No. 1 Sushi - Pearl River

79 N Middletown Rd, Pearl River
(845) 735-4991

Recent Reviews

Francisco Ramos

Excellent service

Nickolaus Beck

Always great sushi ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Spicy Tuna, Sushi or Sashimi Appetizer, Chicken Teriyaki

John H.

Great place in the heart of pearl River. They have an all you can eat option that's true to its name. Service is good and decor is updated. Definitely worth you time and money. You won't leave hungry. Try the salmon salad

john morales

Don’t waste your time and your money there. try the one in Nanuet

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Oliver P.

We had the all you can eat sushi and the food was excellent. Our family does sushi once per week and everyone was impressed. Ambiance was average. Service was outstanding, picking up the straw wrappers left on the table, refilling drinks and bringing food fast. We will be back for sure.

Jill D.

I came here after picking up the kids from camp on a Tuesday afternoon. It was about 5pm, so it was slow until we were leaving. We were the only ones there at the beginning, and we sat in a corner behind a wall. This made it tough to see and signal our waiter. Our writer was great, besides not being able to see him. We ordered three rolls, an order of sashimi, and tempura. The Naturo roll was salmon, tuna, crab, and avocado wrapped in cucumber. We've never had a rice-free roll before and enjoyed it very much! We thought in ordering the chicken tempura, it would be a small plate of chicken tempura. To our surprise, it was 5 tempura veggies and 2 chicken.

Napawan Sriprom

I am very upset with the food quality. My husband and I went there for All You Can Eat ($30.95 per person). We ordered special roll sushi but all it tastes like imitation meat.Especially, the topping on sushi, you can see on my pictures. It is such a huge amount of topping, its almost the same size as sushi. It makes you full very quickly and its taste like a fake filler like flavored flour.We could not finish all of them. Anyway, it was bad experience for me, we will never go there again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Trevor Smith

Avoid this place.Nice seating, friendly waiters, BUT....The sushi was imitation meat, the spicy tuna was just a rice flavored tuna mush, and the toppings weren't fishy at all.The unlimited sushi is definitely fishy... pun intended.Avoid and go to a different location and restaurant all together.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Corinne Duffy

Went here for AYCE - they offered us the corner booth, which was probably a mistake, because once it got busy, they forgot all about us back there. My boyfriend had to order his dessert from two different waitresses, and he still never ended up getting it. Waitresses were helping the tables surrounding us, but rarely came to our table. The food was great otherwise (the gyoza & Angry Dragon Roll were delicious!), but once it got busier, the service was severely lacking. I've been to the Midland Park location and never had this issue, so was disappointed since this location is closer to me.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Gyoza

Steve Adams

Fantastic price for all you can eat sushi that is actually good. Spent years going here weekly with friends! Kitchen food is good too!

Randeep Singh

Rude service and had a waiter chase me out of the restaurant asking for a bigger tip despite leaving 20%

Nikolaos Pamfilis

The worst!!! All the kitchen menu was awful! The servers did not have a good attitude at all!

Brianna T.

I am a regular at this establishment. Yesterday, there was a bug in my ginger when served our sushi. I'm assuming the man who we told was not just a server but even some sort of management.. there was no apologetic notes to his voice and a simple "what do you want?" This man sees me coming in frequently throughout the years and I was surprised there was no discount or apology. The sushi + food is overall very good. But a bug? No thanks! Also as most of you know prices have gone up, all you can eat is now $29.99

Cole Wiseltier

Giving this a 1 star because can’t rate it anything less. So a few days ago we stopped by this place to have dinner. We used to go to this place weekly before Covid. We specifically did the all you can eat option. First we ordered the appetizers and salads. Kani salad took 10-15 minutes to come out but tasted decent. We asked for crunch on the salad and you guessed it, salad came with no crunch on it. After this incident we forgot about that and moved onto the sushi. We ordered a normal amount of sushi and nothing too complicated just a few maki and special rolls. After waiting about 40-45 minutes a peice of our order comes and they tell us we’ve ran out of yellowtail and white tuna. WHAT SUSHI RESTAURANT RUNS OUT OF YELLOWTAIL AND WHITE TUNA. After this issue we end up ordering some other rolls that didn’t include the fish that they didn’t have. We notice that this order is taking a horrendous amount of time to be made. Then we figure out that our sushi order that we put in first has been overrided by a takeout order that was placed 10 minutes after we placed our order. I’m my mind that’s not fair to make people who are dining in your restaurant wait for a takeout order especially if we placed our order first. Finally our rolls came, almost felt like a Christmas present cause Christmas was coming faster then they made this order. Rolls were small and not filling at all but we just forgot about it and hoped desert would be better then the rest of the meal. We ordered green tea, red bean, and vanilla ice cream which came out more icy then a literal ice cube. All I’m saying is this place has really gone down hill and it sucks to see a place that you used to love dining at become a place that you will never eat at again. Ps, don’t come here unless you wanna be unhappy with your dinner.

Dominique Dubay

Sushi and service was amazing! The prices were super reasonable for the quality of food and the service was quick! They did accidentally charge us for soup that was included with the hibachi meal but they were able to correct it.

Load More