Tony Harper's Pizza & Clam Shack

3062 NY-28, Old Forge
(315) 316-2100

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sicilianangel90

First time going there and will not be returning. The service was ok but the food was horrible and lets not forget the food is overpriced for the portion they give. I ordered seasoned rice and they gave me plain white rice in a small bowl for 5.15 thats ridiculous. Its wasn't even season. Why put that on the menu if you're just going to give plain white rice. I also ordered a make your own pizza which was supposed to be a 16 in and its was small more like 12 or 10 inches. And it was burnt. Ordered 1/2 lb shrimp and there was like 8 piece or so how is that 1/2 lb for ? And last ordered the chimichurri bowl thats was like 5 small pieces of steak on some rice for $20 is ridiculous. Oh lets not forgot my drink was 6.18 for a cup of strawberry water more or less. Which is ridiculous, it tastes nasty basically like flavor water. Ordered the strawberry breeze non alcoholic. Very disappointed. Do not recommend. Will not be returning. Horrible food. My total came to 64 and change. For that price dinner for two theres other places you can go for better food. If I could give zero stars I would.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kathy Rinere

Food and service was excellent. Had a well made pizza. The place is a bit noisy and little confusing. Two entrances but must use the front for seating. Open window to outside seating at bar. Large wall video adds to confusion. It is dark. However welcoming to families and large or small groups. A good venue with good value.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Norma Swetnam Nesmith

They did not obey the law. They made their restaurant inaccessible to a friend who is blind because she had a service dog with her. They suggested she order food and take it outside to eat. When questioned, the server admitted he would not have suggested that to her party if the dog wasn’t with her. It is disappointing in 2025 for any place of business to deny service to someone who is blind. They face enough challenges every day in a world designed for sighted people. Shame on you, Tony Harper’s Pizza and Clam Shack!

Elizabeth Oleksa

We went to Tony Harper‘s pizza and clam shack on September 9, 2025. There were six adults, one baby and one service dog, a legitimately trained Seeing Eye guide dog from The Seeing Eye Inc. They told us that they were full on the bottom and full on the top, but we could order in and then take it outside to eat. When asked if the same options would have been given if the dog was not with us, the worker responded with, “no, I would not have.“ This is breaking the law! I had every right to call the police and have a police report filed, but I chose the higher ground. Family was disgusted at this response, even when informed that my dog was in fact, a service dog. It is very obvious he is a surface animal as he has a leather harness stamped with the school name, matching leash, and assigned that says working service dog, no hand sniffs and do not pet. My son and I dog, nacho, is never even noticed as he lays silently at my feet, under the table, without a peep. He does not scrounge for food, he does not bark or wine. He does his job perfectly and then we leave. But I will never offer my business to this location moving forward. They violated my right as a human being, living with independence and dignity. And, they broke the law. Train your staff, please!

Shelly Zolotas

Food was just ok. Chicken fingers were burnt. Pizza Order was wrong, manager was a jerk about it. And the clam shack was out of clams. Skip it!

Lunareiko

favorite pizza place and service was amazing

Jeremy LaGrange

Do not go out of season. It's June 23rd been here many times no issue. Ordered 3 dozen clams out of clams so ordered 2 orders of mussels brought one lemon garlic and one mussel marinara. Never given options, no one likes mussels marinara. Ask customers don't just give them one of each. Super dissappointing for $100 bill for 2 people. DO BETTER.

nancy freitag

Amazing chicken wings

Joe DiPietro

Great spot. Pizza is decent but the clams with garlic butter wine sauce were outstanding. Friendly staff, great atmosphere, and nice outdoor seating options as well.

Catherine Jones

Disappointing. We had a large party here on an outing for a wedding and split into two tables to be accommodated. They told us they wouldn’t split the bill which was inconvenient. We waited for thirty minutes before they even took our order. When they brought the food finally, one member didn’t get either of her sides; another only got one side; the pizza ordered was completely wrong and by the time they brought the correct one everyone had finished eating and we were leaving so he had to take it to go. While we were waiting for it to come out we saw a chef in the back eating and walking around. Menu prices were deceiving. They were flat numbers but when we received the check each item had additional change tacked on. The menu stated nothing about an up charge. Very disappointing experience and will not be returning.

Jennifer Dombrowski

Really good pizza

B P

Great time. What i can remember anyway.

Karen Merica

Excellent

Molly Jean

I had to give a shout out to my server Hudson he is so genuinely great at his job. Super attentive and just brought joy to everyone. Give that man a raise immediately! Our pizza was banging too. Thanks dawg!

Kimberly Roy

It was ok .

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak, Bang Bang Shrimp, Lobster Roll

Loading...

Tony Harper's Pizza & Clam Shack

3062 NY-28, Old Forge, NY 13420
(315) 316-2100