Marty's Bagels

500 NY-303, Orangeburg
(845) 359-2330

Recent Reviews

Melissa Ruiz

The bagels are back! They taste like the ones from my childhood. The new owners know what they’re doing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Tianna

I ordered an Italian Combo sandwich today and received salami thats going bad ? glad I decided to look at my sandwich before eating it

Food: 1

Service: 1

Andre Cotto (Trustdre)

Good bagels but the holes are too big. Enjoy ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Cruise

They only put 3 strips of bacon on a $7 BLT. In the future, I'll just go to United Deli ??‍♂️

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Fancy Feast

Yummy..fresh bagel with partly melted spreadable butter. Much better than those ice cold chunks of butter I've gotten at so many places

Ramona Diaz

The service was good the bagels are delicious

Angelo Soto

Fresh hot bagels, quick service.

Neil Large

The best bagels in Rockland country!

stephen

Boy, has this place gone downhill! I used to love this place when it was actually owned and operated by the original Marty. I don't know who makes them now, but they are hard as rocks and the bagel is half the size it used to be, because the "holes" are twice as big. Go to Zimi's or Geno's for good bagels and egg sandwiches.I will say that the apple turnovers, cinnamon rolls and the coffee are very good. And the counter help is very friendly.

Jack Amparo

Half the reason I show up to weekend drills is because I signed the contract to serve my country. The other half is because the breakfast they serve here.

Ever Bracamonte

Good prices and good service

Steve S

Great bagels and staff

Steve M.

Six stars if that were possible. The bagels are great. They do really load them up with cream cheese or lox spread, so you might have some leakage. We have good bagels in San Rafael CA, but they are not in the same class with these. Take out or eat in - we managed to be there when it was not too busy so YMMV.

Bev S.

Service was quick However..... Ordered plain bagel with vegetable cream cheese. Could taste jalapeño. Must have been on knife or spreader previously. Ran out of milk for the coffee do brought container over for ease of Associate and she instructed me where to refill it Not for me

Bryan C.

After years of knowing this place has really gone down the tubes, I reluctantly stopped here for breakfast in the interest of convenience. Lets just say the employees here could be described as anything but intelligent. I ordered 2 breakfast sandwiches and stood back and waited. Within a minute or 2 another customer orders 2 breakfast sandwiches very similar to my order yet different. The 2 sandwiches come to the counter and they call over the customer who came after me with the similar order. I thought to myself ..."Wow that's odd, we order almost the same thing and I ordered before him and yet his is ready first even though his order involved additional steps during preparation" I try to get their attention to ensure he is not being given my order since I was there and ordered before him but I am ignored. The next 2 sandwiches come out and I question them if they're the ones on the specific bagel I asked for and I'm looked at like I have 2 heads. I opened the foil and of course they're wrong, so I tell them but they turned their backs and went back to working. Tips for this place: 1) Don't go here, this is not the same place it was 20 years ago. (They should change their name) 2) Monitor other peoples orders in order to receive the right food because the employees clearly do not.

Load More