Consistently delicious! I purchased a cauliflower crust pizza - it was the absolute best I’ve ever had! It was crispy and full of flavor, evident in the picture attached. Many places fail with the cauliflower crust by letting it get soggy, but not Benny’s! We have previously purchased many different pies - plain, pepperoni, Hawaiian, chicken bacon ranch, buffalo chicken - and all have been absolutely amazing. We have also had their garlic knots, bread sticks and beef patties which are also great every time! Being able to rely on their consistency has been amazing. I will definitely be back for more and recommend to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J
I'm happy I found this place! Delicious NYC style pizza! We have been ordering the regular cheese pizza but will definitely try the other options there as well in the future. The service is always super friendly and attentive. The location is very central but a little hidden from the main road (jusy around the corner from it) so I found out about this place after someone recommended it. Thank you Benny's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ariana Berisha
Must must must stop in. This place is a gem. Pizza is thin, has a nice crisp to it. Garlic knots are the old school traditional ones, smothered in olive oil and garlic. Wings both buffalo & bbq were fall off the bone tender. Damn… got my mouth watering just thinking about the food. The owner Benny took great care of myself and family- treated us like his. We will be back to enjoy ourselves soon again.
Delicious!!!! So excited for a really good pizza place in pleasant valley!!!
Food: 5
Concetta Lozito
The owners are very friendly, the service was great and sicilian pizza was thick and delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Garlic Knots
Robert T
Tried this place out 3 times already and hasn't failed me. The Pizza's are amazing and great selections to choose from. Great service, owner operator which is a rare gem to find these days. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Meat Calzone, Sausage and Pepper Roll
stephen difiore
Great slices had pepperoni and sausage-huge slices great value, and quality, friendly guys that were working.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Cepeda
Moved to this area and we were in search of a good pizzeria, I believe we found it.
Food: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Knots
sam hickey
Finally, I have my go to pizzeria in the Hudson Valley. Benny is truly great at his craft and has always provided the highest level of service. Can’t recommend enough. Personal favorites, Sicilian and Buffalo chicken pie. Definitely check it out if you haven’t already!
I Don’t Sugar Coat My Reviews…I only tell my experiences from the truth and real feelings ..of what I actually think of the Food Establishment's That I Patronized ..The Pizza Sucked… The dough had No flavor… Hardly any sauce on the pie.. And the garlic knots were hard… and the size .. of a golf ball… I would not recommend this place…!!
AMAZING PIZZA! Great service and very clean restaurant. Highly recommend, especially for larger catering orders.
Mike Valentino
Tried twice. Owner appears more worried about money than the food and customer satisfaction.Be warned- if you get a bad meal, you won’t get your money back- just another bad meal.Much better with the previous ownership.
Anthony Loussedes
I’ve been going to Bennys since it first opened. The staff, atmosphere, and food are all top notch. Every week I get something different and it always beats the last order. I’ve been searching for good, quality pizza for years in the area and finally feel like what I’m paying for is worth it. Toppings aren’t skimped, flavor is outstanding, and the best people to see each week. It’s never a bye, it’s a see you next week already!! Go to Bennys!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richie Sassa
Food is disgusting. No flavor. They have no business making food.. The service is horrible. Very rude and that guy Benny needs to buy delivery truck or efficient car to actually make deliveries, instead of taking an old benz as a Hand over from Daddy..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ayden Spagnoli
Amazing food! Amazing service! The New owner Benny is awesome! He’s very friendly, and the staff is fantastic. The buffalo chicken and the bread sticks are my favorite. I highly recommend this place to anyone who wants good pizza and a great environment.
Consistently delicious! I purchased a cauliflower crust pizza - it was the absolute best I’ve ever had! It was crispy and full of flavor, evident in the picture attached. Many places fail with the cauliflower crust by letting it get soggy, but not Benny’s! We have previously purchased many different pies - plain, pepperoni, Hawaiian, chicken bacon ranch, buffalo chicken - and all have been absolutely amazing. We have also had their garlic knots, bread sticks and beef patties which are also great every time! Being able to rely on their consistency has been amazing. I will definitely be back for more and recommend to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm happy I found this place! Delicious NYC style pizza! We have been ordering the regular cheese pizza but will definitely try the other options there as well in the future. The service is always super friendly and attentive. The location is very central but a little hidden from the main road (jusy around the corner from it) so I found out about this place after someone recommended it. Thank you Benny's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Must must must stop in. This place is a gem. Pizza is thin, has a nice crisp to it. Garlic knots are the old school traditional ones, smothered in olive oil and garlic. Wings both buffalo & bbq were fall off the bone tender. Damn… got my mouth watering just thinking about the food. The owner Benny took great care of myself and family- treated us like his. We will be back to enjoy ourselves soon again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Chicken Wings 12, Mozzarella Sticks
Delicious!!!! So excited for a really good pizza place in pleasant valley!!!
Food: 5
The owners are very friendly, the service was great and sicilian pizza was thick and delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Garlic Knots
Tried this place out 3 times already and hasn't failed me. The Pizza's are amazing and great selections to choose from. Great service, owner operator which is a rare gem to find these days. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Meat Calzone, Sausage and Pepper Roll
Great slices had pepperoni and sausage-huge slices great value, and quality, friendly guys that were working.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Moved to this area and we were in search of a good pizzeria, I believe we found it.
Food: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Knots
Finally, I have my go to pizzeria in the Hudson Valley. Benny is truly great at his craft and has always provided the highest level of service. Can’t recommend enough. Personal favorites, Sicilian and Buffalo chicken pie. Definitely check it out if you haven’t already!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Wings 12
I Don’t Sugar Coat My Reviews…I only tell my experiences from the truth and real feelings ..of what I actually think of the Food Establishment's That I Patronized ..The Pizza Sucked… The dough had No flavor… Hardly any sauce on the pie.. And the garlic knots were hard… and the size .. of a golf ball… I would not recommend this place…!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
AMAZING PIZZA! Great service and very clean restaurant. Highly recommend, especially for larger catering orders.
Tried twice. Owner appears more worried about money than the food and customer satisfaction.Be warned- if you get a bad meal, you won’t get your money back- just another bad meal.Much better with the previous ownership.
I’ve been going to Bennys since it first opened. The staff, atmosphere, and food are all top notch. Every week I get something different and it always beats the last order. I’ve been searching for good, quality pizza for years in the area and finally feel like what I’m paying for is worth it. Toppings aren’t skimped, flavor is outstanding, and the best people to see each week. It’s never a bye, it’s a see you next week already!! Go to Bennys!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is disgusting. No flavor. They have no business making food.. The service is horrible. Very rude and that guy Benny needs to buy delivery truck or efficient car to actually make deliveries, instead of taking an old benz as a Hand over from Daddy..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amazing food! Amazing service! The New owner Benny is awesome! He’s very friendly, and the staff is fantastic. The buffalo chicken and the bread sticks are my favorite. I highly recommend this place to anyone who wants good pizza and a great environment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5