Tony's Pizza Pit

786 Main St, Poughkeepsie
(845) 471-4110

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Charlie Lattin

Best pizza in town. Make some of the others tasteless. Their other dishes are delicious and very large amounts. Prices are fair.

Parking: Other eating places share the parking lot, first come, first served. It's near a college and weekends are tough parking.

Wheelchair accessibility: Available.

Kevin Drisgula

Friendly hard working staff. So far only had various pizza and garlic knots but very solid at a competitive price. The bbq chicken slice is superior In flavor. Great dough, thin crust, and seasoned.

DIVAKEYZ Erica A

At first it was great customer service I felt Iike a regular got more then pizza ? that young dude is rude so anytime he's around I'll pass.. I like to support all local businesses I NEVER have a problem at TJ'S food plus customers service= The place to go?

Matthew Bass

Specialty pizza is very good, especially the square. The regular round pies kit so much. Customer sevice is terrible. I brought in a coupon (with no expiration date) for free 2 liter soda with purchase of specialty pizza and it was denied. Just told they don't accept coupons anymore. I spent $70 and they couldn't honor the coupon for a $3 soda??? Bad business.

Gary Franklin

Food is good. One of our go-to pizzerias. Staff is fairly friendly.A down side is that a few times I've pre-ordered food online, I'll arrive well after the estimated time and my food will still have not been cooked. Forgivable, but still not cool.Overall a good pizza place and will continue to order from.

Heather Infantas

Pizza was so good!! The sauce was amazing. The delivery was quick and the driver was very polite. Highly recommend!

Michael O'Connor

Lol, pretty funny to see that this place hasn't changed its ways for years. I had a problem with these people years ago when I was still living in the area - owner screamed at me over the phone and yeah, pffft, cya. Up in NY on a visit and people I'm staying with got a pie a few days ago that was meh. I wonder if I'm going to get the same stock response with no actual change that all of the other accurate reviews of this place got. Take a few more minutes and head up to Kokopelli's on Violet for really good pizza.

christine dino

This place is a rip off. We called from Newburgh hotel and asked them for delivery. They never told us this was the Poughkeepsie location. You would think when we gave the Newburgh address for delivery they would of told us. They kept my money and screamed at us on the phone. I will be calling my credit card company about the charges. This is not the way to treat customers because a employee made a mistake. Bad business

Bonnie Catalano

I would never order from here again. The pizza was too thick and not cooked. They made me a second one and when I ate it the dough was not cooked again even though I asked for it thin, it was still thick and not cooked enough. It was horrible. Thumbs down

Legacy Mission

This is a wonderful, local restaurant with THE BEST PIZZA in Poughkeepsie, NY. But in addition to the GREAT pizza(Crust and all!!!), Tony's has daily lunch specials - ALL of the amazing Italian restaurant entrees you've enjoyed for years for great prices and ALWAYS very, very good. Good food at great prices. Go there as soon as you can - you won't regret it.

Daniel Tasman

Potential to be pretty decent decent personal size pizzas but the two we got were so salty we couldn't finish them. We had a pepperoni pie and a cheese pie. It was like they salted the top of the pizza... Very gross.

greg juan

Great food. Lunch specials are very well portioned. You will not be let down.

otaku7me

Today I ordered the Spicy Shrimp Alfredo and the La Puttanesca Pasta. Both came with a side of garlic bread and a small salad. Both dishes were absolutely delicious !!! I will definitely order again.

eric walker

Friendly staff, good pizza and other items. Good variety.

Mr. J

This place used to be my go to, it used to be the best in the area. However the last few times I've gone here I have been disappointed. The service is atrocious, and the food is not as good as it once was. This past time, I arrived for my pick up order within the 15 min time frame they gave me. My calzone was done in the package and I spent the next 10 minutes waiting for my fried calamari. I arrived home to a cold calzone and to top that off it had no sauce in the package. This is a joke and this place is trash now. I will never go here again.

Loading...