Billy Mac's Pizzeria

2555 Youngstown Lockport Rd, Ransomville
(716) 791-3107

Recent Reviews

William Holstrom

Order whole pizza i get half then have to wait a half hr to get the other half with no discount for their incompetence

Danny P.

food is good but like rolling dice don,t know who,s cooking some times it alright sometimes not that,s the truth but what can I say that,s how it at most places.

Thomas Marks

Really really disappointed. I have had good subs from here before. Today I got a Royal, the roll was so toasted it was literally hard as a rock even burnt on the ends... almost no lettuce, it was supposed to have cheese, I did not see any, the tomatoes cut so thin that they were barely visible and impossible to taste. Now it’s impossible to believe that the person who made this sub was unaware of the poor quality of the sun sold to me. When a food establishment does not value the quality of the food that is a red flag about what could be going on out of the customer’s sight. I will not be back. I live too far away to run back… so I am out $16..

Food: 1

Julia Saunderson

Love their sweet sauce. It’s very distinct, and original. I feel like a lot of places claim to have sweet sauce, but this one is Definitely sweet, but in the best way possible. I would have never come here if I didn’t meet my husband, and him being from Ransomville, but I’m so glad his family introduced me to their delicious pizza??. The pizza is all I’ve tried from there before, so this is strictly a pizza review. Once I placed my order, it took about 35 min to become ready. I paid I believe $23 for a half tray (half cheese/half pepperoni). The crust is delicious too, not too thick or thin, a good balance. They give you can option of sweet sauce or regular, and I’ll always pick sweet ???.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Kim Yourston Jr.

Good food, good price!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Tricia Raymond

Pizza was loaded with sauce and undercooked. Chicken wings had loads of garlic powder just dumped on them, this made them gritty and undeniable. 60.00 for 1/2 try and 30 wings that I could not eat.. So sad as I was a frequent Billy Mac customer..

Jessica Perina

Ordered a salad. Very disappointed to find that its made with shredded sub lettuce. Who wants a salad made with that?! Basically all topping no lettuce, waste of $14.

BHA

The day had Buffalo Bills in play off with Chiefs, order pizza and wings, food was perfect and no wait.then day of super bowl last week, between Tampa and chiefs, order pizza and wings again, perfect. thank you, Billy Mac's Pizzeria,1- 29-2023 ordered pizza and wings yum perfect really good.a few weeks ago, got subs delicious

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Lisa Ingrassia

We order from Billy Mac’s about once a week-their sweet sauce is soooo good!

Terence Weir

Absolutely disappointed and it seemed intentional I only got a large pizza it was soup on top and concrete old dough that was rushed to cook on bottom 27 dollars wasted ...even asked of 45 min to close was to late and ge said no problem well I hope I don't get sick the pizza could have been delicious if someone cared

HipD3

Camping nearby so I grabbed a couple pizzas and a clam basket to take back to the campground. I don’t like to complain but the sauce was really bad. Waaaay too many herbs in the sauce. Too much oregano and maybe basil (??). Also needed salt. We couldn’t finish and that doesn’t happen.

Craig Sherman

Pizza was good. Ordered a salad wasn't that great.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Lisa i

We order from Billy Mac’s about once a week-their sweet sauce is soooo good!

Cathy Wagner

First time in years ordering from here. Pizza was very good though crust was a tad overcooked.

Smelling the Roses

The pizza was not so good. All the toppings and cheese were sliding off, so we had to rst it with a spork we had in the car. But it was nice to have someplace to get something to eat on that long drive. They also have sub sandwiches, chicken, and tacos. Probably should have tried one of those.

Load More