Online it shows they are open until 9pm. I made a 15 minute detour to stop here and when I arrived at 1:10 pm they were closed with a sign that they close at 1pm on Saturday and Sunday. They need to adjust their hours online.
Stephen Anderson
Not sure why I am being asked to review rooms? But here is a review of the Market/Restaurant:
A Worthwhile Detour on the Way to the Adirondacks
We were heading from my Cornell University reunion up to the Adirondacks for some hiking when we stumbled upon this gem of a spot in Pulaski, NY. Mill House Market is a cozy, welcoming place just off I-81—easy to miss, but well worth the stop for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
The front of the shop sets the tone with a cute little market offering unique local gifts and goods, plus a sign out front with some classic Pulaski fishing-town humor (see photo for a chuckle). Inside, you can order at the counter for takeout or settle into their small dining room and order from the menu.
We opted to dine in and went with the savory crepes: mine was the smoked salmon with egg, cream cheese, capers, red onion, tomato, and lemon—all wrapped in a flavorful herb crepe and served over fresh arugula. The egg was cooked on top, and while everything was fresh and well-balanced, I would’ve loved the yolk just a little runnier—it would’ve made the perfect natural sauce. Still, a definite hit.
Our friend had the Sicilian Eggs with artichokes, spinach, fresh mozzarella, herbs, and grilled bread—plus avocado. It looked fantastic, and she really enjoyed it. Generous portions across the board.
A few things to note: the menu is extensive, which can feel a bit overwhelming at first glance. A little more structure or a clearer layout might help. Also, our lattes were served in to-go cups even though we were dining in, which felt a bit out of step with the otherwise cozy, sit-down vibe.
Service was friendly and attentive, though with just one server managing the room, things did slow down as it got busier. That said, she was warm, helpful, and clearly juggling a lot with grace.
Beyond breakfast, Mill House Market offers an impressive lineup of sandwiches, salads, bowls, pizzas, and rotating specials—so there’s plenty to choose from, no matter what time of day you stop in. It’s clearly a place built with care and personality—part café, part neighborhood hub—and a perfect pit stop whether you're local or just passing through between Syracuse and Watertown.
Clayton Carey
Good selection of food. Fast service excellent Pizza.
Pat
Large, creative menu, draft beers, store, all good. We stopped on the way to Toronto and then again on the way back
Robert Mevec
This place is better than fast food options. Everything is priced fairly. Wide selection of food and desserts. Everything is made on premisis. Staff is friendly and they even carry local artisan foods and crafts.they have a full bar as well as coffees and teas. Specials throughout the week . Take out is available, full bar with craft beers on tap and local wines from the area. Stop in..
Zara Noreen
This is not for room/lodging, but rather for just the market itself. Went here for a caramel macchiato and their Pulaski sandwich to go. I think the balance of the brie and cranberry and turkey along with the arugula was perfect, but I did find that the amount of mustard was a little bit overpowering but I can see that if they didn’t have that amount of mustard, the sandwich might’ve been a bit dry. Maybe using a mustard mayo combo and then dressing, the arugula with maybe olive oil and a little bit of lemon juice would have been a little bit better in my opinion. But overall, it was still a really good sandwich. I got it grilled and would highly recommend doing so. The macchiato was delicious. The staff is really friendly and it’s just a cute little shop to walk around and look at little trinkets and stuff while waiting.
Scott Anderson
Awesome north country eatery. Highly recommend their pizza, bakery, and sandwiches.
Sam Hurne
Very good sandwiches, salads, and pizza here. I would definitely recommend it as a great place for lunch in the area!
E Rudsinski
Cozy little gem of a place that serves up tasty foods crafted with fresh ingredients. Friendly staff. Breads baked in-house. Delicious!
Chef Cabrera
Highly disappointed Thai lime bowl, terrible, not flavorful, chicken cold, wasn’t fresh at all… Pizza place burn my hand, no warning… Food was
REAL FOOD! Great place to stop for a meal off Rt.81 if you are looking for quality food. People are great, loved my Tahini Bowl and pastry. Pizza looked amazing. Husband's turkey sandwich was delicious. Nice collection of local wares for sale. Bar had a pretty awesome looking selection, too. Place seems to have everything - very well done!
Service: 5
Diana Siegel
Food was excellent, staff were friendly and helpful, the space is beautiful and clean. I love their homemade bread and the variety of options they offer. They’re are a real gem in the North Country! My only regret is that I didn’t find them sooner!
Service: 5
Eric Ransone
We ordered pizzas near closing, about 30-40 minutes prior to closing, and they were decent. It was obvious they were ready to close and wanted to get done, The homemade crust was great, but sauce and toppings were about 2 inches or more from the edge of the crust. I got the Hawaiian Islands pizza, and aside from toppings being minimized it was indeed very tasty. The pulled pork on a pizza was wonderful. They have an absolutely HUGE selection of all kinds of foods. If you can't find something you like here, you are way too picky. The service, even though it was getting late, was very good. Friendly and helpful, which considering the volume of choices help was needed. I'm willing to give them another try because it seems they have great food and good prices.
Service: 5
Mary Smith
This is such a special place! We happened to stumble upon a humble suite at the Mill House Market while looking for a place to stay (on Airbnb) for my husband to do some salmon fishing. Little did we know what a treat we were in for in this sweet town, especially at the Mill House Market. Rebekah, the owner has created something so lovely. We enjoyed several meals at the Mill House while staying here, each of which left us wanting to try more. The cozy and cute atmosphere was so welcoming. Hand making pizzas (which are fired in the open oven right in front of you) was Jeremy who was a kind and passionate young man who carried on a very heartfelt conversation while preparing our pizza. Each employee was friendly and happy to answer questions. We also learned that Rebekah owns another kitchen right on the edge of Lake Ontario called Rainbow Shores so we had a drive over to check that out. Wow! Rebekah you have accomplished so much, I was so happy that I actually got to meet you in person because you are delightful. What a wonderful experience which paired so well with the amazing fishing in this cute little town! We will be back! Thank you for making our trip special. Btw…those browned butter chocolate chip cookies will be on my mind for some time!
Service: 5
James Bond
I've only used the sit down dining area and bar. Everyone in the party very much enjoyed the sandwiches. I visit Pulaski often for the fishing seasons and this is definitely on the short list for lunch or dinner.
Online it shows they are open until 9pm. I made a 15 minute detour to stop here and when I arrived at 1:10 pm they were closed with a sign that they close at 1pm on Saturday and Sunday. They need to adjust their hours online.
Not sure why I am being asked to review rooms? But here is a review of the Market/Restaurant:
A Worthwhile Detour on the Way to the Adirondacks
We were heading from my Cornell University reunion up to the Adirondacks for some hiking when we stumbled upon this gem of a spot in Pulaski, NY. Mill House Market is a cozy, welcoming place just off I-81—easy to miss, but well worth the stop for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
The front of the shop sets the tone with a cute little market offering unique local gifts and goods, plus a sign out front with some classic Pulaski fishing-town humor (see photo for a chuckle). Inside, you can order at the counter for takeout or settle into their small dining room and order from the menu.
We opted to dine in and went with the savory crepes: mine was the smoked salmon with egg, cream cheese, capers, red onion, tomato, and lemon—all wrapped in a flavorful herb crepe and served over fresh arugula. The egg was cooked on top, and while everything was fresh and well-balanced, I would’ve loved the yolk just a little runnier—it would’ve made the perfect natural sauce. Still, a definite hit.
Our friend had the Sicilian Eggs with artichokes, spinach, fresh mozzarella, herbs, and grilled bread—plus avocado. It looked fantastic, and she really enjoyed it. Generous portions across the board.
A few things to note: the menu is extensive, which can feel a bit overwhelming at first glance. A little more structure or a clearer layout might help. Also, our lattes were served in to-go cups even though we were dining in, which felt a bit out of step with the otherwise cozy, sit-down vibe.
Service was friendly and attentive, though with just one server managing the room, things did slow down as it got busier. That said, she was warm, helpful, and clearly juggling a lot with grace.
Beyond breakfast, Mill House Market offers an impressive lineup of sandwiches, salads, bowls, pizzas, and rotating specials—so there’s plenty to choose from, no matter what time of day you stop in. It’s clearly a place built with care and personality—part café, part neighborhood hub—and a perfect pit stop whether you're local or just passing through between Syracuse and Watertown.
Good selection of food. Fast service excellent Pizza.
Large, creative menu, draft beers, store, all good. We stopped on the way to Toronto and then again on the way back
This place is better than fast food options. Everything is priced fairly. Wide selection of food and desserts. Everything is made on premisis. Staff is friendly and they even carry local artisan foods and crafts.they have a full bar as well as coffees and teas. Specials throughout the week . Take out is available, full bar with craft beers on tap and local wines from the area. Stop in..
This is not for room/lodging, but rather for just the market itself. Went here for a caramel macchiato and their Pulaski sandwich to go. I think the balance of the brie and cranberry and turkey along with the arugula was perfect, but I did find that the amount of mustard was a little bit overpowering but I can see that if they didn’t have that amount of mustard, the sandwich might’ve been a bit dry. Maybe using a mustard mayo combo and then dressing, the arugula with maybe olive oil and a little bit of lemon juice would have been a little bit better in my opinion. But overall, it was still a really good sandwich. I got it grilled and would highly recommend doing so. The macchiato was delicious. The staff is really friendly and it’s just a cute little shop to walk around and look at little trinkets and stuff while waiting.
Awesome north country eatery. Highly recommend their pizza, bakery, and sandwiches.
Very good sandwiches, salads, and pizza here. I would definitely recommend it as a great place for lunch in the area!
Cozy little gem of a place that serves up tasty foods crafted with fresh ingredients. Friendly staff. Breads baked in-house. Delicious!
Highly disappointed
Thai lime bowl, terrible, not flavorful, chicken cold, wasn’t fresh at all…
Pizza place burn my hand, no warning…
Food was
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
REAL FOOD! Great place to stop for a meal off Rt.81 if you are looking for quality food. People are great, loved my Tahini Bowl and pastry. Pizza looked amazing. Husband's turkey sandwich was delicious. Nice collection of local wares for sale. Bar had a pretty awesome looking selection, too. Place seems to have everything - very well done!
Service: 5
Food was excellent, staff were friendly and helpful, the space is beautiful and clean. I love their homemade bread and the variety of options they offer. They’re are a real gem in the North Country! My only regret is that I didn’t find them sooner!
Service: 5
We ordered pizzas near closing, about 30-40 minutes prior to closing, and they were decent. It was obvious they were ready to close and wanted to get done, The homemade crust was great, but sauce and toppings were about 2 inches or more from the edge of the crust. I got the Hawaiian Islands pizza, and aside from toppings being minimized it was indeed very tasty. The pulled pork on a pizza was wonderful. They have an absolutely HUGE selection of all kinds of foods. If you can't find something you like here, you are way too picky. The service, even though it was getting late, was very good. Friendly and helpful, which considering the volume of choices help was needed. I'm willing to give them another try because it seems they have great food and good prices.
Service: 5
This is such a special place! We happened to stumble upon a humble suite at the Mill House Market while looking for a place to stay (on Airbnb) for my husband to do some salmon fishing. Little did we know what a treat we were in for in this sweet town, especially at the Mill House Market. Rebekah, the owner has created something so lovely. We enjoyed several meals at the Mill House while staying here, each of which left us wanting to try more. The cozy and cute atmosphere was so welcoming. Hand making pizzas (which are fired in the open oven right in front of you) was Jeremy who was a kind and passionate young man who carried on a very heartfelt conversation while preparing our pizza. Each employee was friendly and happy to answer questions. We also learned that Rebekah owns another kitchen right on the edge of Lake Ontario called Rainbow Shores so we had a drive over to check that out. Wow! Rebekah you have accomplished so much, I was so happy that I actually got to meet you in person because you are delightful. What a wonderful experience which paired so well with the amazing fishing in this cute little town! We will be back! Thank you for making our trip special. Btw…those browned butter chocolate chip cookies will be on my mind for some time!
Service: 5
I've only used the sit down dining area and bar. Everyone in the party very much enjoyed the sandwiches. I visit Pulaski often for the fishing seasons and this is definitely on the short list for lunch or dinner.
Service: 5
Loading...