They have been around for a long time and continuously excellent for food and service. The noise remains due to acoustics so I turned my hearing aid lower and you get used to it The prices are fair considering Bidenomics, and they show their class by not charging for the use of Credit Cards. Got to get back here soon.
Bill Albert
Great food great lunch special.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oysters on the Half Shell, Thai Shrimp
Carrie's Berrys
Delicious comfort food in a beautiful, rustic setting.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Dish
Gary R.
A gem In oyster bay. Been missing wild honey since they closed a location In port. Unfortunately because of distance to this location it's not one of our go to choices when we're going out for dinner. But each time we go we say why don't we go more often. The food and service is that good. As weather gets nicer I'm sure we will be coming more often. We always start with 2 martinis and probably one of our favorite apps anywhere the skillet roasted mussels. While I like mussels the way wild honey prepares them they take them to another level. Restaurant always has great specials each night that are usually amazing choices.
Thomas T.
We had dinner here last weekend and not impressed. The ambience was nice with dim lighting and the service was good. The food was not very good. My gf ordered fish and it had no flavor. I ordered the pork chop and it had no flavor i had to sprinkle tons of salt and pepper on it. Will NOT ever eat here again. Oh and the oysters did not taste very fresh and we know delicious oysters!
Bri T.
great food great town ribs are amazing as is everything els on the menu. always my go to when i visit this town.
Nicholas Patti
If you want a first class dinner in a cozy romantic place this is the place! The food is off the charts and pricing is a bargain with food quality and unique dishes. The ribs . . . Good luck trying to keep the meat on the bone. UNREAL!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Esposito
Classic Oyster Bay; quaint but yet modern restaurant. Food is great, dessert is even greater. I've been there about 4 times over the years and it just gets better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alejandro Fernandez
Excellent Place.
Annette Park
When you first walk in there is a quiet and dark atmosphere. The waitress rarely came to the table so we had to call her over multiple times during our visit but she was friendly. The food was salty and over seasoned. I got the cracker crusted wild flounder and it was soggy, as if it was sitting in the sauce for too long. Another person at my table got the vegan pad Thai with chicken and it was super salty and the sauce was way too powerful and tasted like soy sauce, not pad Thai. We also got the Thai shrimp and it was also super salty. Overall we will not be going again.Vegetarian options: Not good and only 1 main course option.
We visited for lunch. Enjoyed the wine and dine menu, avocado hummus plate, salmon tostada and a generous pour of wine.My companion enjoyed the crispy chicken sandwich. Food was fresh and delicious, service was great …place has a nice vibe….looking forward to returning soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katherine A.
I have been frequenting Wild Honey since moving to Oyster Bay. I am always made to feel welcome, even with young children. I am always impressed with the food. The beet and goat cheese salad is delicious. I highly recommend this establishment :)
Amanda T.
My husband and I decided we always wanted to revisit Oyster Bay since it is the town where we chose to purchase our wedding bands at the Jewelry Gallery right nearby. My Hubby specifically wanted to take me out for oysters since he knows my love for them and they gotta be good if they are in a town called Oyster Bay! He came across Wild Honey and I have to say he knows how to pick an outstanding restaurant! We came around 12pm when they first opened and the staff were so friendly and warm. We chose a quaint, cozy corner table and dined on various starts from blackberry oysters (the pineapple mignonette they are served with is incredible!), spinach and truffle baked oysters, the filet mignon Texas toast (a MUST order, absolutely delicious), and the mushroom tatter tots, to drink a peach margarita (also a must order) and the Parisian. We loved our dining experience here so much and truly enjoyed our time spent here. We think we'll make it a yearly tradition to always come back and revisit. We even dedicated each oyster I ate to a month from the past year and chose to reflect on our favorite parts of each month haha, we always know how to make the most of our dates :)
Tom Gallucci
Food was great, but we’re pretty sure they purposefully made a “mistake” in their math to charge us an extra $100 for a group of 7. They do their bills by hand rather than machine, which made it easy for them to simply add incorrectly to their advantage. They corrected it when we brought it to their attention, but barely apologized. Sneaky. Be careful. And it’s a shame because the food was very good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Brian T.
One of my favorite spots. The food is consistently delicious and the staff makes you feel at home. It is like the "Cheers" of Oyster Bay! A must try!
They have been around for a long time and continuously excellent for food and service. The noise remains due to acoustics so I turned my hearing aid lower and you get used to it The prices are fair considering Bidenomics, and they show their class by not charging for the use of Credit Cards. Got to get back here soon.
Great food great lunch special.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oysters on the Half Shell, Thai Shrimp
Delicious comfort food in a beautiful, rustic setting.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Dish
A gem In oyster bay. Been missing wild honey since they closed a location In port. Unfortunately because of distance to this location it's not one of our go to choices when we're going out for dinner. But each time we go we say why don't we go more often. The food and service is that good. As weather gets nicer I'm sure we will be coming more often. We always start with 2 martinis and probably one of our favorite apps anywhere the skillet roasted mussels. While I like mussels the way wild honey prepares them they take them to another level. Restaurant always has great specials each night that are usually amazing choices.
We had dinner here last weekend and not impressed. The ambience was nice with dim lighting and the service was good. The food was not very good. My gf ordered fish and it had no flavor. I ordered the pork chop and it had no flavor i had to sprinkle tons of salt and pepper on it. Will NOT ever eat here again. Oh and the oysters did not taste very fresh and we know delicious oysters!
great food great town ribs are amazing as is everything els on the menu. always my go to when i visit this town.
If you want a first class dinner in a cozy romantic place this is the place! The food is off the charts and pricing is a bargain with food quality and unique dishes. The ribs . . . Good luck trying to keep the meat on the bone. UNREAL!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Classic Oyster Bay; quaint but yet modern restaurant. Food is great, dessert is even greater. I've been there about 4 times over the years and it just gets better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent Place.
When you first walk in there is a quiet and dark atmosphere. The waitress rarely came to the table so we had to call her over multiple times during our visit but she was friendly. The food was salty and over seasoned. I got the cracker crusted wild flounder and it was soggy, as if it was sitting in the sauce for too long. Another person at my table got the vegan pad Thai with chicken and it was super salty and the sauce was way too powerful and tasted like soy sauce, not pad Thai. We also got the Thai shrimp and it was also super salty. Overall we will not be going again.Vegetarian options: Not good and only 1 main course option.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Seafood, Thai Shrimp
Restaurantji Recommends
We visited for lunch. Enjoyed the wine and dine menu, avocado hummus plate, salmon tostada and a generous pour of wine.My companion enjoyed the crispy chicken sandwich. Food was fresh and delicious, service was great …place has a nice vibe….looking forward to returning soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been frequenting Wild Honey since moving to Oyster Bay. I am always made to feel welcome, even with young children. I am always impressed with the food. The beet and goat cheese salad is delicious. I highly recommend this establishment :)
My husband and I decided we always wanted to revisit Oyster Bay since it is the town where we chose to purchase our wedding bands at the Jewelry Gallery right nearby. My Hubby specifically wanted to take me out for oysters since he knows my love for them and they gotta be good if they are in a town called Oyster Bay! He came across Wild Honey and I have to say he knows how to pick an outstanding restaurant! We came around 12pm when they first opened and the staff were so friendly and warm. We chose a quaint, cozy corner table and dined on various starts from blackberry oysters (the pineapple mignonette they are served with is incredible!), spinach and truffle baked oysters, the filet mignon Texas toast (a MUST order, absolutely delicious), and the mushroom tatter tots, to drink a peach margarita (also a must order) and the Parisian. We loved our dining experience here so much and truly enjoyed our time spent here. We think we'll make it a yearly tradition to always come back and revisit. We even dedicated each oyster I ate to a month from the past year and chose to reflect on our favorite parts of each month haha, we always know how to make the most of our dates :)
Food was great, but we’re pretty sure they purposefully made a “mistake” in their math to charge us an extra $100 for a group of 7. They do their bills by hand rather than machine, which made it easy for them to simply add incorrectly to their advantage. They corrected it when we brought it to their attention, but barely apologized. Sneaky. Be careful. And it’s a shame because the food was very good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
One of my favorite spots. The food is consistently delicious and the staff makes you feel at home. It is like the "Cheers" of Oyster Bay! A must try!