Beautiful location and amenities. With the weather just right, it feels like you are abroad in some a sun swept Mediterranean location. Come by boat, by car, and sea plane (if thats your thing) : ) Bring your appetite and your friends for the food is served family style. The chicken and steak were delicious as was the lobster. Though there is no full bar, you will not be lacking. Don't worry if you are in need of a greater assortment of libations. There are great bars nearby. Start at Claudios on the water and work your way about. Enjoy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah L.
I would skip the restaurant and go for drinks and light apps at the beach club portion. They charge you for water, the bathrooms were all dirty and broken. The staff was comically rude. Not the waiters but the host and women who rings up your food like you’re at Panera bread.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Nora Cruz
The atmosphere is excellent. The place looks fantastic, and the food was terrific. It was my first time here since Duryea’s took over. I was not aware of how the restaurant was. No one explained that we had to place our order and pay for it before they brought out the food to us. After half an hour, I asked someone, and they looked at me weirdly, but explained to me that we needed to check the mark what we wanted and then go to the cashier to pay for the food. I left a great tip, thinking we would get service. No one brings your food out; we NEVER saw a waiter come to us. I was highly disappointed with that. Because I saw the waiter going to other tables but never to us to ask us how everything was. I want to return because the food was terrific, but tipping someone who will never come to the table is rude and unacceptable. They should let the customers know how the restaurant works as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Eli Be
We made a reservation here (instead of Montauk) and realised day of. We looked at the cancellation policies and this case was listed as a no reimbursement case for the (50$ pp cancellation fee). We were a party of 9 (booked for 10- the birthday girl actually even fell sick) and would have had to travel 1.5 hrs to get to this place. So we decided to call before making the trip to see if there was really no other way than us showing up in order to not pay $500 for a missed reservation. Upon many calls to all different phone numbers they have (because they seem to avoid having a working phone number listed at all), a sweet hostess from the Montauk branch told us she spoke to the Orient Point GM and that we were fine to come to the Montauk location and our reservation would be cancelled without the fee. She even called us back after double checking this. Only after getting this confirmation, we decide to not make the trip and instead ate and drank at the Montauk location. However, a few days later I still get a $500 fee charged to my credit card. Upon calling the number again, we were confirmed again that our reservation was cancelled and we’d get reimbursed, over messenger they responded we might get half of the sum back. This was 1 month ago and even after inquiring a few more times we have heard nothing and I paid $500+ the cost of dinner at their sister location. I think the fee first of all is crazy, but sure, agreed to. However, had we not been promised by the restaurant that the cancellation was okay, we would have made the trip out there to not incur the cancellation fee. After the false promise, we now paid $500 for a non existent experience.
leilani lopez
Lobster Cobb salad is phenomenal. Pico Oysters super salty. Love the ambience reminds me of Greece.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Betty Launt
Beautifully plated food presentation, fresh and delicious. Pricey but worth it. Beachy decor, open air dining overlooking the water. In as upscale restaurant as such I was appalled at their ordering style - fill out your own order, take it to a counter, pay and tip before food is presented, go back to the counter pay again for any additional food (extra pita) or drinks. Wait staff was pleasant and prompt.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
clinton steenekamp
The food is delicious, I have shellfish allergy, they made me pasta without lobster, sooo good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fran\u0026Dan Bleier
Truly a delightful dining experience overlooking a marina. The service was 'spot on', quick, attentive and very helpful. The wonderfully prepared, very fresh and perfectly cooked food was some of the best I've had. The local oysters are so very tasty. Fresh crusty bread, and the side dishes, including jasmine rice, slightly hot spiced was delicious, as we're the locally sourced roasted and delicately spiced veggies. The traditional old school lobster roll was also nicely made without the butter overwhelming the lobster taste and soaking the roll. Add a local brew, a basket of fries that puts other places to shame, and the sea air to make this a place that we will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adriana Morote
Great place. Plates are huge... family style recommended to go party of 4... Great service ambiance and food quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hannah Curtis
We were soooo impressed by this meal. First off, we were under a time crunch because I had to catch the local ferry but the team made it certain that we would have our meal in time for it.
The lamb was INSANE. Hands down some of the best my father and I have ever had. We were super impressed. We loved the atmosphere, it was chill and relaxed.
family style on water chicken tenders 4 pcs were overcooked. dry chicken inside. $24.00. lol. burgers. meh. lobster roll was good. served with horrible stale chips. best thing was the bread basket. not impressed. too expensive for just ok food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Michael Barkman
Food was good. Nice atmosphere with great views. Very pricey for what it is though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Megan Bess
I am baffled by this place. All insanely expensive family style portions and you get charged $50 per person if you need to cancel for any reason. But you walk up to a register to order? At this price point it makes no sense. I was asked when I went to order a second round of drinks what my table # was and chastised for not knowing. Spoiler alert-there are no signs on the tables. Drink menu is quite limited. If you don't want wine the cocktails are very meh--I had to settle for an overly sweet margarita. Such a shame because it is a really pretty setting. Service is really lacking for the price point and vibe is off. Can't imagine sitting down for a drink at the bar at the tiniest barstools I've ever seen in my life...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Humberto Pacheco
Food was mediocre, but expensive. Service was slow, but the people were nice. You have to get up and pay before you get your food, which is annoying if you want to order more. Place feels like a bit of a rip off, the quality vs price is not there. Also, they want to charge $75 for a corkage fee, even though when you order their wines they come hot (not room temperature, hot like they’ve been in the sun). The location is very pretty, but to charge what they are charging, they need to up their game.
Beautiful location and amenities. With the weather just right, it feels like you are abroad in some a sun swept Mediterranean location. Come by boat, by car, and sea plane (if thats your thing) : )
Bring your appetite and your friends for the food is served family style.
The chicken and steak were delicious as was the lobster. Though there is no full bar, you will not be lacking. Don't worry if you are in need of a greater assortment of libations. There are great bars nearby. Start at Claudios on the water and work your way about. Enjoy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I would skip the restaurant and go for drinks and light apps at the beach club portion. They charge you for water, the bathrooms were all dirty and broken. The staff was comically rude. Not the waiters but the host and women who rings up your food like you’re at Panera bread.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
The atmosphere is excellent. The place looks fantastic, and the food was terrific. It was my first time here since Duryea’s took over. I was not aware of how the restaurant was. No one explained that we had to place our order and pay for it before they brought out the food to us. After half an hour, I asked someone, and they looked at me weirdly, but explained to me that we needed to check the mark what we wanted and then go to the cashier to pay for the food. I left a great tip, thinking we would get service. No one brings your food out; we NEVER saw a waiter come to us. I was highly disappointed with that. Because I saw the waiter going to other tables but never to us to ask us how everything was. I want to return because the food was terrific, but tipping someone who will never come to the table is rude and unacceptable. They should let the customers know how the restaurant works as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
We made a reservation here (instead of Montauk) and realised day of. We looked at the cancellation policies and this case was listed as a no reimbursement case for the (50$ pp cancellation fee). We were a party of 9 (booked for 10- the birthday girl actually even fell sick) and would have had to travel 1.5 hrs to get to this place. So we decided to call before making the trip to see if there was really no other way than us showing up in order to not pay $500 for a missed reservation. Upon many calls to all different phone numbers they have (because they seem to avoid having a working phone number listed at all), a sweet hostess from the Montauk branch told us she spoke to the Orient Point GM and that we were fine to come to the Montauk location and our reservation would be cancelled without the fee. She even called us back after double checking this.
Only after getting this confirmation, we decide to not make the trip and instead ate and drank at the Montauk location.
However, a few days later I still get a $500 fee charged to my credit card.
Upon calling the number again, we were confirmed again that our reservation was cancelled and we’d get reimbursed, over messenger they responded we might get half of the sum back. This was 1 month ago and even after inquiring a few more times we have heard nothing and I paid $500+ the cost of dinner at their sister location.
I think the fee first of all is crazy, but sure, agreed to. However, had we not been promised by the restaurant that the cancellation was okay, we would have made the trip out there to not incur the cancellation fee. After the false promise, we now paid $500 for a non existent experience.
Lobster Cobb salad is phenomenal. Pico Oysters super salty. Love the ambience reminds me of Greece.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Beautifully plated food presentation, fresh and delicious. Pricey but worth it. Beachy decor, open air dining overlooking the water. In as upscale restaurant as such I was appalled at their ordering style - fill out your own order, take it to a counter, pay and tip before food is presented, go back to the counter pay again for any additional food (extra pita) or drinks. Wait staff was pleasant and prompt.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
The food is delicious, I have shellfish allergy, they made me pasta without lobster, sooo good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Truly a delightful dining experience overlooking a marina. The service was 'spot on', quick, attentive and very helpful. The wonderfully prepared, very fresh and perfectly cooked food was some of the best I've had. The local oysters are so very tasty. Fresh crusty bread, and the side dishes, including jasmine rice, slightly hot spiced was delicious, as we're the locally sourced roasted and delicately spiced veggies. The traditional old school lobster roll was also nicely made without the butter overwhelming the lobster taste and soaking the roll.
Add a local brew, a basket of fries that puts other places to shame, and the sea air to make this a place that we will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place. Plates are huge... family style recommended to go party of 4... Great service ambiance and food quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were soooo impressed by this meal. First off, we were under a time crunch because I had to catch the local ferry but the team made it certain that we would have our meal in time for it.
The lamb was INSANE. Hands down some of the best my father and I have ever had. We were super impressed. We loved the atmosphere, it was chill and relaxed.
We definitely would come back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
family style on water
chicken tenders 4 pcs were overcooked. dry chicken inside. $24.00. lol. burgers. meh.
lobster roll was good. served with horrible stale chips. best thing was the bread basket.
not impressed. too expensive for just ok food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Food was good. Nice atmosphere with great views. Very pricey for what it is though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
I am baffled by this place. All insanely expensive family style portions and you get charged $50 per person if you need to cancel for any reason. But you walk up to a register to order? At this price point it makes no sense. I was asked when I went to order a second round of drinks what my table # was and chastised for not knowing. Spoiler alert-there are no signs on the tables. Drink menu is quite limited. If you don't want wine the cocktails are very meh--I had to settle for an overly sweet margarita. Such a shame because it is a really pretty setting. Service is really lacking for the price point and vibe is off. Can't imagine sitting down for a drink at the bar at the tiniest barstools I've ever seen in my life...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Food was mediocre, but expensive. Service was slow, but the people were nice. You have to get up and pay before you get your food, which is annoying if you want to order more. Place feels like a bit of a rip off, the quality vs price is not there. Also, they want to charge $75 for a corkage fee, even though when you order their wines they come hot (not room temperature, hot like they’ve been in the sun). The location is very pretty, but to charge what they are charging, they need to up their game.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
I got terrible food poisoning here
Loading...