Best pizza in town. Nice variety of beers for everyone. Plenty of space to where you can find a table quickly.
Greg L.
The pizza was hands down amazing. I'm super picky and this was the best! Definitely go here!!!
Sarah M.
Just avoid. A takeout order took an hour over the 25 min that they told us. No one seems to know what they're doing there. When we finally got home with our food and crying kids, the fish was completely over cooked and we were missing items that we ordered. This is the second chance after a very similar experience last year. We won't be back.
Infield99
Avoid this place. To be fair, the food is good, but the service is horrible. Got seated promptly but waited way too long to get drinks, give order. Our food order took over 30 minutes, was incomplete and wrong. Also overpriced. Never going back.
Pamela P.
The service at this place is abysmal. The waitresses ignored me for ten minutes. Rude!
Alisha M.
Great pizza little wait time good cocktails friendly service fast service must try if in old forge
Shanna F.
Amazing whiskey wings. Music was too loud. Service at bar was excellent! Pizza was good. Nice outdoor seating area.
Ashley K.
We ordered the bang bang shrimp appetizer. The shrimp was really good and there were about a dozen pieces. I do wish the container of sauce was bigger. We also ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and the BBQ chicken pizza. Both pizzas were delicious. Our waiter was very friendly and the service was great. As far as ambiance it was a little dark and a little loud. Overall a great experience and we will definitely be back again!
Kari S.
I feel I need to warn the public. We ate at the Old forge location on Saturday 8/19/23. We came here solely on the recommendation from a friend because all of the online reviews were terrible. Unfortunately the online reviews are true. Our hostess was incredibly rude. Our waitress was completely useless. She would rather be on her phone and drink out of her cup by the kitchen than maintain any of her tables. You could sit there and watch other waitstaff trying to help this 'clueless' waitress. Many were bussing her tables, bringing out things she forgot. I had to practically beg for refills. She would look right at the empty cups and walk by and go back to her phone. Our food came out super slow. I ordered the prime rib, my husband ordered the steak. My potato came out highly overcooked and dry with nothing with it. Both of our beef came with butter knives to cut it. I will say the only thing our waitress was competent in doing was bringing the bill. After paying my husband noticed he had left behind an envelope of money. Needless to say he went back to get it and of course it wasn't there. She waitress and hostess argued that he had took it with him. Yes he raised his voice and left. Apparently the manager at that point must have questioned them because I recieved a call within an hour saying it had been turned in and for him to come retrieve it. I guess if you want to recieve a mediocre meal with crap service from thieves look no further than Tony Harper's in Old Forge!
Kari L
I feel I need to warn the public. We ate at the Old forge location on Saturday 8/19/23. We came here solely on the recommendation from a friend because all of the online reviews were terrible. Unfortunately the online reviews are true. Our hostess was incredibly rude. Our waitress was completely useless. She would rather be on her phone and drink out of her cup by the kitchen than maintain any of her tables. You could sit there and watch other waitstaff trying to help this 'clueless' waitress. Many were bussing her tables, bringing out things she forgot. I had to practically beg for refills. She would look right at the empty cups and walk by and go back to her phone. Our food came out super slow. I ordered the prime rib, my husband ordered the steak. My potato came out highly overcooked and dry with nothing with it. Both of our beef came with butter knives to cut it. I will say the only thing our waitress was competent in doing was bringing the bill. After paying my husband noticed he had left behind an envelope of money. Needless to say he went back to get it and of course it wasn't there. She waitress and hostess argued that he had took it with him. Yes he raised his voice and left. Apparently the manager at that point must have questioned them because I recieved a call within an hour saying it had been turned in and for him to come retrieve it. I guess if you want to recieve a mediocre meal with crap service from thieves look no further than Tony Harper's in Old Forge!
Great place for tavern style food. Chicken wings are awesome at this place. Music a bit loud but ok. Also had clams and they were also very good. If you're in Old Forge you need to stop in. Pizza excellent also .
Carol G.
This place was amazing. Stopped by with multiple families with kids. They let us put three shaded picnic tables together so we could all eat outside. We got the pizza and wings with a side of onion rings and they were all exceptional. The beer selection is great and the staff is very accommodating. I can't wait to come back here specifically for those wings... They are to die for!
thiso273
It happens every time we go every year. we sit at a picnic table outside with a family of seven the pizza comes in about 15 minutes. My hamburger comes 20 minutes later. Then the fries for the table-after the pizza was eaten. What’s that all about? They explained that they were swamped. That is not my problem. Service should include all meals at the same time, not at their convenience.
LisaB168
We went here 3 times. The first day we had an ok, average meal. The 2nd day we had salads, that the lettuce was wilted, and service was almost non-existent. The 3rd day was the clincher. We went upstairs to their roof top bar. The co-owner, (self-acclaimed) and another man were sitters at the bar. The other man was allowed to walk around and bother other patrons, despite people telling him to leave them alone. The bartender continued to serve this inebriated man, who turned out to be a local who is there often, and his offensiveness is considered him having fun. At the end, he ended up in a fight with another patron, because he would not leave them alone. Not saying that this other patron was right, however an owner allowing someone to bother customers, and continue to serve when he is drunk, is a questionable practice.
Hunter W.
Tony harpers is one the most best pizzas. It always fills me up and satisfies me would recommend
Best pizza in town. Nice variety of beers for everyone. Plenty of space to where you can find a table quickly.
The pizza was hands down amazing. I'm super picky and this was the best! Definitely go here!!!
Just avoid. A takeout order took an hour over the 25 min that they told us. No one seems to know what they're doing there. When we finally got home with our food and crying kids, the fish was completely over cooked and we were missing items that we ordered. This is the second chance after a very similar experience last year. We won't be back.
Avoid this place. To be fair, the food is good, but the service is horrible. Got seated promptly but waited way too long to get drinks, give order. Our food order took over 30 minutes, was incomplete and wrong. Also overpriced. Never going back.
The service at this place is abysmal. The waitresses ignored me for ten minutes. Rude!
Great pizza little wait time good cocktails friendly service fast service must try if in old forge
Amazing whiskey wings. Music was too loud. Service at bar was excellent! Pizza was good. Nice outdoor seating area.
We ordered the bang bang shrimp appetizer. The shrimp was really good and there were about a dozen pieces. I do wish the container of sauce was bigger. We also ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and the BBQ chicken pizza. Both pizzas were delicious. Our waiter was very friendly and the service was great. As far as ambiance it was a little dark and a little loud. Overall a great experience and we will definitely be back again!
I feel I need to warn the public. We ate at the Old forge location on Saturday 8/19/23. We came here solely on the recommendation from a friend because all of the online reviews were terrible. Unfortunately the online reviews are true. Our hostess was incredibly rude. Our waitress was completely useless. She would rather be on her phone and drink out of her cup by the kitchen than maintain any of her tables. You could sit there and watch other waitstaff trying to help this 'clueless' waitress. Many were bussing her tables, bringing out things she forgot. I had to practically beg for refills. She would look right at the empty cups and walk by and go back to her phone. Our food came out super slow. I ordered the prime rib, my husband ordered the steak. My potato came out highly overcooked and dry with nothing with it. Both of our beef came with butter knives to cut it. I will say the only thing our waitress was competent in doing was bringing the bill. After paying my husband noticed he had left behind an envelope of money. Needless to say he went back to get it and of course it wasn't there. She waitress and hostess argued that he had took it with him. Yes he raised his voice and left. Apparently the manager at that point must have questioned them because I recieved a call within an hour saying it had been turned in and for him to come retrieve it. I guess if you want to recieve a mediocre meal with crap service from thieves look no further than Tony Harper's in Old Forge!
I feel I need to warn the public. We ate at the Old forge location on Saturday 8/19/23. We came here solely on the recommendation from a friend because all of the online reviews were terrible. Unfortunately the online reviews are true. Our hostess was incredibly rude. Our waitress was completely useless. She would rather be on her phone and drink out of her cup by the kitchen than maintain any of her tables. You could sit there and watch other waitstaff trying to help this 'clueless' waitress. Many were bussing her tables, bringing out things she forgot. I had to practically beg for refills. She would look right at the empty cups and walk by and go back to her phone. Our food came out super slow. I ordered the prime rib, my husband ordered the steak. My potato came out highly overcooked and dry with nothing with it. Both of our beef came with butter knives to cut it. I will say the only thing our waitress was competent in doing was bringing the bill. After paying my husband noticed he had left behind an envelope of money. Needless to say he went back to get it and of course it wasn't there. She waitress and hostess argued that he had took it with him. Yes he raised his voice and left. Apparently the manager at that point must have questioned them because I recieved a call within an hour saying it had been turned in and for him to come retrieve it. I guess if you want to recieve a mediocre meal with crap service from thieves look no further than Tony Harper's in Old Forge!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place for tavern style food. Chicken wings are awesome at this place. Music a bit loud but ok. Also had clams and they were also very good. If you're in Old Forge you need to stop in. Pizza excellent also .
This place was amazing. Stopped by with multiple families with kids. They let us put three shaded picnic tables together so we could all eat outside. We got the pizza and wings with a side of onion rings and they were all exceptional. The beer selection is great and the staff is very accommodating. I can't wait to come back here specifically for those wings... They are to die for!
It happens every time we go every year. we sit at a picnic table outside with a family of seven the pizza comes in about 15 minutes. My hamburger comes 20 minutes later. Then the fries for the table-after the pizza was eaten. What’s that all about? They explained that they were swamped. That is not my problem. Service should include all meals at the same time, not at their convenience.
We went here 3 times. The first day we had an ok, average meal. The 2nd day we had salads, that the lettuce was wilted, and service was almost non-existent. The 3rd day was the clincher. We went upstairs to their roof top bar. The co-owner, (self-acclaimed) and another man were sitters at the bar. The other man was allowed to walk around and bother other patrons, despite people telling him to leave them alone. The bartender continued to serve this inebriated man, who turned out to be a local who is there often, and his offensiveness is considered him having fun. At the end, he ended up in a fight with another patron, because he would not leave them alone. Not saying that this other patron was right, however an owner allowing someone to bother customers, and continue to serve when he is drunk, is a questionable practice.
Tony harpers is one the most best pizzas. It always fills me up and satisfies me would recommend