I have ordered there pizza for a few years but while I do receive good service I have not been satisfied with there pizza for the last few months. I find the bread thin, taste lacks flavor and very little cheese and sauce.
Robert Nelson
Under new management. Bought a pizza was burt so bad couldn't fold the slice or eat it. All the people their are nice told manager about it said he would take care of me so I reordered a week later the pie was ok not so tasty. I wanted to talk to the manager about maybe half price for my new order. THE OWNER WAS THEIR AND SEEMED NOT TO CARE OR HAVE TIME FOR ME A CUSTERMER TOLD CASHIER TO GIVE ME ONLY $ 1.50 OFF. VERY BAD CUSTERMER SERVICE... NOT A GOOD STart for this new business especially when the owner doesn't care. Will not go back unless have no choice, better pizza place 2 miles away either way you drive. Very bad customer service if not better soon I bet their will be a fore sale sign their. I never like to write bad reviews but I was not at all happy with the owner.
Rich Iuele
Stopped in for a slice from the rail trail. It was an awesome slice perfectly crisp crust. Will be coming here again and again
Olivia F.
It was ok. The crust was hard and it didn't have much flavor but the toppings were generous.
Richard Berube
Always a special pizza to try at Joe Cristiano. I had the sweet chilli today.
Robert Stern
Great place for a quick bite.
Kevin Molloy
Pizza has stayed great and the wings are damn good too!
Joe Sportello
Good chicken roll. Good service, nice staff.
Carolyn F.
TITUSVILLE ROAD location: I usually order from the Wappingers South Road( Rte 9) location, but was driving past ad stopped in for takeout. MY ORDER: Large Plain Cheese and Chicken Parmesan hero. The girl at the counter was lovely and the shop was very clean with table and high-tip seating. Two large screens showing football. THE FOOD: the chicken was abundant on very good bread, toasted perfectly. Unfortunately, the breading was mushy and there was not enough sauce. (List a star) Plenty of chees, though. THE PIZZA: Nicely cooked, but I was really disappointed that the person who prepared it trimmed it, reducing the size of the "large" significantly. He was collecting all the bids in a separate container, presumably to form a couple of additional pies. This was very disappointing and really explains why I've always felt that the Wappingers location has a larger large pie than the Titusville Road location. ( list a star) I should've called him out on it, but instead I probably won't go back.
Neil Hunter
I go to this unique place from time to time as I like the special air that is unique to this restaurant. The staff is awfuly welcoming and experienced. The service is awfully rapid. Not to mention, the food they cook is exceptionaly good. I frequent often and I was never disappointed. The cost is fair. I suggest this restaurant to all my friends.
JCs has good food and good fast service right by the walkway on Titusville Rd.
Nathan Frederick
If you don't mind a bunch of kids who know nothing about being sanitary making your pizza then it's great
Theresa Peek
Good service, good pizza.
Hakm R.
The only consistently good thing they have is the meatball sliders, everything else (especially the pizza) is below average. I can't say it's completely inedible, but I advise you to consider your options.
I have ordered there pizza for a few years but while I do receive good service I have not been satisfied with there pizza for the last few months. I find the bread thin, taste lacks flavor and very little cheese and sauce.
Under new management. Bought a pizza was burt so bad couldn't fold the slice or eat it. All the people their are nice told manager about it said he would take care of me so I reordered a week later the pie was ok not so tasty. I wanted to talk to the manager about maybe half price for my new order. THE OWNER WAS THEIR AND SEEMED NOT TO CARE OR HAVE TIME FOR ME A CUSTERMER TOLD CASHIER TO GIVE ME ONLY $ 1.50 OFF. VERY BAD CUSTERMER SERVICE... NOT A GOOD STart for this new business especially when the owner doesn't care. Will not go back unless have no choice, better pizza place 2 miles away either way you drive. Very bad customer service if not better soon I bet their will be a fore sale sign their. I never like to write bad reviews but I was not at all happy with the owner.
Stopped in for a slice from the rail trail. It was an awesome slice perfectly crisp crust. Will be coming here again and again
It was ok. The crust was hard and it didn't have much flavor but the toppings were generous.
Always a special pizza to try at Joe Cristiano. I had the sweet chilli today.
Great place for a quick bite.
Pizza has stayed great and the wings are damn good too!
Good chicken roll. Good service, nice staff.
TITUSVILLE ROAD location: I usually order from the Wappingers South Road( Rte 9) location, but was driving past ad stopped in for takeout. MY ORDER: Large Plain Cheese and Chicken Parmesan hero. The girl at the counter was lovely and the shop was very clean with table and high-tip seating. Two large screens showing football. THE FOOD: the chicken was abundant on very good bread, toasted perfectly. Unfortunately, the breading was mushy and there was not enough sauce. (List a star) Plenty of chees, though. THE PIZZA: Nicely cooked, but I was really disappointed that the person who prepared it trimmed it, reducing the size of the "large" significantly. He was collecting all the bids in a separate container, presumably to form a couple of additional pies. This was very disappointing and really explains why I've always felt that the Wappingers location has a larger large pie than the Titusville Road location. ( list a star) I should've called him out on it, but instead I probably won't go back.
I go to this unique place from time to time as I like the special air that is unique to this restaurant. The staff is awfuly welcoming and experienced. The service is awfully rapid. Not to mention, the food they cook is exceptionaly good. I frequent often and I was never disappointed. The cost is fair. I suggest this restaurant to all my friends.
Restaurantji Recommends
JCs has good food and good fast service right by the walkway on Titusville Rd.
If you don't mind a bunch of kids who know nothing about being sanitary making your pizza then it's great
Good service, good pizza.
The only consistently good thing they have is the meatball sliders, everything else (especially the pizza) is below average. I can't say it's completely inedible, but I advise you to consider your options.
Great staff awesome food