Wager's Cider Mill

256 E Main St, Penn Yan
(315) 536-6640

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mike Smith

Great farmstand, but not much else. Sell AMAZING apple related products. Kids raved about cider donuts! I liked the hard cider and regular cider. They have a ton of types of apples. Don't go expecting more than an awesome apple farm stand. BUT 100% worth a visit.

Alex Anderson

My new favorite cider and donut place. I’ve been telling everybody I know about it.

Danielle Quintanilla

Amazing fresh cider!! Make sure to try the donuts too and grab some of their picked apples! They have some outdoor seating too

Titan Prime

The most amazing Apple Cider and Cider Doughnuts in the Finger Lakes. Family owned & operated. Running one of the oldest Apple presses in the Country.

Amazing selection of their own Apples too!!! A must!

Dean Wyant

Cider, cider donuts, New York cheddar cheese, applesauce, apple jelly, apples, fruit pies and a lot more.
So good.

Pete J

Nice place to get fresh apples, cider and doughnuts.

Jason Bunnell

Family owned and operated with some of the best pies you can find. The family has their own apple orchards and are a great supply of local apples and cider.

M. Zimmerman

We love the Autumn Crisp apples ?? and of course the cider donuts!

Trapper Traphagen

Cider donuts are awesome! They have cheese,cider, maple iced donuts, cider donuts. All fresh!

Gail Tack

We drive down for Apple Pies every year. Best crust ever.

Reta Lewis

Beautiful place, very friendly, great tasting apples and plums.
Great prices as well ? ?
Thanks for a lovely visit.

Laura Hernandez

Best cider and cider donuts you’ll ever have. Fresh apples and other great items for purchase. This is a must visit if you’re in the area.

Anne Killen

Most delicious cider and fresh donuts around! they also had fresh grape juice. Wonderful!

Elaine Ambrose

Great Autumn tradition.

Tamara Mancuso

Pressed cider, not cooked, just like when we were young! Tasty donuts, we were surprised that they were quite small. At $11 a dozen. Hmmm.

Loading...