Utterly Delicious

1898 US-44, Pleasant Valley
(845) 723-4261

Recent Reviews

Sort by
chaotica

I ordered a vanilla malted milkshake today and it was the best I've had! The staff was friendly too.

Tyson John

Travelled the world and this is by far some of the best Ice cream I’ve ever had. Highly recommend. The store feels like a family store and not like a franchise. The staff were super happy and made it a great experience. Making sure to stop here every time I’m in pleasant valley

Finley Faust

ice cream was great, vibes were weird…. two guys were behind the counter and when i walked in they both got up and just stared at me silently until i finally ordered. i had never been here before so i was hoping to take my time trying to figure out what i wanted.
i didn’t even feel comfortable enough to sit down and enjoy it, i just instantly left when i got my ice cream. i felt really pressured to hurry up and just picked something random and one of them ended up sighing loud enough for me to hear when he had to open a new container of ice cream.
i felt like i was just an inconvenience to them to make them do their job? other guy was nice enough when he spoke, but just didn’t like the way they stared when i was trying to figure out what i wanted. it was just weird.

TLDR; go here for the ice cream, not the vibes.

Mijael Da

Best soft serve twirl ever.

Jennifer Rangel

Delicious!!

Aaliyah Thomas

The ice cream is really good . The milkshakes are a good size and delicious . They are really nice there . But the hot fudge sundae is barely a sundae . They had a 4 by 4 little brownie in the bottom of a big cup and filled with ice cream the brownie was hard a tasted like cardboard .

Jamie Renda

Best ice cream around hands down! We look forward to their opening every Spring! Friendly staff!

Christina Joanne Ritter

I love utterly delicious they have the best ice cream ever the girls behind the counter are so sweet and kind definitely a go to yummy spot for a cold treat

Christina Lynn Hazygurl

I love utterly delicious they have the best ice cream ever the girls behind the counter are so sweet and kind definitely a go to yummy spot for a cold treat

Shannon Meagher

Best ice cream. Staff are great. They are nice and helpful

Zachary Noland

Great tasting ice cream, decent prices. Cute little shop. Also nice that it’s nearby other frequented places, made it a very convenient stop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Soft Serve

Vivienne Sell

A little pricey, bit delicious

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookie Dough

Veronica Hopkins

This was the first time in my 64 years that I believe I have had a Banana split... Yummy. The price was great the girl who waited on us was very helpful. And as we were leaving I realized the were actually closing up shop when we arrived and still never rushed us nor made us feel uncomfortable for being the so late. I would so go there again.

Dietary restrictions: They have dairy free options

Parking: It's a little place with a deli next door. It was later so no problem, but it is a large parking lot there should be no problem parking.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Split, Wet Walnuts Chocolate Syrup, Hot Fudge

tim scott

Yum always great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Soft Serve

Chris Snow-Hebel

Ice cream was delicious ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Soft Serve

Loading...