My dining companion enjoyed the French toast. But my ham and cheese omelette was very disappointing with tiny bits of ham and cheddar that was almost impossible to find. The good news was the manager took the omelette off the bill. But I left feeling hungry as the omelette was not eaten. Didn't want to wait for a "do-over". They bring blueberry muffins for brunch while you are waiting for your order to arrive. So, at least I had eaten a muffin. I do not like to leave poor reviews, but this one is fair. We had not been here in many years and wanted to give them a try again as we were heading to a concert nearby. But we will not be returning again.
Les
A very nice dining experience, from making reservations (on New Year's Eve) to the special menu, to the food. All excellent.
Suzanne
We go here almost weekly and always enjoy the food, drinks and service. It was a bit loud on New Year's Eve, but that is to be expected. We were told that there would be a band at 10, but we left after 10, and there was no band. It didn't matter because we weren't planning on staying, anyway, but it might have been nice to hear them.
Norman
We had a wonderful experience; we had not been to this restaurant for over 20 years. We will be back soon.
Lilly
The food and service were very good. The noise level was high and made it difficult to converse.
Mary
My husband and I had dinner at Finn McCools on Thursday 11/20/25 before a concert, and it was great. The food was delicious, service was good and the vibe was happy! We'll be back.
Supreet Kaur
We had our wedding party after here in August and it was such a seamless and perfect experience. I just let them know the time and about how many people were arriving. When we got there we had a section with tables set aside for us and the bartenders were very attentive. It was low effort and everyone had a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Sonjay Joseph Fonn, DO
Sheppards pie and pot roast to die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deborah Seeger
Their pot roast is one of the best I’ve ever had!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doreen
Finn Mccools has been a favorite restaurant of ours, especially my 6 year old grandson . Buttered pasta and after eight mints, what more can you ask for . Unlike so many restaurants today where you can't hear each other talk, Finn McCools is perfect for a nice family dinner. .. the food is great ,service wonderful and half price bottles of wine on Mondays tops it off.
Very kind and absolutely delicious food! Manager and staff are so kind and I think about their salmon dish every day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
RossB
Very nice restaurant located conveniently across the street from the Landmark Theatre in Port Washington. The service is excellent and the food is very good. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
rlee2000
My wife and I had dinner last night at Finn Mac Cools before going to The Landmark Theatre across the street for a concert. The restaurant is really nice and comfortable. The service was above average and the food was very good. I had the Fish and Chips and my wife had a steak sandwich. Will be back.
Michael
Wonderful gem of a restaurant! Food was (and, always is) excellent, portions perfect. Restaurant was immaculate. Comfortable seating.
John Bruno
Pre-show dinner reservations. Lisa was our server. Great meal. Attentive service allowed us to take our time and easily make our show. Very pleasant dinner.
My dining companion enjoyed the French toast. But my ham and cheese omelette was very disappointing with tiny bits of ham and cheddar that was almost impossible to find. The good news was the manager took the omelette off the bill. But I left feeling hungry as the omelette was not eaten. Didn't want to wait for a "do-over". They bring blueberry muffins for brunch while you are waiting for your order to arrive. So, at least I had eaten a muffin. I do not like to leave poor reviews, but this one is fair. We had not been here in many years and wanted to give them a try again as we were heading to a concert nearby. But we will not be returning again.
A very nice dining experience, from making reservations (on New Year's Eve) to the special menu, to the food. All excellent.
We go here almost weekly and always enjoy the food, drinks and service. It was a bit loud on New Year's Eve, but that is to be expected. We were told that there would be a band at 10, but we left after 10, and there was no band. It didn't matter because we weren't planning on staying, anyway, but it might have been nice to hear them.
We had a wonderful experience; we had not been to this restaurant for over 20 years. We will be back soon.
The food and service were very good. The noise level was high and made it difficult to converse.
My husband and I had dinner at Finn McCools on Thursday 11/20/25 before a concert, and it was great. The food was delicious, service was good and the vibe was happy! We'll be back.
We had our wedding party after here in August and it was such a seamless and perfect experience. I just let them know the time and about how many people were arriving. When we got there we had a section with tables set aside for us and the bartenders were very attentive. It was low effort and everyone had a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Sheppards pie and pot roast to die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their pot roast is one of the best I’ve ever had!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finn Mccools has been a favorite restaurant of ours, especially my 6 year old grandson . Buttered pasta and after eight mints, what more can you ask for . Unlike so many restaurants today where you can't hear each other talk, Finn McCools is perfect for a nice family dinner. .. the food is great ,service wonderful and half price bottles of wine on Mondays tops it off.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very kind and absolutely delicious food! Manager and staff are so kind and I think about their salmon dish every day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very nice restaurant located conveniently across the street from the Landmark Theatre in Port Washington. The service is excellent and the food is very good. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
My wife and I had dinner last night at Finn Mac Cools before going to The Landmark Theatre across the street for a concert. The restaurant is really nice and comfortable. The service was above average and the food was very good. I had the Fish and Chips and my wife had a steak sandwich. Will be back.
Wonderful gem of a restaurant! Food was (and, always is) excellent, portions perfect. Restaurant was immaculate. Comfortable seating.
Pre-show dinner reservations. Lisa was our server. Great meal. Attentive service allowed us to take our time and easily make our show. Very pleasant dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...