Gimme Burger

39 E Main St, Oyster Bay
(516) 922-3300

Recent Reviews

Amanda Johnson (Balloons by Amanda)

EDIT- Well a gentleman from the restaurant reached out about my experience. He has offered a gift certificate to give me another opportunity to check them out. So I bumped up a star.To be continued......Really wanted to like this place. Daily Fresh made in-house rolls, Special meat blend- yes please. Whomp whomp. There was a full rack of buns in plastic bags at 6pm- clearly they are out sourcing. Burger patty was dense (like pre frozen) and seemed steamed (weird color?) The shake was more like chocolate milk- Sooo thin. Fries were limp- but well seasoned. Young lady at counter was clearly not thrilled with her job.Bacon cheese burger, cheese burger, 2 fries, 2 shakes $40. Nope- not worth it. Only plus the bacon was thick and tasty.

Dan Z.

Average at best. The bun is unique and doesn't seem to go with the burger. The meat is average, nothing special about it. I prefer five guy, but theres not one in town.

Katherine A.

Delicious burgers and fries. Milkshakes are great. Staff is always friendly :) I love when they text me about coupons and deals!

Troy Lov

No better burger for the price. Classic

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Laura Morrison

You wont find better.I consider myself lucky to have it not too far from where i work.

Beverly Jacobsen

The burgers are great and filled with flavor but small! This is the first time I've eaten a burger and still felt hungry after. The homemade bun is probably the best burger bun I've ever had. Fries are great and the portion is very good, a must try. In my opinion, the vanilla shake is awful. The first time I got it I would have rated it a 3/10, but this time it's a zero. Honestly the worst vanilla milkshake I've ever had, coming from someone who doesn't eat chocolate, so I've had a LOT of vanilla shakes. I was surprised when I saw the reviews saying they actually liked it. Maybe I got it on an off day, or maybe I shouldn't have had vanilla. It tastes like cheap melted diner ice cream, filled with bubbles, thick but in a syrupy sweet way. Or even like the little vanilla ice cream cups that they serve to patients at the hospital. Tastes 100% artificial and left a fake sugar taste in my mouth. It's also super sticky and goopy? For a child that just wants something sweet to sip on, it's fine, but if you're looking for even a half decent milkshake, don't waste your time or money, especially at such a small drink size.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Joseph S.

Outstanding burgers. They make the chop meat there with a special blend of different meats and spices. They make the buns too and they are outrageously delicious. The fries are great and the chicken tenders are excellent. It's a cool joint like an old burger joint from when I was a kid growing up in the city type vibe. We'll definitely go back there it was really good.

Penny P.

Service, cheeseburgers with fries are excellent. Nice area to eat your food. Do not order your food from Yelp -- my order was rejected and my credit card was charged the following day. Yelp uses Grubhub to place your order and the amount is much higher. When my order was declined from Yelp Grubhub I went to Gimmeburger website and placed my order with no problem. I then realized there was a big difference in the prices. I will never place an order for food through Yelp Grubhub ever again! Now I'm in the process of disputing the credit card charge, which is totally unacceptable, since they declined my order! Don't understand why they then charged my credit card, the next day, for an order they declined.

Iben A.

Amazing burger and fries! The man who runs the place is amazing and nice. Beat burger in New York for sure and for a good price.

Kathena F.

Tasty burgers, high quality ingredients, good prices, excellent service. Nice addition to the neighborhood.

Trudy Llama

Awesome place! They have cool decorations and umbrella tables, amazing burgers too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steven T.

Excellent Burgers!Very flavorful tasting burgers and Shakes!Good prices fast service. Good job guys keep it consistent you’ll be there a very long time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Passalacqua

Really fantastic burger, better than five guys and a lot cheaper. Not the best fries but hard to complain at that price point when the burger is so good. Fantastic vibe, couldn't recommend it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Cheeseburger

Pappy T.

Excellent Burgers!Very flavorful tasting burgers and Shakes!Good prices fast service. Good job guys keep it consistent you’ll be there a very long time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Terence Teng

If you're looking for a place that combines speed, quality, and excellent customer service, look no further. I will definitely be returning for more of those delicious burgers and the friendly atmosphere. Highly recommended!"

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More