Good experience & food but we felt we were being rushed. It was my husband's birthday and we were celebrating! But, loved the live music!
Andrew
Incredible dining experience. I have been going there for years. Waited for my friends to arrive at the bar, bartender was so friendly and hard working. The entire waiting staff was always there to serve our every need. The food was 10/10 as always. Also incredible live music experience, really set a welcoming mood that enhanced the experience for us and creating a night for great memories.
donna
Dined at restaurant last night for the second time. Ordered the halibut special. I was appalled at the size of the portion-I couldn't help but think where is the rest of my halibut? Bill arrives and I see 49.95-more appalling and ridiculous. We are new to the area and thought we had found a spot to dine regularly however after this experience we will not be back. You should know what your kitchen is turning out.
Judi
Pulcinella in Massapequa is an absolute gem! From start to finish, every dish was perfection. The branzino, served table-side, was like butter—delicate, flavorful, and melt-in-your-mouth good. The warm figs with goat cheese were a beautiful balance of sweet and savory, the burrata with paper-thin tomatoes and shrimp was fresh and elegant, and the pistachio gelato was the perfect finish—creamy, rich, and unforgettable. The owner Ciro was on site, ensuring everything ran seamlessly, and the staff's attention to every detail was truly impeccable. A five-star experience in every way!
Annie
Pulcinella never disappoints. Food is always great, ambiance is lovely, and the noise level is perfect for conversation. Service is perfection.
Luciana
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ An Unforgettable Experience at Pulcinella! From the moment we arrived, we were warmly welcomed by Jeremias, whose impeccable, attentive, and friendly service truly made our visit special. We enjoyed two special dishes that completely won us over: the seafood salad and capeline cake, along with delicious garlic shrimp and succulent lamb chops, all perfectly prepared. To accompany, an ice-cold beer just the way we love it, and expertly crafted drinks that rounded out the evening beautifully. The Pulcinella ambiance is absolutely stunning—like a scene straight out of a movie—creating the perfect setting for any special occasion. To top it all off, the spumoni and cannoli, paired with a chilled limoncello, brilliantly crowned the end of our meal. Highly recommend for anyone seeking an exquisite combination of outstanding food, top-notch service, and a charming atmosphere!
Cedric
Perfect date night spot. Ambiance was amazing, medium/low lighting, intimate table settings. Noise was moderate to low...only other family's laughing and having a great time. Our server was new but he was great! Food was amazing and always consistent. I got the Shrimp Oreganata with gnocchi and I just want to drink that sauce! My husband got chicken parm and loved it. We will be going back this weekend!
Lisa
One of my favorite places to dine. This time I was a little disappointed. Food was just ok. Not level I was used to there. Also seemed like everyone was rushing around a bit chaotic but they were pleasant.
Henry
Have been here many times especially if we're in the area. Consistently great. Always fabulous specials. In fact I rarely order off the menu because the specials are so spectacular. Our server Jeremiah filleted my Branzino like a surgeon who graduated first in his class. Only disappointed they were out of stuffed zucchini flowers. I guess we'll have to go back
Mary
Clams casino had so much red pepper not enough clams , was only 1 Sauvignon Blanc glass to choose from , stuffed flounder was covered with reddish breadcrumbs / ruined meal
Good food. Slow service. Refused to put bread Lin table until we ordered despite putting an oil/herb mix down that's used for bread. 45 minutes to get breaf
Nicole
First time dining here on Fathers Day. Was happy to have gotten a reservation on such short notice. Food was delicious. Great atmosphere. Will definitely be back!
Anthony
Excellent as always. Highly recommended. Antonio, Rudy and Jeremiah are at the top of their game. Highly recommend dining here.
Marjorie
Delicious food and very attentive service- the short ribs and stuffed veal chop are excellent!
Maria
Fabulous!! The food the service, everything was just amazing. We've been there twice and it will be a pleasure to be back!
Good experience & food but we felt we were being rushed. It was my husband's birthday and we were celebrating! But, loved the live music!
Incredible dining experience. I have been going there for years. Waited for my friends to arrive at the bar, bartender was so friendly and hard working. The entire waiting staff was always there to serve our every need. The food was 10/10 as always. Also incredible live music experience, really set a welcoming mood that enhanced the experience for us and creating a night for great memories.
Dined at restaurant last night for the second time. Ordered the halibut special. I was appalled at the size of the portion-I couldn't help but think where is the rest of my halibut? Bill arrives and I see 49.95-more appalling and ridiculous. We are new to the area and thought we had found a spot to dine regularly however after this experience we will not be back. You should know what your kitchen is turning out.
Pulcinella in Massapequa is an absolute gem! From start to finish, every dish was perfection. The branzino, served table-side, was like butter—delicate, flavorful, and melt-in-your-mouth good. The warm figs with goat cheese were a beautiful balance of sweet and savory, the burrata with paper-thin tomatoes and shrimp was fresh and elegant, and the pistachio gelato was the perfect finish—creamy, rich, and unforgettable. The owner Ciro was on site, ensuring everything ran seamlessly, and the staff's attention to every detail was truly impeccable. A five-star experience in every way!
Pulcinella never disappoints. Food is always great, ambiance is lovely, and the noise level is perfect for conversation. Service is perfection.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ An Unforgettable Experience at Pulcinella! From the moment we arrived, we were warmly welcomed by Jeremias, whose impeccable, attentive, and friendly service truly made our visit special. We enjoyed two special dishes that completely won us over: the seafood salad and capeline cake, along with delicious garlic shrimp and succulent lamb chops, all perfectly prepared. To accompany, an ice-cold beer just the way we love it, and expertly crafted drinks that rounded out the evening beautifully. The Pulcinella ambiance is absolutely stunning—like a scene straight out of a movie—creating the perfect setting for any special occasion. To top it all off, the spumoni and cannoli, paired with a chilled limoncello, brilliantly crowned the end of our meal. Highly recommend for anyone seeking an exquisite combination of outstanding food, top-notch service, and a charming atmosphere!
Perfect date night spot. Ambiance was amazing, medium/low lighting, intimate table settings. Noise was moderate to low...only other family's laughing and having a great time. Our server was new but he was great! Food was amazing and always consistent. I got the Shrimp Oreganata with gnocchi and I just want to drink that sauce! My husband got chicken parm and loved it. We will be going back this weekend!
One of my favorite places to dine. This time I was a little disappointed. Food was just ok. Not level I was used to there. Also seemed like everyone was rushing around a bit chaotic but they were pleasant.
Have been here many times especially if we're in the area. Consistently great. Always fabulous specials. In fact I rarely order off the menu because the specials are so spectacular. Our server Jeremiah filleted my Branzino like a surgeon who graduated first in his class. Only disappointed they were out of stuffed zucchini flowers. I guess we'll have to go back
Clams casino had so much red pepper not enough clams , was only 1 Sauvignon Blanc glass to choose from , stuffed flounder was covered with reddish breadcrumbs / ruined meal
Restaurantji Recommends
Good food. Slow service. Refused to put bread Lin table until we ordered despite putting an oil/herb mix down that's used for bread. 45 minutes to get breaf
First time dining here on Fathers Day. Was happy to have gotten a reservation on such short notice. Food was delicious. Great atmosphere. Will definitely be back!
Excellent as always. Highly recommended. Antonio, Rudy and Jeremiah are at the top of their game. Highly recommend dining here.
Delicious food and very attentive service- the short ribs and stuffed veal chop are excellent!
Fabulous!! The food the service, everything was just amazing. We've been there twice and it will be a pleasure to be back!
Loading...