The last review was 3 years ago. I normally take that as a sign the business is no longer open. Not so here — alive & well since 1960. Most people judge pizza based on the pizza they grew up with. I’m no different. Pepi’s was my pizza since it opened. I’ve never had a pizza I liked better. I use the on-line ordering option and it’s never failed me. There will always be critics, but a pizza restaurant can’t survive for 65 years without being excellent, and Pepi’s is. Are you going to like it? Depends on the pizza you grew up with, but I’m pretty sure you’ll like this. Other pizza places — including some of the chains — have come and gone since 1960. Pepi’s is still here. There’s a reason why.
Matthew Chmielewski
Peppi’s pizza is always great. Been going there for years miss Mrs. Pepi
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Raymond Finnegan
My first visit. No stranger to Pizza establishments. It was a Friday evening, but it took far too long for our food to be made and delivered to the table. Pizza was heavily over sauced, and although I paid for extra cheese, it was not made that way. Meatball sub we ordered was GREAT, as were the wings. Pizza was overpriced and a disappointment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
mattmarybeth
Great Pizza! Try the Pola, it's great. Don't forget the fried dough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dorothy Janczuk
Always an amazing experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Lewis
Delivery on time, food proper
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Rendino
This evening was my wife and my first time at Pepe's Pizza in Oneida and this establishment has renewed my faith and that some people can still actually make a real Pizza.
We ordered a large chicken bacon ranch pizza and 20 sweet and sour wings and it was spectacular!!
Are drinks came in large glasses full of ice. I've not seen glasses this size since the 90's. The Establishment has a lot of seating inside. They even have a game room which blew my mind!! Their phones were ringing off the hook and their drive-thru was just cranking! So you know this is a great place to eat.
By far the best pizza and wings from Camillus, NY all the way to Oneida NY!!!!
This establishment was the cleanest eatery that I've been in in a while. No exaggeration.
How to make our first visit even more special, Amanda was beyond amazing!!! Thank you so much Amanda for making our visit so awesome!!!
My wife and I both agree that this eatery is definitely at the top of our go to list going forward!
Wonderful customer service and as always the food is amazing. Love how they’ve always stayed true to their roots.
Larry Liess III
Tried the eat in for once and server was not friendly at all . Like we burdened her. Got our drinks to not seeing the server again. Some of the food was brought out by a different girl and then the pizza was brought out after I asked another server where our pizza was and it was not cooked all the way you could taste the uncooked dough. Wings were dry and over cooked I could not finish them I will not go back or order again . This is sad I know a few workers there and they are good hard workers
Todd Kilburn
Had a lot of great memories in this place, they have changed the arcade to one of those ticket based skill game arcades. Not a good move. But still, food is great.
Jessica Frazer
The food wonderful the people are amazing the new game room although it's nice, we loved the old things and the way the game room made us feel about are childhood
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diana Stevens
I thought the salads were have been better.. Should gotten the pizza.
The last review was 3 years ago. I normally take that as a sign the business is no longer open. Not so here — alive & well since 1960. Most people judge pizza based on the pizza they grew up with. I’m no different. Pepi’s was my pizza since it opened. I’ve never had a pizza I liked better. I use the on-line ordering option and it’s never failed me. There will always be critics, but a pizza restaurant can’t survive for 65 years without being excellent, and Pepi’s is. Are you going to like it? Depends on the pizza you grew up with, but I’m pretty sure you’ll like this. Other pizza places — including some of the chains — have come and gone since 1960. Pepi’s is still here. There’s a reason why.
Peppi’s pizza is always great. Been going there for years miss Mrs. Pepi
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My first visit. No stranger to Pizza establishments. It was a Friday evening, but it took far too long for our food to be made and delivered to the table. Pizza was heavily over sauced, and although I paid for extra cheese, it was not made that way. Meatball sub we ordered was GREAT, as were the wings. Pizza was overpriced and a disappointment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Great Pizza! Try the Pola, it's great. Don't forget the fried dough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always an amazing experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delivery on time, food proper
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This evening was my wife and my first time at Pepe's Pizza in Oneida and this establishment has renewed my faith and that some people can still actually make a real Pizza.
We ordered a large chicken bacon ranch pizza and 20 sweet and sour wings and it was spectacular!!
Are drinks came in large glasses full of ice. I've not seen glasses this size since the 90's. The Establishment has a lot of seating inside. They even have a game room which blew my mind!! Their phones were ringing off the hook and their drive-thru was just cranking! So you know this is a great place to eat.
By far the best pizza and wings from Camillus, NY all the way to Oneida NY!!!!
This establishment was the cleanest eatery that I've been in in a while. No exaggeration.
How to make our first visit even more special, Amanda was beyond amazing!!! Thank you so much Amanda for making our visit so awesome!!!
My wife and I both agree that this eatery is definitely at the top of our go to list going forward!
Great job, Pepe's!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Very pleasant staff, great fun for a family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Salad, Mozzarella Sticks, Mild Wings, Meaty Special, Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Good food, prices in line with everyone else's
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Thank you for wonderful service and amazing food last night! Don’t just read reviews people go in and see for yourself how great everything is!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Wonderful customer service and as always the food is amazing. Love how they’ve always stayed true to their roots.
Tried the eat in for once and server was not friendly at all . Like we burdened her. Got our drinks to not seeing the server again. Some of the food was brought out by a different girl and then the pizza was brought out after I asked another server where our pizza was and it was not cooked all the way you could taste the uncooked dough. Wings were dry and over cooked I could not finish them I will not go back or order again . This is sad I know a few workers there and they are good hard workers
Had a lot of great memories in this place, they have changed the arcade to one of those ticket based skill game arcades. Not a good move. But still, food is great.
The food wonderful the people are amazing the new game room although it's nice, we loved the old things and the way the game room made us feel about are childhood
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I thought the salads were have been better.. Should gotten the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Loading...