Third and Company Lakeside

3649 NY-52, Pine Bush
(845) 524-4874

Recent Reviews

My Whole Family Essentials (Tricia Doebler)

Our family has held so many events here and we keep coming back because of the awesome food, service and atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmella Damiano

I am giving this restaurant one star because it doesn’t allow zero and I gave it to the atmosphere because while it is a nice location it was not worth the headache! In the beginning the owner was willing to work with me so that the venue would fit my budget we changed the menu and all was set I payed in cash but upon leaving my husband was slapped with a big bill I did add donuts to the menu morning of but not 1500 dollars worth later we were told it was for food that was not ordered nor discussed. The staff took it upon themselves to replenish trays of food that never got eaten and were sent home in doggie bags only to be discarded because I was less then impressed with the food the quality was very different then anything I’ve had while dining. I have yet to get an answer or a refund and continue to reach out very unprofessional and not good business!

Atmosphere: 1

may “Hudson valley explorer”

Great burgers and perfect

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A P

Absolutely love it here and now will forever hold a special place in my heart. I just got married here. Everything was absolutely beautiful and perfect. Our families absolutely loved everything. Not just our wedding but everytime we have ate here we have never been disappointed. Definitely go check this place out. We love it since the first time we came here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wet Chickens

Great restaurant however the staff is very rude. I would not recommend it here simply because of a worker.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Whitetail Hunter

It was okay. Beautiful inside/outside decor. Service was friendly. The food however left A LOT to be desired. We got the fish and chips, would have done better swinging by McDs for 12 limpy fries and 3 fish sticks out of box of Captain Gordon's...?‍♂️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 4

Cody Van Houten

They've done an amazing job bringing this location back to life with the renovations. The food is impressive and delicious. I have had great dinners as well as officiated a spectacular wedding here and was not one bit dissatisfied. Would recommend 100%

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken and Waffles

A M

Absolutely beautiful place. We fell in love to much with this place we are getting Married here in October. Everyone here is so nice and the food is amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Luke Kaufman

This place feels like what would happen if you turned AI loose on Joanna Gaines' Pinterest page and said make me a restaurant. Everything about the decor and property is meticulous and well maintained. I actually thought they just opened because the property was so clean. The staff was extremely awesome. Quick to serve, quick with drinks, quick to check back, and very friendly.Now, the less good news. The food. I had the French onion soup. This was very obviously a pot of beef stock that they dumped onions in. That's it. They did not caramelize the onions and build that deep flavor. This was beef stock, with rough sliced onions dumped in and simmered for a bit. No salt, pepper, nothing. Then to finish it off they put two pieces of baguette in there with a slice of cheese on top and I think either microwaved it or put a lid/cover on it to soften the cheese as there was zero browning. This was not put under a broiler. Wasn't terrible once I added salt and pepper but it's hard to hate beef broth, bread, and cheese.The shrimp po boy was a disaster. But you could tell parts of it were made with care. Like the tomatoes were seasoned, dressed, and blanched in some manner. However the roll was a raw, thick, chewy ciabatta roll that was so hard to bite through that as you did it crumbled and squeezed the breading off the shrimp and pushed out the tomatoes. Also there was nowhere near enough shrimp on this thing. I would say it had half of what would be needed to have a bite of shrimp in every bite. You can see in my pictures the pile of crumpled raw bread that was leftover.Someone really has put a lot of care into this restaurant and it shows. They just need someone to help dial in their menu. I can't even say that maybe the main cook had the night off as both simple dishes I ordered felt like no one making them had ever attempted to eat them or seen how they are supposed to be made. Beautiful place though, even the parking lot was magical, but they need to hire a consultant or bring in a chef and make some changes to the menu. I would come back for sure if there was some announcement like "new menu" or "now with a chef on staff" but until then this restaurant is a beautifully cared for place to take a picture of and maybe have a beer or wine before going to dinner somewhere else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Fran Mazza

The waitresses are rude, rude you can’t ask them a question I act like you’re bothering them and they have hardly any tables. It’s not even crowded and there’s five waitresses and they can’t be bothered. I won’t come back here again never even came back after she gave us the food to ask us if everything was good or if we needed anything

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Mackenzie Lockwood

Way over priced, my hamburger was dry. Staff was not acomding. Husbands meal came out Luke warm. I do NOT recommend it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Konggratz

Food is subpar owner is very rude had an issue with my meal spoke with the waitress she made me feel as if i was bothering her last time they will see our

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Randall Palmer

Awesome local restaurant with top notch service and food. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee

Bart Panessa

Friday night wife and I eat dinner only to have a cockroach run across our table my wife was mortified I spoke to the manager his remark was we're in the country I do not recommend

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tara C.

First went there for a wedding. Excellent service and very hard working and kind servers. Food was great! Returned with friends. Love the outdoor seating. The food and beer selection was great. Will return!

Load More

Third and Company Lakeside

3649 NY-52, Pine Bush, NY 12566
(845) 524-4874