Gilshar Greek Cafe

1072 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 473-2909

Recent Reviews

Carol M

The Gyro is the best we’ve ever had even in Greece! (Just as a sidebar, in Greece, they serve their gyros with french fries ) The Greek salad is superb. I would love to have their salad dressing recipe!. The owners are dedicated to serving their customers with great

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicholas Recchion

Best greek food arlund

Ron Beckerman

The absolute best Greek food ever. We’ve been going there for 30 years. Years before Covid, during and after. Consistently the best Greek food ever. Great people. We always recommend Gilshar’s to everyone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen T.

Food is good, can be a little dry but overall flavor is a strong 8/10, the staff is sweet, and very welcoming

Janet I.

Nice small eatery. Met a friend for lunch. Our server was very nice and she had no problem with us sitting and chatting in no over a two hour lunch. We both ordered the gyros. They were loaded with delicious lamb/beef mixture, moist and seasoned well. Will definitely return and order other Greek specialties

Andrea

This place never disappoints...great food and big portions!Vegetarian options: The eggplant gyro is delicious and an excellent vegetarian option, the falafel as well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich, Greek Salad with Chicken, Baklava, Olives, Dressing, Grilled Chicken, Chicken Souvlaki, Hummus, Falafel, Pita, Chicken Gyro, Large Salad, Fries

Paul B.

One of the best places around to get Greek food. The people who work there are friendly and will happily answer any questions you have about the menu. The food is very good and the portions are perfect. If you order sides, it can get costly, but everything is expensive today. Our go to place for Greek food.

Ed K.

Never disappoints. Love their gyro and lemon chicken soup. My kids love to eat there.

John Amini

This place is amazing, the food is unbelievable.. So good! I never been to Greece but I can imagine this is exactly what the food would taste like. The staff is very friendly and warm! Highly recommended!!

Eugenia Woods

Food is amazing. !!!! Very nice and pleasant atmosphere and service.Parking: Large parking area.Kid-friendliness: Pleasant environment for children

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: That Is Chicken Gyro Combonation with Rice and French Fries, Chicken Gyro, Yogurt Sauce, Fries

Beth Epstein

The falafel wrap is spicy. It’s not falafel. And the hummus is flavorless. And the female owner is rude. The only reason I ever went there was that I live pretty close. And their gyro and Slovaki is just OK. Never again.

holly murtha

The food was good. The salad was great! The lemonade was delicious. I ordered a spinach pie type meal and had to pay for tzatziki sauce. It was a little hot inside. We WILL be going back:)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

joe

Walk in… great friendly people service was instant, very nice woman at the front! We did take out- classic gyros, great tzatziki on the side bread was most certainly homemade, Food was great 9/10.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christopher Berger

****ZERO STAR****DO NOT ORDER A GREEK SALAD W/SHRIMP!!!Comes with sauteed onions, peppers and zuccini- doesn't list ANY of that on menu-GREASE SALAD is what should be listed on menu- the ENTIRE salad was soaked in grill grease...Unapologetic after TWO calls to complain.ANY mention of Greek food will be met with "DO NOT GO TO gilshar

Patricia G Barrett (Tricia)

The food is good I only get the Greek salad they give you enough for two or three people I always call a head my food is always ready when I get there to pick it up and it's still

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Load More