Cino's Hot Bagels

Customer service was great! Food was just as excellent. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I typically drive into farmingdale to get my bagels but I figured I would try this place as it's right by my house. I can only speak on the bagels and cream cheese as that's all I've ordered. bagels are extra fluffy and when I toast them at home they are awesome! slightly crisp outside and incredibly soft fluffy inside. i love the vegetable cream cheese. personally I don't like giant chunks of vegtable in my vegetable CC. But here, the vegetables are minced up very small so I get the awesome taste of veg CC without the giant chunks like other places. for now this is my go to spot for bagels. I do wish they threw in a bagel or 2 free when you buy a dozen like some other places do as it's always much appreciated. overall very satisfied so far.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

I’ve never had a bagel that’s not extremely fresh and soft from here every single time the food is great and there’s never line

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everything Egg Bagel Breakfast Sandwich with Salt Pepper and Ketchup

Love this place!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I recently visited Cino's Hot Bagels while out of town, and my experience exceeded all expectations. My uncle, who delivers for Uber Eats, mentioned that this place is the local favorite for bagels, and he was absolutely right!

From the moment I walked in, I was met with the warmest welcome. The lady at the counter was incredibly kind and patient as I struggled to decide what to order. She noticed my uncertainty and graciously offered suggestions that turned out to be perfect. I ended up purchasing two dozen bagels, each more delicious than the last, and treated myself to a bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel. It was absolutely phenomenal!

The bagels are fresh, flavorful, and everything you could hope for. The service, however, is what truly sets Cino's Hot Bagels apart. The staff's attentiveness and kindness made my visit memorable. My only regret is not having cash on hand to leave a well-deserved tip, as tipping is not possible on the receipt. I am definitely planning to return, not only for the amazing bagels but also to properly thank the wonderful staff.

Cino's Hot Bagels is a gem, and I can't recommend it enough!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The... best... bagels... ever. I'd shipped some to California, I've brought dozens with me to Texas and I'm bringing more on my next trip to California. Everyone I bring these to are SO GRATEFUL. Last week it was my turn to bring bagels to the faculty breakfast and no lie, usually we have leftovers but with Cino's there wasn't so much as a crumb left by lunchtime.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice comfy bagel store with great

Food: 5

Service: 5

The bagels are made with real fresh ingredients, are soft and light, the owner knows most of the customers by name and he supports the Plainedge community. We have been loyal customers for years and every time I try somewhere else I am reminded why I love this place (and their bagels) so much.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Egg sandwiches and the best bagels 🥯

First off way over priced. Small portions and the drink machines are cleaned about once every 6 months which means caked on sour milk in the dispensers. They use tap water for the iced teas and lemonades. Kitchen was filthy, floors and refrigerator in the back we’re filthy. They freeze the left over bagels over night and would mix old tuna into the new tuna salad. It’s disgusting. The Owner is very high strung and agitated very often, could be lack of sleep or something else more personal but even at that you can’t take it out on you’re employees or customers. Anthony is very hot tempered and needs to realize he runs a small little deli that most of the town passes by anyway and isn’t a brain surgeon or building rockets for space x. Get a grip and stop using people to do work you’re too lazy to do.

Clean! People are friendly, food is fresh. Bacon like mom makes it.

Food is great and customer service is always on point

Excellent little bagel store. Very nice people working there, apple turnovers look really good. I like that u can make your own coffee.

This place is my family’s second home! It kind of reminds me of the show “cheers” everytime we walk in there! My father, daughter and I walk in and they smile and call us by name there! Ant (Anthony) Lilly TJ Stephanie and Omar are always there with big happy smiles (even at 6:00 AM LOL) our “norms” of what we want are always ready... it’s just like home there! I would recommend Cinos to EVERYONE AND THEIR FAMILIES! GREAT FOOD, FAMILY ENVIRONMENT and GREAT PRICES!! We couldn’t and would never go anywhere else!!! Stop by and see them, they’ll treat you like they’ve been ur friends for years!!! LOVE CINOS... Love u guys, thank you for all u do for us!!

This place is my family’s second home! It kind of reminds me of the show “cheers” everytime we walk in there! My father, daughter and I walk in and they smile and call us by name there! Ant (Anthony) Lilly TJ Stephanie and Omar are always there with big happy smiles (even at 6:00 AM LOL) our “norms” of what we want are always ready... it’s just like home there! I would recommend Cinos to EVERYONE AND THEIR FAMILIES! GREAT FOOD, FAMILY ENVIRONMENT and GREAT PRICES!! We couldn’t and would never go anywhere else!!! Stop by and see them, they’ll treat you like they’ve been ur friends for years!!! LOVE CINOS... Love u guys, thank you for all u do for us!!