Mayors pizza
452 Oliver St, North Tonawanda
(716) 389-0052
Customers' Favorites
Breaded Wings
Pizza
Menu
Photos
+10 photos
+9 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Went and got a slice of cheese and pepperoni pizza, since it was recommended on the NT facebook page. It was good. My only complaint is, it was a bit inconsistent. Half of the pizza had sauce and cheese to the crust, and the other had just alot of crust. I think all pizzas should have sauce, and cheese to the crust, with crust not being more than an inch. Don't scrimp on ingredients. As you can tell from Good Guys Pizza, rated number 1 in NT.
I don't usually have a problem with their food. I come from Niagara Falls just for food. But last night I got 2 subs and they were not good. The pizza sub I got had sauce that was so thick like paste. The other sub the meat was dry and had a wierd taste. Very disappointed.
We tried here for the first time after my son played a basketball game in N.T. The customer service was top notch and our food was delicious. The breaded wings were the best we've tasted in a long time. We will definitely order from here again.
You May Also Like
Soup Lady at the 412 Diner - 412 Oliver St
![]()
Diner, Salad, Burgers, American
Panxin Express - 485 Oliver St
![]()
Chinese