Oysters were terrific. Fish and chips (both bass and cod) were very good. Wine (Portuguese Albarono, vino verde) was better (much) with food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Henry
My wife and I love eating at Brothers Fish! The food is delicious, original and beautifully presented. Elmer Oliveros, owner and chef, is a master at his trade who clearly loves offering food to his patrons. Dining at Brothers Fish combines a delicious and sophisticated culinary experience with the informality and pure joy of having dinner at your best friend’s home.
Awesome fish and chips! The Caesar salad is awesome, too!
I'm knocking off a star because they told me on the phone they had chicken tenders (which weren't on the menu, but I thought I'd ask because I was ordering for a family including kids who wanted chicken tenders), but upon pickup it was a fried chicken breast cut into strips. These aren't the same and it felt dishonest. I'd have rather just have been told no, or told what I was ordering more accurately.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Fish and Chips
Rosalina García
BEST PLACE! Love the food very perfect for dates, and celebrating important events with your loved ones. Food is made with love and the presentations are incredible. make sure to book your table. It gets very busy. The Tasting menu is the best part of the place. Enjoy every moment and dish that comes in. Service is perfect sometimes get busy and understand but love the people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos, Fish and Chips, Ceviche Mixto, Fish & Chips
Geoff C
Fish and chips are $32. That’s right. $32. They were ok but no better than the fish and chips you can get at any pub for less than $20. The bill for four of us was nearly $300 before gratuity and this was after having only about 4 drinks in total and no dessert. The service was slooooow and the place was empty, I presume due to the ridiculous prices. Come on. Not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Philip
We've been meaning to try this place for years after trying the takeout. Wish we'd skipped it. The food was disappointing. Oysters were overdressed with shallots, tobiko and a spicy sauce. Soup with mussels and shrimp was uneven. Mussels were chewy and poorly cleaned. The broth was flavorful, but the shrimp were tasteless and over cooked. Stripped bass was lukewarm and filleted poorly. Risotto with Gruyère and lobster was not good. Concept was intriguing , but the execution was flawed. The risotto was congealed and stodgy and the lobster was overcooked. Really disappointing for a $40. Entree. Our plates were left half finished, yet we were never asked about our meal. The only bright spot was the she-crab soup. That was quite good. We'll Stick to the fish and chips take out from now on.
Melisa Imberman The Event Of A Lifetime, Inc.
The entire experience was amazing! The food was innovative, delicious & presented well & the service was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Zimmerman
I wanted to bring my friend to a restaurant specializing in fish and close by to her home for her birthday dinner. Brothers Fish and Chips fit the bill. The food was absolutely delicious and so well prepared. We split the sea bass fish and chips. It was accompanied by a variety of flavorful dipping sauces. One was more delicious than the next. We also Ordered the tuna with mole and mushrooms. The flavor combination was unexpected and wildly tasteful. The quality of the tuna was enhanced by the perfect cooking. Small and charming restaurant with mighty food and very attentive service. Looking forward to a return visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Fish
Barry Rosenbloom
Food quality is always top notch. But value and service were below par. $22 for the smallest portion of calamari I've ever seen, by far?. $30+ for what used to be a huge portion of fish & chips but has been cut down to what you'd get at local pub? C'mon guys. Lobster risotto was great though. Service was way too slow. That calamari app took over thirty minutes from when we ordered. Won't be back, at least not for the regular menu.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Lobster Risotto
Diane Bernstein
Food was amazing..the fish and chips were light but flavorful and the hand cut french fries were done perfectly. The standout was the lobster risotto which was decadent!! Service was attentive and always with a smile. Don't let the outside of the place fool you..When you walk in you will be treated with excellent food!!
Usually do the tasting menu. This time went a la carte. Surprisingly, probably took longer than the multi-course extravaganza. And prices are quite high for not a lot of food, tasty as it might be.
Diane
Food was delicious. The lobster risotto was decadent and amazing. Fish and chips were lightly bettered and were perfect. Service was friendly. Wine prices were quite reasonable. Everything is made to order. Will certainly be back .
alfred pucci
The atmosphere is appropriately aligned with the excellent seafood alternatives and the service is friendly, very accommodating and proficient. A.P. August 27, 2024
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Rhodes
Fabulous from the first pristine oyster through to the lobster risotto and beyond. Chef Elmer is so talented he belongs on top chef, and when he does, he needs to make the preserved tuna with mole. Also…loved the applewood smoked Negroni as the palette cleanser. Don’t be fooled by the location in a strip mall that includes a laundromat and nail salon, this is a hidden gem of a place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chef's Tasting Menu
Jason Macias
Chef’s tasting menu is a hidden gem in Westchester. The creativity, attention to detail and combination of flavor exceeds all expectations. Chef Elmer is on top of his game.
Oysters were terrific. Fish and chips (both bass and cod) were very good. Wine (Portuguese Albarono, vino verde) was better (much) with food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
My wife and I love eating at Brothers Fish! The food is delicious, original and beautifully presented. Elmer Oliveros, owner and chef, is a master at his trade who clearly loves offering food to his patrons. Dining at Brothers Fish combines a delicious and sophisticated culinary experience with the informality and pure joy of having dinner at your best friend’s home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Octopus, Cod, Calamari, Chef's Tasting Menu, Fish, Ceviche Mixto, Coconut Flan, Lobster Risotto, Seafood Paella
Awesome fish and chips! The Caesar salad is awesome, too!
I'm knocking off a star because they told me on the phone they had chicken tenders (which weren't on the menu, but I thought I'd ask because I was ordering for a family including kids who wanted chicken tenders), but upon pickup it was a fried chicken breast cut into strips. These aren't the same and it felt dishonest. I'd have rather just have been told no, or told what I was ordering more accurately.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Fish and Chips
BEST PLACE! Love the food very perfect for dates, and celebrating important events with your loved ones. Food is made with love and the presentations are incredible. make sure to book your table. It gets very busy. The Tasting menu is the best part of the place. Enjoy every moment and dish that comes in. Service is perfect sometimes get busy and understand but love the people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos, Fish and Chips, Ceviche Mixto, Fish & Chips
Fish and chips are $32. That’s right. $32. They were ok but no better than the fish and chips you can get at any pub for less than $20. The bill for four of us was nearly $300 before gratuity and this was after having only about 4 drinks in total and no dessert. The service was slooooow and the place was empty, I presume due to the ridiculous prices. Come on. Not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
We've been meaning to try this place for years after trying the takeout. Wish we'd skipped it. The food was disappointing. Oysters were overdressed with shallots, tobiko and a spicy sauce. Soup with mussels and shrimp was uneven. Mussels were chewy and poorly cleaned. The broth was flavorful, but the shrimp were tasteless and over cooked. Stripped bass was lukewarm and filleted poorly. Risotto with Gruyère and lobster was not good. Concept was intriguing , but the execution was flawed. The risotto was congealed and stodgy and the lobster was overcooked. Really disappointing for a $40. Entree. Our plates were left half finished, yet we were never asked about our meal. The only bright spot was the she-crab soup. That was quite good. We'll Stick to the fish and chips take out from now on.
The entire experience was amazing! The food was innovative, delicious & presented well & the service was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wanted to bring my friend to a restaurant specializing in fish and close by to her home for her birthday dinner. Brothers Fish and Chips fit the bill. The food was absolutely delicious and so well prepared. We split the sea bass fish and chips. It was accompanied by a variety of flavorful dipping sauces. One was more delicious than the next. We also
Ordered the tuna with mole and mushrooms. The flavor combination was unexpected and wildly tasteful. The quality of the tuna was enhanced by the perfect cooking. Small and charming restaurant with mighty food and very attentive service. Looking forward to a return visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Fish
Food quality is always top notch. But value and service were below par.
$22 for the smallest portion of calamari I've ever seen, by far?. $30+ for what used to be a huge portion of fish & chips but has been cut down to what you'd get at local pub? C'mon guys. Lobster risotto was great though.
Service was way too slow. That calamari app took over thirty minutes from when we ordered. Won't be back, at least not for the regular menu.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Lobster Risotto
Food was amazing..the fish and chips were light but flavorful and the hand cut french fries were done perfectly. The standout was the lobster risotto which was decadent!! Service was attentive and always with a smile. Don't let the outside of the place fool you..When you walk in you will be treated with excellent food!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Usually do the tasting menu. This time went a la carte. Surprisingly, probably took longer than the multi-course extravaganza. And prices are quite high for not a lot of food, tasty as it might be.
Food was delicious. The lobster risotto was decadent and amazing. Fish and chips were lightly bettered and were perfect. Service was friendly. Wine prices were quite reasonable. Everything is made to order. Will certainly be back .
The atmosphere is appropriately aligned with the excellent seafood alternatives and the service is friendly, very accommodating and proficient.
A.P. August 27, 2024
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fabulous from the first pristine oyster through to the lobster risotto and beyond. Chef Elmer is so talented he belongs on top chef, and when he does, he needs to make the preserved tuna with mole. Also…loved the applewood smoked Negroni as the palette cleanser. Don’t be fooled by the location in a strip mall that includes a laundromat and nail salon, this is a hidden gem of a place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chef's Tasting Menu
Chef’s tasting menu is a hidden gem in Westchester. The creativity, attention to detail and combination of flavor exceeds all expectations. Chef Elmer is on top of his game.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...