Ally's Ice Cream & Grill Cafe

141 Overlook Rd, Poughkeepsie
(845) 204-6901

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kim Case

Sighhh. I soooo wanted to love it here but this is the second time I've gone here and was told there are no bananas. (The other time was in the summer of 2024) The young man ran downstairs to check and apparently one was found. I asked if I could get light strawberry sauce and was told that there are no toppings on a banana split. Just 3 scoops of ice cream, a banana and whipped cream. That was ridiculous!! I canceled it and just got a vanilla soft serve with sprinkles. My fiance got the 'banana split' because he had planned on getting 2 scoops with a banana cut up in it.
We paid, got our order and went outside to sit in our truck and eat. My fiance said that he couldn't find any banana pieces mixed in. Welp, it turned out that the last/only banana was pretty much over ripe and complete mush at the bottom🤢🤢 It was pretty gross.
Hopefully this place will learn the proper making of a banana split and teach the kids working there how to make one. If you're going to continually not carry bananas, then it would be wiser to just take it off the menu. Do better Ally's!!

Jonni Griffin

always good ice-cream

Justin Clarke

Ice cream is good. Last time we went there or two ice creams went to walk outside the door hit the ice cream out of my hand. Both ice cream fell on the floor in front of staff and was recharged for ice creams.

Sarah Nicolaescu

The best thing I’ve ever had is Ally’s Dubai Chocolate Pile-up. So freaking good!!!!

Natasha Mincey

The ice cream from here is amazing and the girl (I think her name was Sara I don't really remember) who helped me was so helpful and nice. This is a good ice cream spot!

James D

Lovely and friendly family owned business. Only place I know of that serves milkshakes made with real coffee!

Debra Long

The ice cream was delicious, however I ordered a small, it cost $8.00 with 2 toppings: one being wet walnut and I only received 3 of them. The size could have fed a three year old toddler. When I tell you this is the true definition of price gauging and this place will NEVER get another dime from me!

Jason Sunwall

Ice cream was excellent and staff was very friendly

Elena Yee

Dubai chocolate pile-on sundae!!!! So, so good. I’ve been wanting to try Dubai chocolate but to buy a bar of it costs $19.99. Instead I decided to try the Dubai chocolate pile on at Ally’s and they even place a corner of a bar on it. The cost is $10.95 which, to be honest, I was happy to pay. They also put a coating of pistachio filling (?) along with pistachio ice cream and a sprinkling on pistachios on top. There’s soft serve at the bottom with a little bit of strawberry sauce. Such a good combination. Add to it, the young person who took and made my order was friendly, warm and polite. Look forward to visiting again!

Jason Hurban

Delicious ice cream, kind people, worth the stop!

Mandi S.

First time customer, only took me over 10yrs to stop in! Customer service was perfect. The onion rings and mozzarella sticks were DELICIOUS 🤤 My boyfriend and I were too full to eat the ice cream afterwards. I got Queen of Hearts to-go. Just had a couple bites, very rich dark chocolate ❤️ yummy!

Daniel Wetter

Food and ice cream we're fabulous. The young man(Tommy) was very friendly, polite and professional.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger, Shakes Floats, French Fries

Hayden Bennett

Terrible service, very slow, overpriced, and the young girls in there don’t know how to make milkshakes at all

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ella Gufler

Best burgers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

Tyler Barton

the best spot for ice cream, burgers, shakes, crepes and more! great veggie burger and fries. super sweet spot

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...