Better On A Bagel Deli
4960 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 473-5858
Customers' Favorites
Bagel with Cream Cheese & Nova Lox
Sausage Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Bagels
Breakfast Bagels and More
Bagels Breakfast
Sliced Lox Breakfast
Lox served by the lb.
Plain Cream Cheese by the Pound
Bagel with Butter Breakfast
Bagel with Cream Cheese Breakfast
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese Breakfast
Muffin Breakfast
Served with your choice of flavor.
Bagel with Cream Cheese and Nova Lox Breakfast
Salads by the lb.
Tuna Salad
Cold salad with shredded tuna.
Egg Salad
Chopped eggs that have been mixed with seasoning and mayo.
Macaroni Salad
Cold pasta salad made with macaroni noodles.
Potato Salad
Cold dish made from seasoned potatoes.
Chicken Salad
Chopped chicken that has been tossed in a creamy dressing.
Boar's Head by the lb.
Branded Deluxe Ham
Thinly sliced meat from a pig's leg.
Ovengold Turkey Breast
Poultry.
Maple Honey Turkey Breast
Poultry.
Cracked Pepper Turkey Breast
Poultry.
Deluxe Roast Beef
Sliced beef that has been cooked over dry heat.
Pastrami
Smoked and cured beef.
Bologna
Finlely sliced sausage.
Genoa Salami
Cured sausage.
Pepperoni
Seasoned beef and pork salami.
Grilled Chicken Cutlet
Thinly sliced grilled chicken.
Breaded Chicken Cutlet
Thinly sliced breaded chicken.
Sliced Lox
Cured salmon.
Boar's Head Cheeses by the lb.
American Cheese
Lacey Swiss Cheese
Provolone Cheese
Munster Cheese
Monterey Jack Cheese with Jalapeno
Mozzarella Cheese
Alpine Lace Swiss Cheese
Snacks
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Baked sweet dough.
Hals Chips
Original, sour cream and onion, Buffalo, vinegar, BBQ.
Muffins
Blueberry, corn, double chocolate, pumpkin, pistachio, chocolate chip.
Lunch Specialty Sandwiches
Philly Cheese Steak Lunch Sandwich
Grilled roast beef, sauteed onions, and melted American.
Long Islander Lunch Sandwich
Grilled roast beef, bacon, melted American, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Lunch Sandwich
Grilled chicken cutlet, ham, melted Swiss, and honey mustard.
Chicken Supreme Lunch Sandwich
Grilled chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.
New Yorker Lunch Sandwich
Grilled pastrami, melted Swiss, and mustard.
Gobbler Lunch Sandwich
Grilled honey maple turkey, melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.
Spicy Southwest Lunch Sandwich
Grilled cracked pepper turkey, pepper jack cheese, guacamole, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayo.
Chicken Philly Lunch Sandwich
Grilled chicken cutlet, American, sauteed onions, green peppers, and mushrooms.
Triple Play Lunch Sandwich
Ham, roast beef, turkey, American, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Cheese Head Lunch Sandwich
Swiss, American, muenster, provolone, and pepperj ack cheeses with lettuce, tomato, onions, and mayo.
Godfather Lunch Sandwich
Ham, pepperoni, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, red peppers, and Italian dressing.
Gym Special Lunch Sandwich
Turkey, alpine Swiss, lettuce, and tomato.
Boss Man Lunch Sandwich
Breaded chicken, cheddar, bacon, and BBQ sauce.
Chicken Caesar Lunch Sandwich
Grilled chicken, provolone, lettuce, and Caesar dressing.
The Patriot Lunch Sandwich
Grilled chicken, mozzarella, roasted peppers, and balsamic dressing.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Lunch Sandwich
Breaded chicken, cheddar, bacon, onions, and ranch dressing.
The Warrior Lunch Sandwich
Grilled chicken, melted mozzarella, roasted peppers, guacamole, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.
Quesadilla Lunch
Grilled chicken or roast beef with choice of cheese.
The Classic Lunch Sandwich
Grilled turkey, Swiss, and mustard on toasted rye bread.
The Royal Lunch Wrap
Turkey, muenster, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on a spinach wrap.
Bronx Bomber Lunch Sandwich
Grilled roast beef, melted mozzarella, BBQ sauce, and garlic and herb seasoning.
Mobster Meltdown Lunch Sandwich
Grilled pastrami, melted cheddar, bacon, coleslaw, and Russian dressing.
The Chipotle Chomper Lunch Sandwich
Cracked pepper turkey, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, and chipotle mayo.
Grilled Cheese Lunch Sandwich
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled. Add tomato for an additional charge.
Chicken Salad Lunch Sandwich
Chopped chicken that has been tossed in a creamy dressing. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Tuna Salad Lunch Sandwich
Chilled creamy mild fish sandwich. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Egg Salad Lunch Sandwich
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
Tuna Melt Lunch Sandwich
Hot sandwich with cheese and tuna. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Breaded Chicken Lunch Sandwich
Sandwich with boneless grilled or fried chicken. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Grilled Chicken Lunch Sandwich
Sandwich eith boneless grilled chicken. Add cheese for an additional charge.
BLT Lunch Sandwich
Bacon, lettuce, tomato. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Turkey BLT Lunch Sandwich
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Ham Lunch Sandwich
Thinly sliced meat from a pig's leg. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Salami Lunch Sandwich
Cured sausage sandwich. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Turkey Lunch Sandwich
Poultry sandwich. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Maple Turkey Lunch Sandwich
Poultry sandwich. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Cracker Pepper Turkey Lunch Sandwich
Poultry sandwich. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Roast Beef Lunch Sandwich
Sandwich with thinly sliced beef that has been cooked over a dry heat. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Pastrami Lunch Sandwich
Smoked and cured beef sandwich. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Bologna Lunch Sandwich
Finely sliced sausage sandwich. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Drinks
Poland Spring Water
Red Bull 12 oz. Large
Regular, watermelon, blueberry, coconut berry.
Apple & Eve
Orange, apple, cranberry, ruby red, fruit punch.
Iced Tea
Lemonade
Gatorade
Fruit punch, cool blue, orange, lime.
Iced Coffee
Monster
Regular, low carb.
Quick
Chocolate, double chocolate, strawberry, vanilla.
Red Bull Small
8 oz. Regular, low carb.
Snapple
16 oz. Lemon, diet lemon, peach, diet peach, half & half, diet half & half, raspberry, diet raspberry, kiwi, apple.
Bottled Soda
Coke, Diet Coke, Coke Zero, Cherry Coke, Ginger Ale, Sprite, Orange.
10 oz. Tropicana
Apple, orange, cranberry.
12 oz. Tropicana
Original.
Tropicana Carton
Original.
Yoo-Hoo
Coffee
3 Egg Skillets
Original Skillet (3 Eggs)
Hash browns, meat, and cheddar cheese.
Western Skillet (3 Eggs)
Hash browns, peppers, onions, ham, and cheese.
Spanish Skillet (3 Eggs)
Has browns, peppers, onions, cheese, and salsa.
Omelets
Italian Omelet
Spanish Omelet
Western Omelet
Low Cal Omelet
Jumbo Veggie Omelet
Egg Sandwiches
Hungry Man Sandwich
Three eggs cooked any style with your choice of two types of meat and it is served with extra American cheese.
Two Eggs
Three Eggs
One Egg
Healthy Man Sandwich
Three egg whites and turkey.
Hungry Man XXL
Three eggs cooked any style, comes with bacon, ham, sausage, extra American cheese, and home fries on the sandwich.
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We go out of our way to come here to get our bagels. They are the best by far. No good bagels in our area that are good. There big fat, Fluffy fresh all the time. Been coming here to get bagels for 20 years.
December 2024
The place looked very clean. The bagel was fresh, soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside, lots of cream cheese and very tasty. BLT on a roll, perfectly made. Wish I had gotten Cole slaw instead of macaroni thimble, bland. Coffee, well it doesn't taste like coffee. Perhaps because I've gotten used to Colombian coffee with hot milk, which is rich and flavorful. It seemed to lack the aroma and flavor of real coffee, with a slightly bitter aftertaste. I could be wrong,...
October 2024
Classic Long Island bagel shop. Really solid bagel sandwiches, and I loved the BEC. A small selection of drinks, and not a lot of different cream cheeses compared to other places. But they absolutely meet expectations for a LI bagel shop. I'll come back often because I'm an absolute sucker for a
August 2024
You May Also Like
PJ Sushi Teriyaki - 4950 Nesconset Hwy
![]()
Sushi, Japanese, Korean, Sushi Bar, Vegan
Carnival - 4900 Nesconset Hwy
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegan, Vegetarian