The Wurlitzer Pizza Co., Inc.

I ordered the one slice deal came out in 3 minutes it was cold I complained they did nothing about it no good I'll never go back there again this was the one on Delaware Avenue in Tonawanda

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

The food here isn't all that great but we do frequent this location for the custard and ice cream which is muy bueno. The pizzeria aspect is however no Bueno. The food just falls flat and lacks flavor.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Gluten free pizza with pepperoni. Tasted fine. I’m sorry $30 (29 and change) for this size?? Way too small. Kind of ridiculous. If I’m paying premium price I should be getting premium pizza

Great variety and fast service.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Good food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

First time I’ve eaten here. Ordered a large and 20 wings. Best food I’ve had in a long time. I’m very picky about my wings and they were perfect. I ordered through Slice. Food was ready when they said it would be.

I ordered online at 6:25PM and received confirmation text and email that order would be ready at 7:05PM. I show up at 7:15PM and gave my name and showed email and text confirmation I was informed they had no record of my order but after they checked their computer quickly apologize I said we missed this young kid working apologize and said he would make my order quickly. My order came out 20 minutes later and when I got home, pizza was raw and chicken fingers were still frozen. I do not blame the young kids working there, but I will never order from this place ever again.

$80 later - Large taco no sauce and cold taco meat charged me for sour cream never got that etc - 2 orders of cold soggy quesadillas - 3 wrong salads After several fails an inconsistencies throughout the years calling back was not an option this time around. We are done with the pizzeria. Ice cream yes!! (kinda hard to screw that up ) pizza! And pizzeria horrible Good luck

Their veggie pizza is AMAZING! Nom, nom, nom.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Pizza and wings were good. Nice size on the wings

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Buffalo Style Chicken Wings

My wife really enjoyed her Sicilian-style personal pan pizza (just cheese and sauce). I got the same with Hawaiian toppings; the toppings were really sparse: 2 slices of ham. For my wife, the pizza was top 5 or 10 ever. For me, lower half.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Food was good, reasonable prices.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza

I love Wurlitzer pizza and have since they opened back in the Wurlitzer bldg. Their white pizza is a great change of pace from the regular red sauce , we like half green peppers and half hot peppers, it's great 👍 Everything we've ever ordered from them has been very good and has not disappointed any of us

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Our pizza was very good! Only thing is they cut a round pizza into squares! Why??? Small squares and triangle pieces with nothing on it 🙄CUT THE PIZZA IN SLICES!!! also ordered wings from the pit, they came from a deep fryer!😡

Food: 3

Eating specialized food here is a waste.

This is a Owner or Manager
problem. The employees shouldn't be heald accountable.

I did not eat in store. I felt bad for yelling at the employees for this one which is how I got small salad & medium pizza to my house for $43.47. That was before the pizza came!

I ordered a Gluten Free Pizza which came with about half of pizza worth of topping. It's a Medium pizza compared to a normal large wheat flour pizza in size. I will add that it was an average pizza not over the top delicious. Just ok, but I just do not understand how it can be this much.

& One SIDE salad which you will see in the pics it was being shared with my parrot. He can get very sick from spoiled foods. The rest of the salad SEEMED very fresh & I had to throw my salad out as you can see why in the photos. Plus I live probably 3-5 miles, at most...

Cannot get much closer & my delivery fee was $5.50

I should have not gotten my food from here, what saddens me the most. They used to be my favorite place to go or get food from!

If we continue to pay these high prices, we will continue to see these high prices. Why don't we get together & strike (by not ordering for a month) maybe then these prices will go down.

I am utterly disgusted!

Dietary restrictions: Again Gluten Free.

Food: 1

Service: 5