspberry madness cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in white chocolate chips topped with homemade raspberry jam and drizzled with White chocolate sauce
Funfetti birthday cheesecake
Funfetti New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in rainbow sprinkles and drizzled with chocolate sauce
dulce de leche cheesecake
Dulce de leche York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate drizzled with caramel and salted caramel sauce sprinkled with Sea salt
peanut butter finger cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled into crushed Butterfinger and nutter butter crackers cookies then drizzled with creamy peanut butter
Pecan pie cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in pecan drizzled with Caramel and salted caramel and sprinkled with cinnamon
Oreo Nutella
New York Oreo cheesecake dipped Ghirardelli milk chocolate and rolled in oreo crumbs drizzled with Nutella and topped with oero
PB and Nutella cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate drizzled with peanut butter sauce and Nutella sprinkled with Sea salt
English toffee cheesecake
Dulce de leche York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in Heath english toffee bites drizzled with Caramel salted caramel and sprinkled with Sea salt
Turtle pumpkin cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in toasted pecans drizzled with Caramel then sprinkled with cinnamon and nutmeg
ice cream topper
The dirty brownie creation
English toffee brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in Heath english toffee bites drizzled with Caramel salted caramel and sprinkled with Sea salt
PB Nutella brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate drizzled with peanut butter sauce and Nutella sprinkled with Sea salt
Oreo Nutella brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped Ghirardelli milk chocolate and rolled in oreo crumbs drizzled with Nutella and topped with oero
Peanut butter finger brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled into crushed Butterfinger and nutter butter crackers cookies then drizzled with creamy peanut butter
Dulce de leche brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate drizzled with caramel and salted caramel sauce sprinkled with Sea salt
Reese's cup brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in crushed Reese's peanut butter pieces and drizzled with Reese's peanut butter sauce
Campfire brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in graham crackers crumbs and covered with homemade torched marshmallows and drizzled with Hershey chocolate syrup
Oreo dream brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered with crushed Oreo drizzled with home made chocolate and white chocolate sauce
Allergy shot brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered with crushed hazelnut and drizzled with Nutella
Snickers bar brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered in snickers bites and drizzled with our homemade salted caramel sauce
The exotic brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in shredded coconut and drizzled with Brazilian condensed milk
Lili's stuffed cookie creation
Reese's Peanut butter lava overload
2 layers of PB chocolate chip cookies stuffed with generous amount of creamy peanut baked to perfection drizzled with PB sauce and sprinkled with crushed peanuts
Cheesecake stuffed red velvet lava cookie
2 layers of white chocolate loaded red velvet cookies stuffed with our famous NY cheesecake and more white chocolate chips and drizzled with white chocolate sauce
S'mores lava cookie
2 layers of s'mores cookie stuffed with marshmallows graham crackers and Hershey kisses chocolate chips baked to perfection and drizzled with Hershey chocolate sauce
Nutella stuffed cookie dough
2 layers of gooey and buttery cookie dough stuffed with Generous amount off Nutella and loaded with Hershey chocolate kisses
Giant Cookies
Oatmeal chocolate chip Cookie
Snickerdoodle Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Salted Caramel Cookie
NY famous black and white cookie
Red velvet cookie
Reese's PB cookie
white chocolate macadamia cookie
Bars & Squares
Lili's bar
Chocolate chip cookie dough crust topped with whole Oreo and covered with Gooey chocolate chip brownies
Sea salt Chocolate chip Fudge Brownie
Gooey Chocolate Chip Bar
Oreo brownie cheesecake bar
Chocolate chip Brownie crust topped with whole Oreos and covered with smooth cheesecake
Brookie bar
A layer of chocolate chip cookie dough topped with a layer of chocolate chip brownie and a whole lot it chocolate chips
Reese's peanut butter bar
Chocolate chip brownie wiped with Reese's peanut sauce mixed and topped with Reese's peanut pieces
Funfetti cheesecake brownie
Loaded brownie
Loaded with Oreo pieces cookie dough and marshmallows
Gooey Reese's bar
Gluten free
Caramel crunch cake GF
A flourless chocolate almond cake studded with crunchy chopped hazelnuts, topped with creamy caramel and hazelnuts drizzled with chocolate
GLUTEN FREE
Mini red velvet cake GF
Alternating layers of gluten free red hued chocolate sponge cake and cream cheese icing topped with gluten free cake crumbs
Gluten Free
Traditional Cupcakes
A Dozen Traditional Cupcakes
If you would like multiples of a certain flavor and/or combination, please indicate the quantity of each in the Special Instructions.
Van or Choc cupcake
Classic vanilla cake with your choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream.
Choc or Van
Rich chocolate cake with your choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream.
Red Velvet Cupcake
A delicious red velvet cake with a hint of cocoa, frosted with our signature cream cheese frosting.
Lemon Cupcake
Classic lemon cake with a tangy lemon frosting.
Vanilla Birthday Cake
Vanilla cake batter with rainbow sprinkles topped with vanilla buttercream
Assorted mini cupcakes
a dozen of our classic mini cupcakes (NUT FREE)
great for sharing or school birthday parties
Signature glass collection
Creme brulee & berries
Feel the summer breeze with a layer of raspberry sauce topped with creamy custard and decorated with mixed berries coated in caramel
Coppa 3 Chocolates
Delicious combination of silky dark, milk and white chocolate creams with a layer of hazelnut crunch, presented in an elegant glass
Espresso Creme Brulee
Creamy custard flavored with espresso, topped with caramelized sugar
Creme Brulee- In Ramekin
A creamy custard presented in a traditional ceramic ramekin
Tiramisu Cup
Coffee and Zabaione cream on a layer of sponge cake soaked in espresso, dusted with cocoa powder.
Macaroons
French Macaroons Per Piece
Fresh macarons. Salted caramel, pistachio, lemon, chocolate, vanilla, coconut, autumn blossom, blueberry, cake batter, cappuccino, chocolate mint, cookie dough, dulce de leche, green tea, lavender, marshmallow, Nutella, Oreo, passion fruit, pumpkin, raspberry, red velvet, rose water, strawberry, strawberry shortcake and tiramisu.
Half Dozen French Macaroons
Fresh macarons. Salted caramel, pistachio, lemon, chocolate, vanilla, coconut, autumn blossom, blueberry, cake batter, cappuccino, chocolate mint, cookie dough, dulce de leche, green tea, lavender, marshmallow, Nutella, Oreo, passion fruit, pumpkin, raspberry, red velvet, rose water, strawberry, strawberry shortcake and tiramisu.
1 Dozen French Macaroons
Fresh macarons. Salted caramel, pistachio, lemon, chocolate, vanilla, coconut, autumn blossom, blueberry, cake batter, cappuccino, chocolate mint, cookie dough, dulce de leche, green tea, lavender, marshmallow, Nutella, Oreo, passion fruit, pumpkin, raspberry, red velvet, rose water, strawberry, strawberry shortcake and tiramisu.
Cake by Slice
Vanilla Cake Slice
Chocolate Cake Slice
Red Velvet Cake Slice
Specialty Cupcakes
A Dozen Specialty Cupcakes
If you would like multiples of a certain flavor and/or combination, please indicate the quantity of each in the Special Instructions.
Salted Caramel Cupcake
Vanilla cake with vanilla caramel swirled buttercream, sprinkled with sea salt.
Cookies N Cream Cupcake
Vanilla or chocolate cake stuffed with a whole oreo topped with an oreo crumb buttercream.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake filled with edible cookie dough topped with vanilla Buttercream and sprinkled with cookie crumbs
Chocolate Buttercream Chocolate Cupcake
Vanilla Buttercream Chocolate Cupcake
Spiced Carrot Cupcake
Spicy Carrot cake topped with spicy cream cheese frosting with hint of cinnamon and nutmeg
Reese's Peanut Butter Cupcake
Dark chocolate cake with Reese's peanut butter cups and peanut butter frosting.
Strawberry cupcake
Strawberry cake with fresh pieces of strawberries stuffed with strawberry jam and topped with white chocolate cream cheese icing
Hazelnut Nutella cupcake
Snickers bar cupcake
Cinnamon toast crunch cupcake
Edible cookie dough
Edible chocolate chip cookie dough
10oz cup
Seasonal pies 🥧
Pumpkin pie slice
Pecan pie slice
10" Pecan pie
Chocolate pecan pie
10" apple pie
10" strawberry Rhubarb pie
10" Lemon meringue pie
10" Mixed berries pie
10" Apply pie
Mason Jar Creation
Birthday Cake in a Jar
Salted Caramel Cake in a Jar
Chocolate Chocolate Cake in a Jar
Reese's PB Cake in a Jar
Oreo Cookies and Cream in a Jar
Cookie Monster Jar
Red velvet cake in a jar
Banana Pudding
Classic Banana pudding
Family size banana pudding tub
Photos
+59 photos
+58 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
First time visiting. For the price, service should be more store-friendly (better presentation/packaging). Pumpkin cheesecake was good—light and tasty—but could be more flavorful, like the macaroons. Macaroons were good, but one is pricey, and a slice of cake with no coffee included feels steep.
November 2025
super cute interior and the staff was really nice ! we couldn't order the s'mores cookie because the marshmallow had gelatin but they helpfully recommended the campfire cheesecake instead which had marshmallow fluff (no gelatin)
November 2025
You May Also Like
Bubble Tea Culture - 1161 Deer Park Ave
![]()
Bubble Tea
Pizzaiola - 1162 Deer Pk Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
The cheesecake is creamy, decadent, and loaded with flavor, topped with just the right amount of crunch and drizzle to take it over the top. You can tell it’s made with care and quality ingredients — every bite is pure indulgence.
If...