Gioia Italian Restaurant in Oyster Bay is an absolute gem. The food is outstanding — every dish tastes fresh, authentic, and beautifully prepared. You can tell there’s real care put into the ingredients and presentation.
What truly sets Gioia apart, though, is the intimate, welcoming atmosphere. It has that perfect cozy Italian feel that makes you want to relax, enjoy a great bottle of wine, and stay awhile. It’s the kind of place that feels special without being pretentious.
If you’re looking for exceptional Italian food in Oyster Bay with a warm, inviting vibe, Gioia is a must-visit. Can’t wait to go back! 🍝🍷
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ray
Celebrated my 33rd wedding anniversary here It was a quiet peaceful and welcoming environment Staff was terrific and even gave us complimentary glasses of champagne to toast our occasion Menu was a delicious twist of words i couldn't wait to try out. I will be back to feast on something else
Anthony
The food, drinks, and service were excellent. Couldn't recommend it more. One of the top restaurants on Long Island for sure.
Katie
Amazing spot. Cute and intimate. Staff was attentive and so kind. Drinks were strong and pasta was 10/10, especially the ravioli!!!
Susan
A delightful dining experience from ambience service to food and cocktails . Staff very attentive. We did the 3 course prix fix dinner. To start the eggplant was delicious and the prosciutto with accompaniments very good. The pasta dishes are always excellent. Dessert and coffee topped off a fine meal. Will definitely go back.
Diane
We had the price fix, it was worth it . The portions are a bit on the small side but delicious .
Michelle
The mozzarella appetizer was not my favorite. However the Brasato was delicious just very rich and heavy. It is a shareable dish with friends not an individual entree.
Caeser Salad
Had 6pm reservations for 4 people. Two of us got there at 540pm and ask to be seated early as the other 2 party members were en route about 5-10 minutes away. Mind you, the restaurant was completely empty , except for two occupants sitting at the bar. The hostess told us we couldn't be seated until the whole party was there as in the past people have come late and they were going to busy that night. Now it's 545 and the hostess still didn't sit us and not one other person was in the restaurant. We were literally about 5-10 feet away from here watching her stand there texting on her phone. I yet again went over and asked to be seated. She replied again in a condescending tone it's the policy of the restaurateur not to seat anyone until the full party arrives. Under normally circumstances I understand but this restaurant was beyond empty. I took it upon myself and finally sat down at one of the many empty tables and the hostess comes over and says I guess you can sit here as you took it upon yourself to seat yourself. Now it's 547pm and the two people in my party arrive. I was beyond disgusted with the hostesses attitude so we left. I would never recommend this restaurant to anyone. Their people are nasty and their policies are lacking. It's a tiny hole in the wall dump. We went down the street to Eddie's and had a very good meal. STAY AWAY FROM GIOIA!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Corinne Troiano
We have been regulars at Gioia for a couple of years now. We have had several meals, and all of them were excellent. The three course dinner is a bargain, and the mozzarella is the best I have eaten anywhere. The young staff is friendly, attentive, well trained , and professional. Hope you enjoy it as much as we do.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephan Herard
The pasta with shrimp and chili was pretty good. But the pricing. I’d like to have more for the price
Gioia is everything you hope to find in a neighborhood restaurant and more. From the moment we walked in, the service was incredibly warm, thoughtful, and attentive without ever feeling intrusive.
I asked for a very specific drink that wasn’t on the menu and instead of saying no, our server literally took a photo of the ingredients and had the bar recreate it for me perfectly. That level of care and willingness to go above and beyond says everything about how this place is run.
The food was outstanding across the board. The pasta was phenomenal, the chicken was cooked perfectly, and every dish tasted fresh, balanced, and thoughtfully prepared. What really stood out is that you leave feeling satisfied and not uncomfortably full like so many restaurants today. The ingredients are clearly high quality, fresh, and intentionally used.
The space itself is small, quaint, and intimate, the kind of place that feels special the second you walk in. It’s perfect for a date night, but just as great for gathering with friends or family.
100% recommended. Gioia is a standout and I will absolutely be back again.
Such a welcome addition to the neighborhood! Hard to believe it was once a pretty bleak-looking pizzeria.
Lesley
Delicious food beautifully prepared. Super attentive waitstaff and front desk . Best bread basket ever! Our Peruvian waiter was a doll, every request met with a smile.
Fabrianna
Great food!!! Truly every bite was amazing. The staff was knowledgeable and attentive. The vibes were great, intimate and not too loud.
Jacqueline
Our chicken was dry and over cooked. Eggplant had did not have much taste. My pasta was fair. Overall, although the cocktails were delicious and the service was on point - the food did not match.
Gioia Italian Restaurant in Oyster Bay is an absolute gem. The food is outstanding — every dish tastes fresh, authentic, and beautifully prepared. You can tell there’s real care put into the ingredients and presentation.
What truly sets Gioia apart, though, is the intimate, welcoming atmosphere. It has that perfect cozy Italian feel that makes you want to relax, enjoy a great bottle of wine, and stay awhile. It’s the kind of place that feels special without being pretentious.
If you’re looking for exceptional Italian food in Oyster Bay with a warm, inviting vibe, Gioia is a must-visit. Can’t wait to go back! 🍝🍷
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Celebrated my 33rd wedding anniversary here It was a quiet peaceful and welcoming environment Staff was terrific and even gave us complimentary glasses of champagne to toast our occasion Menu was a delicious twist of words i couldn't wait to try out. I will be back to feast on something else
The food, drinks, and service were excellent. Couldn't recommend it more. One of the top restaurants on Long Island for sure.
Amazing spot. Cute and intimate. Staff was attentive and so kind. Drinks were strong and pasta was 10/10, especially the ravioli!!!
A delightful dining experience from ambience service to food and cocktails . Staff very attentive. We did the 3 course prix fix dinner. To start the eggplant was delicious and the prosciutto with accompaniments very good. The pasta dishes are always excellent. Dessert and coffee topped off a fine meal. Will definitely go back.
We had the price fix, it was worth it . The portions are a bit on the small side but delicious .
The mozzarella appetizer was not my favorite. However the Brasato was delicious just very rich and heavy. It is a shareable dish with friends not an individual entree.
Had 6pm reservations for 4 people. Two of us got there at 540pm and ask to be seated early as the other 2 party members were en route about 5-10 minutes away. Mind you, the restaurant was completely empty , except for two occupants sitting at the bar. The hostess told us we couldn't be seated until the whole party was there as in the past people have come late and they were going to busy that night. Now it's 545 and the hostess still didn't sit us and not one other person was in the restaurant. We were literally about 5-10 feet away from here watching her stand there texting on her phone. I yet again went over and asked to be seated. She replied again in a condescending tone it's the policy of the restaurateur not to seat anyone until the full party arrives. Under normally circumstances I understand but this restaurant was beyond empty. I took it upon myself and finally sat down at one of the many empty tables and the hostess comes over and says I guess you can sit here as you took it upon yourself to seat yourself. Now it's 547pm and the two people in my party arrive. I was beyond disgusted with the hostesses attitude so we left. I would never recommend this restaurant to anyone. Their people are nasty and their policies are lacking. It's a tiny hole in the wall dump. We went down the street to Eddie's and had a very good meal. STAY AWAY FROM GIOIA!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We have been regulars at Gioia for a couple of years now. We have had several meals, and all of them were excellent. The three course dinner is a bargain, and the mozzarella is the best I have eaten anywhere. The young staff is friendly, attentive, well trained , and professional. Hope you enjoy it as much as we do.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pasta with shrimp and chili was pretty good. But the pricing. I’d like to have more for the price
Restaurantji Recommends
Gioia is everything you hope to find in a neighborhood restaurant and more. From the moment we walked in, the service was incredibly warm, thoughtful, and attentive without ever feeling intrusive.
I asked for a very specific drink that wasn’t on the menu and instead of saying no, our server literally took a photo of the ingredients and had the bar recreate it for me perfectly. That level of care and willingness to go above and beyond says everything about how this place is run.
The food was outstanding across the board. The pasta was phenomenal, the chicken was cooked perfectly, and every dish tasted fresh, balanced, and thoughtfully prepared. What really stood out is that you leave feeling satisfied and not uncomfortably full like so many restaurants today. The ingredients are clearly high quality, fresh, and intentionally used.
The space itself is small, quaint, and intimate, the kind of place that feels special the second you walk in. It’s perfect for a date night, but just as great for gathering with friends or family.
100% recommended. Gioia is a standout and I will absolutely be back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Potato, Chicken Cutlet, Tagliatelle Bolognese
Such a welcome addition to the neighborhood! Hard to believe it was once a pretty bleak-looking pizzeria.
Delicious food beautifully prepared. Super attentive waitstaff and front desk . Best bread basket ever! Our Peruvian waiter was a doll, every request met with a smile.
Great food!!! Truly every bite was amazing. The staff was knowledgeable and attentive. The vibes were great, intimate and not too loud.
Our chicken was dry and over cooked. Eggplant had did not have much taste. My pasta was fair. Overall, although the cocktails were delicious and the service was on point - the food did not match.
Loading...