It's a cute little ice cream stand serving Perry's Ice Cream, but not very big scoops compared to most places.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Michelle Ayers
Love coming and getting ice cream here after playing minture golfing next door to hear.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J “Jay Dee” Dee
Exceptionally nice seating. Ordered a pup cup and it was pretty big. I believe it was the owner, brought our pup some water, which he loved. (Not as much as his pup cup) Right next to a mini golf site. Overall great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becky Lovine
Love this place always visit here when we are in the area. Love it cause they are one of the ice cream places that still serve flavor burst ice-cream and have lots of the flavors. Butterscotch which is my favorite. Very hard to find
Jeffrey Rosen
Great ice cream and friendly service! A delicious Old Forge tradition coming back year after year
Ed H
Fast service. Perry's ice cream served. Was excellent. Soft serve was pretty good tool. Usually only one person working but they were excellent each time we went.
ERIC SCHMIDT
Good icecream
Juan Edgar Checa Hernandez
Rich and good service
Samantha Stam
Spent the weekend in Old Forge with a bunch of family and decided to go grab ice cream on our last night. Benny's was our first choice because of the reviews, and they did not disappoint. Delicious, great portions, and not too expensive. The one girl working was friendly and efficient, with no complaints. She had a long line and made it go quick. Ice cream was delicious, not to mention the place is so darn cute!
Christopher Bell
Great value for your money and my daughter loved the chair swing!
Great place! We go every time we're in Old Forge!!
Dutchman Outdoors
Stopped here after grabbing food near eagle bay. Wife’s flavor burst was great and my milkshake was fantastic. Prices were a bit high but to be expected in a tourist area.
It's a cute little ice cream stand serving Perry's Ice Cream, but not very big scoops compared to most places.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Love coming and getting ice cream here after playing minture golfing next door to hear.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Exceptionally nice seating. Ordered a pup cup and it was pretty big. I believe it was the owner, brought our pup some water, which he loved. (Not as much as his pup cup) Right next to a mini golf site. Overall great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place always visit here when we are in the area. Love it cause they are one of the ice cream places that still serve flavor burst ice-cream and have lots of the flavors. Butterscotch which is my favorite. Very hard to find
Great ice cream and friendly service! A delicious Old Forge tradition coming back year after year
Fast service. Perry's ice cream served. Was excellent. Soft serve was pretty good tool. Usually only one person working but they were excellent each time we went.
Good icecream
Rich and good service
Spent the weekend in Old Forge with a bunch of family and decided to go grab ice cream on our last night. Benny's was our first choice because of the reviews, and they did not disappoint. Delicious, great portions, and not too expensive. The one girl working was friendly and efficient, with no complaints. She had a long line and made it go quick. Ice cream was delicious, not to mention the place is so darn cute!
Great value for your money and my daughter loved the chair swing!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great ice cream and awesome service!
Great ice cream
Great place! We go every time we're in Old Forge!!
Stopped here after grabbing food near eagle bay. Wife’s flavor burst was great and my milkshake was fantastic. Prices were a bit high but to be expected in a tourist area.
They have good ice cream here. Cash only though!!
Loading...