Muddy Waters Café
100 Division St, Palmyra
(315) 502-4197
Customers' Favorites
The 4 Panini Chicken
Fardowner Sandwich
Menu
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I love this local spot serving up sandwiches, salads, drinks, and cookies. In a town filled with mostly heavy food options, this is a welcome change and feels like you’re having a meal at a friend’s home. The portions are perfect and the location, especially in the warmer months, can’t be beat.
Have heard good things about this place for several years so, when a friend and I were looking for a place to meet up near Palmyra, we thought we'd give Muddy Waters a try. Small cozy dining room overlooking the Canal was perfect atmosphere for conversation. We both ordered a breakfast sandwich on a ciabatta roll. It was as good as any I've had ever.
Stopped in here the morning after Halloween. It was sooooo charming! The owner was the cook and cashier. No table side service.
We split a delicious turkey, basil and Swiss cheese panini. It was delicious! Feel like $3 for a cup of coffee was steep but the sandwich was reasonably priced at $9.50, I think.
There is outside seating in warmer months as well. Decor is very charming...
Donna, the owner isn't very warm...
We split a delicious turkey, basil and Swiss cheese panini. It was delicious! Feel like $3 for a cup of coffee was steep but the sandwich was reasonably priced at $9.50, I think.
There is outside seating in warmer months as well. Decor is very charming...
Donna, the owner isn't very warm...
You May Also Like
Nima's Pizzeria - 165 E Main St
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Italian, American, Vegetarian
Happiness Garden - 212 E Main St
![]()
Chinese, Asian