The Fair Shake

1509 Penna Ave, Pine City
(607) 732-4536

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Don Dolaway

awesome staff and excellent ice cream!!!

Paul Wood

Stop for a cone, as often as I can.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim Good

So many flavors it was hard to decide what to get

Chloe McNaney

The Graceland milkshake is the way to go if you like peanut butter and banana, it has to perfect ratio and is no longer on the menu but the girls will still make it if you ask!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katherine Ryan

Me and my BF just had ice cream and it was great! Friendly staff and quick service. We will go again.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim Hamilton

Banana pudding polar freeze is my favorite go too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carrmen J Narde

Their sundae menu is massive ... you can't go wrong going to The Fair Shake!!!

John Phipps, Jr.

Glad you are still open, great place to still visit after all these years! Great flavors and recipes for sundaes!

Heidi Scharett

Very nice polite employees. Very good place for family. Will recommend

Hannah Bennett

Ice Cream is great! Great selection, staff is always friendly and smiling!

Brittany Leone

Delicious and friendly staff. cash only but has an atm

nootchieQ

The most pleasant servers; best quality ice cream both soft and hard, amazingselection of flavors and fair prices on amount served!!!!

Jesse Morgan

Excellent service and selection.. beautiful place to enjoy ice cream...

Tina Hoyles

Nice kind and generous employees

Patty Brown

Awesome as Always 10 out of 10

Loading...