Best pizza in town in Oyster BayMarlo The New Owner is Great! Keep it up Mama Mias!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma
A S
Great Buffalo wings, pizza and pastaVery homey atmosphereDefinitely will be back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yeni Salazar
I've ordered food from Mama Mia's for both my office and family, and let me tell you, they never disappoint. Whether it's takeout or delivery, they are consistently great - always on time, and the food tastes fresh and delicious. Marlo, the new owner, is truly the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mundo Crypto
Ordered catering from Mama Mia's for my office on a friend's recommendation and it was a hit! Every dish was loved by all - the delivery was punctual, and the food arrived fresh and delicious. Definitely making this a go-to for future office catering. Can't wait to order again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Peppers, Eggplant Rollatini, House, Margherita Pizza, Grandma, Rice Ball, Meatballs, Brooklyn Sicilian Pie Slice
Hannah Maiorello
best pizza in oyster bay !! great kind people working here providing the best service !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dani L.
Ordered dinner online at 6:45. Estimated delivery was 8:07. Out for delivery at 7:50 and the food did not arrive until 8:35. The chicken is soggy and the salad is warmer than the spaghetti. Not worth $50.00
Jose Jose
nothing to do with Italian food, I thought I didn't make it at home anymore. I went with my family to buy slices for my children and I ordered some stuff mushrooms. When the food arrived, the pizza was burnt and tasteless and the mushrooms were slimy. I should have ordered McDonald's. , I'm staying with Marios Pizzeria, my family misses the old team
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
G Bach
Restaurant was clean and had enough space/seating available. Staff was friendly and the service was fast. Hawaiian slice had good flavor, but being a deep dish crust, it felt like too much dough for it. Sicilian slice was thick as it should be but needed some more sauce. Vodka grandma slice tasted a bit dry and the crust was thicker compared to other pizzerias. Regular grandma slice had great flavor but needed some more sauce throughout each slice. White slice was loaded with a very thick layer of cheese with a good thin crust, but some complained of it being too salty.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Chad Klusko
We live in Dix Hills, if by chance we are in the area; we always take out from here. From the slices to the sandwiches and dishes they're awesome. Hands down one of the best personal pies on the island. Treat yourself to their chef's cuisine you will not regret it, that I promise you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Moraga G
They do great pizza and the employees are very friendly
Had no idea Oyster Bay was so fast to deliver to Syosset... in 30 minutes or so we had an Everything pizza delivered... feared the worst because I ALWAYS pick up.. Under the weather had to default to delivery... this Everything Pizza arrived hot and with tons of delicious toppings.. bottom crust a bit dark... but better than raw for this heavily topped pizza... Delivery man was energetic and friendly. Nice vibe all around here. Would get again.... Thanks for the perfect stay at home dinner tonight.
Allia
We got their menu in the mail and decided that since tomorrow it’s Thanksgiving and we’ve been cooking all day, let’s try take out. We usually order from Mario’s but decided to try out this “new” joint.The delivery guy was very warm and professional, the food was heavenly, perfect taste and temperature. We will be sure to order here in the near future.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Grohs
Best Italian Resturant in a 50 mile Radius.
Saint James
So long, Pietros. La Bella left a void no pizzeria could hope to fill; yet somehow you managed. You made damn good pizza for us in OB homie, now make some for God.Rest in Peace homie.
donny chang
Did this place close down for good? Terrible. I have to order from Umberto’s now which isn’t as good and is more expensive.
Best pizza in town in Oyster BayMarlo The New Owner is Great! Keep it up Mama Mias!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma
Great Buffalo wings, pizza and pastaVery homey atmosphereDefinitely will be back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've ordered food from Mama Mia's for both my office and family, and let me tell you, they never disappoint. Whether it's takeout or delivery, they are consistently great - always on time, and the food tastes fresh and delicious. Marlo, the new owner, is truly the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered catering from Mama Mia's for my office on a friend's recommendation and it was a hit! Every dish was loved by all - the delivery was punctual, and the food arrived fresh and delicious. Definitely making this a go-to for future office catering. Can't wait to order again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Peppers, Eggplant Rollatini, House, Margherita Pizza, Grandma, Rice Ball, Meatballs, Brooklyn Sicilian Pie Slice
best pizza in oyster bay !! great kind people working here providing the best service !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered dinner online at 6:45. Estimated delivery was 8:07. Out for delivery at 7:50 and the food did not arrive until 8:35. The chicken is soggy and the salad is warmer than the spaghetti. Not worth $50.00
nothing to do with Italian food, I thought I didn't make it at home anymore. I went with my family to buy slices for my children and I ordered some stuff mushrooms. When the food arrived, the pizza was burnt and tasteless and the mushrooms were slimy. I should have ordered McDonald's. , I'm staying with Marios Pizzeria, my family misses the old team
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurant was clean and had enough space/seating available. Staff was friendly and the service was fast. Hawaiian slice had good flavor, but being a deep dish crust, it felt like too much dough for it. Sicilian slice was thick as it should be but needed some more sauce. Vodka grandma slice tasted a bit dry and the crust was thicker compared to other pizzerias. Regular grandma slice had great flavor but needed some more sauce throughout each slice. White slice was loaded with a very thick layer of cheese with a good thin crust, but some complained of it being too salty.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
We live in Dix Hills, if by chance we are in the area; we always take out from here. From the slices to the sandwiches and dishes they're awesome. Hands down one of the best personal pies on the island. Treat yourself to their chef's cuisine you will not regret it, that I promise you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They do great pizza and the employees are very friendly
Restaurantji Recommends
Had no idea Oyster Bay was so fast to deliver to Syosset... in 30 minutes or so we had an Everything pizza delivered... feared the worst because I ALWAYS pick up.. Under the weather had to default to delivery... this Everything Pizza arrived hot and with tons of delicious toppings.. bottom crust a bit dark... but better than raw for this heavily topped pizza... Delivery man was energetic and friendly. Nice vibe all around here. Would get again.... Thanks for the perfect stay at home dinner tonight.
We got their menu in the mail and decided that since tomorrow it’s Thanksgiving and we’ve been cooking all day, let’s try take out. We usually order from Mario’s but decided to try out this “new” joint.The delivery guy was very warm and professional, the food was heavenly, perfect taste and temperature. We will be sure to order here in the near future.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Italian Resturant in a 50 mile Radius.
So long, Pietros. La Bella left a void no pizzeria could hope to fill; yet somehow you managed. You made damn good pizza for us in OB homie, now make some for God.Rest in Peace homie.
Did this place close down for good? Terrible. I have to order from Umberto’s now which isn’t as good and is more expensive.