Great place for ice cream (custard). Flavors are unique and delicious.
Bethany Brady
Excellent service, delicious ice cream, relaxing atmosphere. I highly recommend.
Julia Sullivan
Fantastic custard, my favorites were the blue flower, apple crumble, and vanilla. They even have the ducks in the back that the get their eggs from. A great spot to visit!!!
Joe Moore
Best ice cream in NY
Christopher Mamrol
It’s really good ice cream. I got a flight of ice cream. Reasonable price and beautiful location
Nathan Trudell
Best ice cream place. Has ducks. Ice cream flavors are all very good. If it wasn’t so far away I would come often. Also the bathroom is very clean.
Tamara Mitchell
Really delicious and extra creamy - thanks ducks! The apple caramel was a fall treat.
Danielle Quintanilla
Delicious ice cream!! Loved being able to see the ducks who make it possible too. Definitely get a flight because you'll want to try every flavor!
Lacey Randall
We absolutely love the Spotted Duck Creamery—the ice cream here is truly some of the best we’ve ever had! Every flavor is so fresh and delicious, and it’s always a treat to bring friends and family when they’re visiting.
That said, I was a little disappointed on our most recent visit. I arrived at 8:00 PM, and although they close at 8:30 PM, when I ordered the Seneca Flight (which includes eight different flavors), they opted to split it into two cups—four scoops in each—instead of serving it in the traditional flight style. I was especially excited to share the full flight experience with my family visiting from Virginia Beach, so it was a bit of a letdown not to get the signature presentation.
Overall though, it was still a great experience, and the ice cream itself never disappoints. I’d just encourage the team to consider offering the full experience up until closing, especially for guests who make a point to arrive before the posted hours end. We’ll definitely be back!
J C
I love ice cream, and this was no exception. Scout Vineyards (our fave) recommended Spotted Duck to us. It is a little pricey but completely worth it.
Great place for ice cream (custard). Flavors are unique and delicious.
Excellent service, delicious ice cream, relaxing atmosphere. I highly recommend.
Fantastic custard, my favorites were the blue flower, apple crumble, and vanilla. They even have the ducks in the back that the get their eggs from. A great spot to visit!!!
Best ice cream in NY
It’s really good ice cream. I got a flight of ice cream. Reasonable price and beautiful location
Best ice cream place. Has ducks. Ice cream flavors are all very good. If it wasn’t so far away I would come often. Also the bathroom is very clean.
Really delicious and extra creamy - thanks ducks! The apple caramel was a fall treat.
Delicious ice cream!! Loved being able to see the ducks who make it possible too. Definitely get a flight because you'll want to try every flavor!
We absolutely love the Spotted Duck Creamery—the ice cream here is truly some of the best we’ve ever had! Every flavor is so fresh and delicious, and it’s always a treat to bring friends and family when they’re visiting. That said, I was a little disappointed on our most recent visit. I arrived at 8:00 PM, and although they close at 8:30 PM, when I ordered the Seneca Flight (which includes eight different flavors), they opted to split it into two cups—four scoops in each—instead of serving it in the traditional flight style. I was especially excited to share the full flight experience with my family visiting from Virginia Beach, so it was a bit of a letdown not to get the signature presentation. Overall though, it was still a great experience, and the ice cream itself never disappoints. I’d just encourage the team to consider offering the full experience up until closing, especially for guests who make a point to arrive before the posted hours end. We’ll definitely be back!
I love ice cream, and this was no exception. Scout Vineyards (our fave) recommended Spotted Duck to us. It is a little pricey but completely worth it.
Restaurantji Recommends
Voted the best ice cream (in the state?) - and our party of six concurred. Flavors were all different and well done.
Dietary restrictions: Had two dairy free options - one of our party has a dairy allergy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yummy duck egg ice cream. Unique flavors
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great creamy ice cream/custard. We had three kids 5 years and younger and the ducks on site were a big hit!
We loved the flights!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Creamy custard was good, but I wouldn't consider it the best in New York. But very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salted Caramel, Frozen Custard
Amazing ice cream! You will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...