Pine Island Tap House

We hosted our wedding welcome party last weekend at Pine Island Tap House and it was a wonderful experience! Peter made it so easy to work with them to host our party. Our group was welcomed early to set up, the staff were super friendly and helpful all night. It was so fun having the food trucks onsite for our guests to enjoy. Peter even went out of his way to get us a second truck for the evening so we had more options. Our guests loved the mix of indoor / outdoor space - and the staff graciously set up the fire pits for us to enjoy in the evening! Our friends and family were raving about it and kept asking us how we found such an awesome place! We would highly recommend Pine Island for a visit or any events!

Good place

I just found our that the name changed to the Pine Island Tap House. The place is clean, really nice, and air conditioned. Also, the band Cold Sweat were awesome! I haven't been here is about 4 years...I am so glad we stopped. We will be back. Thanks PITH for a good time. See you soon.

From the first time coming into the Taphouse it has been nothing short of friendly, welcoming and comfortable. They have a great assortment of craft beers, ciders, wines and cocktails not to mention the great inhouse Banished Brewlng selection! They also have a diverse mix of good food trucks which is a juggling act in itself with the climate of unreliability and lack of commitment of today. They also have great entertainment and fun events.The staff is nothing short of excellent, extremely attentive and helpful. The owner's commitment to excellence is evident in their consistency to offer top shelf staff, product and cleanliness while offering a relaxed, comfortable experience. Congrats on your hard earned 3 year celebration!

Their expression is "local brews and sunset views" and it totally applies. I have yet to find a place that has such a great constant rotation of beer, wine, and spirits. It's always a great time!

Great beer, nice atmosphere, friendly service. What more do you want?

An amazing jewel in the Warwick Valley! Amazing beers and wonderful staff.

We are frequent patrons of the Pine Island Tap House which now has Banished Brewing attached. They are always so nice and have a wonderful beer selection. We recently needed a space to have a birthday party and reached out. At a very reasonable rate, the owner welcomed us to use the space to host the private event. We had about 50 people and had it catered. He provided us with tables, helped set up, and provided a staff member to wait on our event members. Ashley, Evan, and Aly are always fantastic but the whole time they were making sure we were covered or if we needed anything at all. I would highly recommend this space for a private event but also just for your casual night out with a bar menu as well as always having food trucks outside!

This place is awesome! Came here after another brewery was closed due to winter hours and instead of driving further south came here instead and was not dissatisfied! Had a flight of their local in house beers and they really were tasty! The food truck option outside was ridiculously superb! Friendly staff and worth coming in! They also offer local products for cocktails or neat drinks! Stop in and have a drink here! Patronize this place!

We had a private party at the Tap House and it exceeded our expectations. The owner and his staff were amazing to work with and so accommodating. Our guests were so impressed with the quality of drinks and how beautifully decorated it was for Christmas. We cannot recommend this establishment enough! We can’t wait to host another event here in the future.

Slamming beers, super nice staff, they had a food truck outside whxuh looked banging. Two thumbs up!

Great vibe, great beer and local spirits. Band completed the night, fun times!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Very disappointed in my experience at this establishment. Haven’t been back since it changed ownership and the brewery closed but decided to give it a try. The female bartender was very rude and seemed to cater to the regulars. Not a single employee came to check on us and if it weren’t for the good food from the food truck and the live music, it would have been a complete waste. The beer from the new brewery recently affiliated with the tap house was nothing to rave about but that wasn’t even a reason for the low score. This place was far better as Pine Island Brewing with friendlier staff and superior local beer. Do yourself a favor and head up the road a little to Glenmere Brewing for superior beer and staff. ????

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Great atmosphere and service with excellent beer! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Excellent atmosphere and fantastic bartender’

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pretzel