we were so excited to check out the new place. Arrived at 5:07pm and doors were locked, although they open at 5pm. Had to call for them to unlock the doors, bad sign #1. very cool place as you enter. Ordered a Money Martini. very well made. Ordered 1 dozen raw oysters for buck a suck night. Very good, actually found a pearl. Ordered 2nd dozen. After 40 minutes waiting asked the waitress behind the bar.l, she checked she never put the order in, placed the order, only to tell us 5 minutes later they were out of oysters. We ordered the duck fat fries and pork belly. after 20 minutes, the fries were delicious and hot, pork belly was cold and chewy, disgusting. asked for the bill, pork belly was removed, as it should be, but they tried to charge us for the 2nd dozen oysters we never received. We may be back for drinks only, but doubt it. Super disappointed..
Liz Feduchka Wardlaw
we were so excited to check out the new place. Arrived at 5:07pm and doors were locked, although they open at 5pm. Had to call for them to unlock the doors, bad sign #1. very cool place as you enter. Ordered a Money Martini. very well made. Ordered 1 dozen raw oysters for buck a suck night. Very good, actually found a pearl. Ordered 2nd dozen. After 40 minutes waiting asked the waitress behind the bar.l, she checked she never put the order in, placed the order, only to tell us 5 minutes later they were out of oysters. We ordered the duck fat fries and pork belly. after 20 minutes, the fries were delicious and hot, pork belly was cold and chewy, disgusting. asked for the bill, pork belly was removed, as it should be, but they tried to charge us for the 2nd dozen oysters we never received. We may be back for drinks only, but doubt it. Super disappointed..
Tracey
I wish they were open on some weeknights.... the atmosphere is excellent, the service very helpful and offers great suggestions based on client input. Our party of 4 had a wonderful evening where we could relax and catch up with each other.
Dietary restrictions: The staff was able to offer Gluten Free cocktail options - so nice to have a "change" from icky Tito's and standard cocktails. Enjoyed a pumpkin something martini that was presented beautifully.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Palsgrove
If you find yourself in Port Jervis, NY, and you're in search of an unforgettable drink, look no further than The Reserve. Located in a beautifully restored old bank building, this speakeasy-style bar combines history, ambiance, and world-class drinks into one incredible experience. The space itself feels like a step back in time with its original oak woodwork, soaring ceilings, and plush leather chairs that invite you to sit back and savor your evening.
But what truly sets The Reserve apart is its bartender, Phil Plotkin. A true master of his craft, Phil's cocktails are not just drinks—they're works of art. Each creation is carefully crafted with precision, showcasing his deep knowledge of top-shelf spirits and his passion for mixology. Whether you're in the mood for a classic or something more experimental, Phil's drinks are consistently delicious and second to none. His attention to detail and understanding of flavors make every sip a memorable one.
The Reserve’s spirit selection is equally impressive, with an extensive range of rare and premium bottles that cater to the most discerning whiskey lovers, rum connoisseurs, and anyone in between. Phil is more than happy to share his expertise and guide you through the collection, ensuring you find something that perfectly matches your tastes.
Beyond the drinks, the atmosphere is unparalleled. The dim lighting, vintage décor, and intimate vibe make it the perfect place to unwind, whether you're there for a quiet night out or celebrating something special. Every element of The Reserve, from the carefully curated spirits to Phil’s impeccable service, makes it a standout destination for anyone looking to enjoy a truly exceptional bar experience.
In short, The Reserve is more than just a bar—it's an experience. Phil’s expertise, the top-tier drinks, and the incredible atmosphere make it one of the best places to grab a drink in Port Jervis.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danny Rowland
I was impressed with this place! It's classy and spacious, but still feels cozy. It's inside an old Bank, which is very cool and you can see the giant vault door behind the bar. Been to places like this before, but they often feel cold or empty, but they did a great job making it feel cozy and comfortable and still elegant. The drinks were really good and I particularly enjoyed the pumpkin beer with the cinnamon sugar rim. They have an espresso martini tower which is a bit of a gimmick and you don't get that much with each of the small glasses, but it was still fun to try espresso martinis made with different alcohol.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina Polini
Drinks are sooooooo good! Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Zingone
Love this place! Missed seeing Phil, maybe next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becca Miller
This place is a must see! Wonderful staff and absolutely delicious drinks and snacks. Don't miss this spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Wilson
Amazing place setup in an old bank. The atmosphere was unique and really cool, props to my friend Cassi who spotted this place.
Food was great, came in small plates which is something I very much enjoy. My friends and I just ordered a few things then shared.
Our waiter gave us exceptional level service and was very accommodating to some our requests.
The facilities were very clean and my overall experience was amazing. I highly recommend this place for a date night or business meeting.
Everything here is absolutely amazing. Wonderful drinks, food, atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mel Baker
Johnny B & Phil were awesome STARtenders! Drinks and food were amazing, will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsay Soares
We just hosted our Engagement party at The Reserve and it was absolutely top notch. The food, the drinks and most importantly the service exceeded all expectations. The staff is incredible, caring and goes above and beyond. Overall was an incredible night and we would absolutely do something here again. 12/10, it was truly a night to remember. So thankful!
Matthew Fellenzer
I recently had the pleasure of experiencing brunch at The Reserve, and it was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we walked in, the ambiance was inviting yet sophisticated, setting the perfect tone for a relaxed weekend meal.
The brunch menu is thoughtfully curated, offering a delightful mix of classic dishes with a creative twist. Every bite was a testament to the quality and care put into the food. But the real star of the show? The drinks. The mixologists at The Reserve are truly masters of their craft.
Their house-made Bloody Mary is, without a doubt, the best I've ever had. The perfect balance of spices, the fresh ingredients, and the richness of the tomato base all came together to create a drink that's both bold and refreshing. It was garnished with just the right amount of flair—enough to make it visually stunning without being over the top.
Highly recommend, a place for everyone to share good vibes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kailah Papuga
My experience at The Reserve was truly exceptional! The ambiance is second to none and it’s the perfect spot to unwind. The bartenders were knowledgeable and provided excellent recommendations for drinks and small bites. The fun cocktails I tried (Greener Pastures, Dirty Money, Bank Roll, and Prohibition Bunch) were AMAZING and thoughtfully crafted. We also tried several of the small bites and they did not disappoint! This is a lovely spot for any occasion! I cant wait to go back
Great atmosphere and great drinks!
we were so excited to check out the new place. Arrived at 5:07pm and doors were locked, although they open at 5pm. Had to call for them to unlock the doors, bad sign #1. very cool place as you enter. Ordered a Money Martini. very well made. Ordered 1 dozen raw oysters for buck a suck night. Very good, actually found a pearl. Ordered 2nd dozen. After 40 minutes waiting asked the waitress behind the bar.l, she checked she never put the order in, placed the order, only to tell us 5 minutes later they were out of oysters. We ordered the duck fat fries and pork belly. after 20 minutes, the fries were delicious and hot, pork belly was cold and chewy, disgusting. asked for the bill, pork belly was removed, as it should be, but they tried to charge us for the 2nd dozen oysters we never received. We may be back for drinks only, but doubt it. Super disappointed..
we were so excited to check out the new place. Arrived at 5:07pm and doors were locked, although they open at 5pm. Had to call for them to unlock the doors, bad sign #1. very cool place as you enter. Ordered a Money Martini. very well made. Ordered 1 dozen raw oysters for buck a suck night. Very good, actually found a pearl. Ordered 2nd dozen. After 40 minutes waiting asked the waitress behind the bar.l, she checked she never put the order in, placed the order, only to tell us 5 minutes later they were out of oysters. We ordered the duck fat fries and pork belly. after 20 minutes, the fries were delicious and hot, pork belly was cold and chewy, disgusting. asked for the bill, pork belly was removed, as it should be, but they tried to charge us for the 2nd dozen oysters we never received. We may be back for drinks only, but doubt it. Super disappointed..
I wish they were open on some weeknights.... the atmosphere is excellent, the service very helpful and offers great suggestions based on client input. Our party of 4 had a wonderful evening where we could relax and catch up with each other.
Dietary restrictions: The staff was able to offer Gluten Free cocktail options - so nice to have a "change" from icky Tito's and standard cocktails. Enjoyed a pumpkin something martini that was presented beautifully.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you find yourself in Port Jervis, NY, and you're in search of an unforgettable drink, look no further than The Reserve. Located in a beautifully restored old bank building, this speakeasy-style bar combines history, ambiance, and world-class drinks into one incredible experience. The space itself feels like a step back in time with its original oak woodwork, soaring ceilings, and plush leather chairs that invite you to sit back and savor your evening.
But what truly sets The Reserve apart is its bartender, Phil Plotkin. A true master of his craft, Phil's cocktails are not just drinks—they're works of art. Each creation is carefully crafted with precision, showcasing his deep knowledge of top-shelf spirits and his passion for mixology. Whether you're in the mood for a classic or something more experimental, Phil's drinks are consistently delicious and second to none. His attention to detail and understanding of flavors make every sip a memorable one.
The Reserve’s spirit selection is equally impressive, with an extensive range of rare and premium bottles that cater to the most discerning whiskey lovers, rum connoisseurs, and anyone in between. Phil is more than happy to share his expertise and guide you through the collection, ensuring you find something that perfectly matches your tastes.
Beyond the drinks, the atmosphere is unparalleled. The dim lighting, vintage décor, and intimate vibe make it the perfect place to unwind, whether you're there for a quiet night out or celebrating something special. Every element of The Reserve, from the carefully curated spirits to Phil’s impeccable service, makes it a standout destination for anyone looking to enjoy a truly exceptional bar experience.
In short, The Reserve is more than just a bar—it's an experience. Phil’s expertise, the top-tier drinks, and the incredible atmosphere make it one of the best places to grab a drink in Port Jervis.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was impressed with this place! It's classy and spacious, but still feels cozy. It's inside an old Bank, which is very cool and you can see the giant vault door behind the bar. Been to places like this before, but they often feel cold or empty, but they did a great job making it feel cozy and comfortable and still elegant. The drinks were really good and I particularly enjoyed the pumpkin beer with the cinnamon sugar rim. They have an espresso martini tower which is a bit of a gimmick and you don't get that much with each of the small glasses, but it was still fun to try espresso martinis made with different alcohol.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drinks are sooooooo good! Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place! Missed seeing Phil, maybe next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a must see! Wonderful staff and absolutely delicious drinks and snacks. Don't miss this spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing place setup in an old bank. The atmosphere was unique and really cool, props to my friend Cassi who spotted this place.
Food was great, came in small plates which is something I very much enjoy. My friends and I just ordered a few things then shared.
Our waiter gave us exceptional level service and was very accommodating to some our requests.
The facilities were very clean and my overall experience was amazing. I highly recommend this place for a date night or business meeting.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything here is absolutely amazing. Wonderful drinks, food, atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Johnny B & Phil were awesome STARtenders! Drinks and food were amazing, will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just hosted our Engagement party at The Reserve and it was absolutely top notch. The food, the drinks and most importantly the service exceeded all expectations. The staff is incredible, caring and goes above and beyond. Overall was an incredible night and we would absolutely do something here again. 12/10, it was truly a night to remember. So thankful!
I recently had the pleasure of experiencing brunch at The Reserve, and it was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we walked in, the ambiance was inviting yet sophisticated, setting the perfect tone for a relaxed weekend meal.
The brunch menu is thoughtfully curated, offering a delightful mix of classic dishes with a creative twist. Every bite was a testament to the quality and care put into the food. But the real star of the show? The drinks. The mixologists at The Reserve are truly masters of their craft.
Their house-made Bloody Mary is, without a doubt, the best I've ever had. The perfect balance of spices, the fresh ingredients, and the richness of the tomato base all came together to create a drink that's both bold and refreshing. It was garnished with just the right amount of flair—enough to make it visually stunning without being over the top.
Highly recommend, a place for everyone to share good vibes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My experience at The Reserve was truly exceptional! The ambiance is second to none and it’s the perfect spot to unwind. The bartenders were knowledgeable and provided excellent recommendations for drinks and small bites. The fun cocktails I tried (Greener Pastures, Dirty Money, Bank Roll, and Prohibition Bunch) were AMAZING and thoughtfully crafted. We also tried several of the small bites and they did not disappoint! This is a lovely spot for any occasion! I cant wait to go back
Loading...