First Rate! Highly recommend! We reserved for 6, but our party grew and we ultimately needed a table for 12. They accomodated--no problem! Bartender, Molly; server Katie. Super friendly and helpful. Thanks to all for a fantastic experience!
Henry Rothschild
I eat here, and order in 3-6 times a month ... need i say more.
rosann
If I have one complaint it is that you are time and feel rushed to eat and leave. An hour and half is not enough time to sit and enjoy and have an enjoyable evening dinner. Otherwise, everything was great!
Mala Sharma
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 A Five-Star Feast with LICOA – Unforgettable Dining Experience! Visited Mary’s Pizza & Pasta in Speonk on June 1, 2025 with the LICOA club, and the entire experience was outstanding — easily one of the best group dining experiences we’ve had on Long Island.
From start to finish, the food was phenomenal. We kicked things off with a classic Caesar salad — crisp romaine, bold dressing, and fresh parmesan. The pizza was perfection: crispy crust, rich sauce, and melty cheese that had everyone going back for seconds.
We ended on a high note with strong, delicious coffee and cannoli filled with chocolate chip-studded cream and topped with chocolate sprinkles — the perfect sweet finish.
The staff was attentive and incredibly accommodating for our large group, and the warm, welcoming atmosphere made us feel right at home. Mary’s is the kind of place that reminds you why you love Italian food.
Highly recommended — we’ll definitely be back! — LICOA Club Member & 2nd Photographer, June 2025
Ricci Paradiso
Always great food and service.
Nigel Peeples
Best pizza around, bar none. Everything is made fresh with the highest quality ingredients. I'll drive 20 minutes to get my pizza here even though there are two other pizza places 5 minutes away from me. Chef's kiss to Mary's!
MorichesBayBum
Never disappoints!
William
Our waitress Alyssa was fantastic, food was great. When the cheesecake wasn't that great, our server removed it from our bill- and we never even asked her too. Was very kind of her. Everything was great, only downside was it was extremely loud. We were a party of 6- 4 adults/2kids- we could barely hear each other. Needs more sound deadening
Colleen
We have been there several times and they have never disappointed. Our waiter was fantastic the busboys were super friendly food was delicious we can't say enough good things!
Pattie
Overall always great but portions seem to be getting smaller... Always a favorite though. :)
Mary's always has consistently good food ..definitely was very busy and a little crowded.. so the noise level was elevated. The only thing I would suggest is a coat room. Everyone's coat is on the back of their chair and can become cumbersome. Food and service was very good.. highly recommend!
John
We have eaten here at least 5 times. We have never had a bad meal. Awesome food, service, and atmosphere.
Jeanne
We absolutely love this restaurant. It is our go place for Italian food. We travel about 40 minutes to have dinner here. The food and service is absolutely amazingly delicious.
El Flanagan
Food quality varies visit to visit, stick with the pastas, decent. Service is attentive but not real professional ( reaching over, handing plates to you), family oriented by which I mean loud, not much noise buffer ( inside). I've been here approximately 4 times, once outside, other inside. It's ok to "eat" but not "dine". It's close and better than cooking myself but that and family b'day parties are what bring me there.
Kid-friendliness: Yes, been there with kids
Wheelchair accessibility: Not sure
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
April Canard
I went twice in one week. A late lunch and a late dinner. Their flatbread pizza was delicious with an eye-pleasing presentation. Great lighting in the front dining area and appropriate level of light in quiet rear dining. The bar area seems quite inviting. The staff members seemed very nice and very busy.
First Rate! Highly recommend! We reserved for 6, but our party grew and we ultimately needed a table for 12. They accomodated--no problem! Bartender, Molly; server Katie. Super friendly and helpful. Thanks to all for a fantastic experience!
I eat here, and order in 3-6 times a month ... need i say more.
If I have one complaint it is that you are time and feel rushed to eat and leave. An hour and half is not enough time to sit and enjoy and have an enjoyable evening dinner. Otherwise, everything was great!
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
A Five-Star Feast with LICOA – Unforgettable Dining Experience!
Visited Mary’s Pizza & Pasta in Speonk on June 1, 2025 with the LICOA club, and the entire experience was outstanding — easily one of the best group dining experiences we’ve had on Long Island.
From start to finish, the food was phenomenal. We kicked things off with a classic Caesar salad — crisp romaine, bold dressing, and fresh parmesan. The pizza was perfection: crispy crust, rich sauce, and melty cheese that had everyone going back for seconds.
Entrees were a true highlight. The Chicken Francese was tender and lemony, just the right balance of richness and acidity. The Sausage & Peppers were full of flavor, hearty and satisfying. The Eggplant Rollatini melted in your mouth — creamy ricotta inside and a light, savory marinara outside. The salmon was beautifully cooked, flaky and fresh, paired perfectly with the sautéed vegetables, which were vibrant and full of natural flavor.
We ended on a high note with strong, delicious coffee and cannoli filled with chocolate chip-studded cream and topped with chocolate sprinkles — the perfect sweet finish.
The staff was attentive and incredibly accommodating for our large group, and the warm, welcoming atmosphere made us feel right at home. Mary’s is the kind of place that reminds you why you love Italian food.
Highly recommended — we’ll definitely be back!
— LICOA Club Member & 2nd Photographer, June 2025
Always great food and service.
Best pizza around, bar none. Everything is made fresh with the highest quality ingredients. I'll drive 20 minutes to get my pizza here even though there are two other pizza places 5 minutes away from me. Chef's kiss to Mary's!
Never disappoints!
Our waitress Alyssa was fantastic, food was great. When the cheesecake wasn't that great, our server removed it from our bill- and we never even asked her too. Was very kind of her. Everything was great, only downside was it was extremely loud. We were a party of 6- 4 adults/2kids- we could barely hear each other. Needs more sound deadening
We have been there several times and they have never disappointed. Our waiter was fantastic the busboys were super friendly food was delicious we can't say enough good things!
Overall always great but portions seem to be getting smaller... Always a favorite though. :)
Restaurantji Recommends
Mary's always has consistently good food ..definitely was very busy and a little crowded.. so the noise level was elevated. The only thing I would suggest is a coat room. Everyone's coat is on the back of their chair and can become cumbersome. Food and service was very good.. highly recommend!
We have eaten here at least 5 times. We have never had a bad meal. Awesome food, service, and atmosphere.
We absolutely love this restaurant. It is our go place for Italian food. We travel about 40 minutes to have dinner here. The food and service is absolutely amazingly delicious.
Food quality varies visit to visit, stick with the pastas, decent. Service is attentive but not real professional ( reaching over, handing plates to you), family oriented by which I mean loud, not much noise buffer ( inside). I've been here approximately 4 times, once outside, other inside. It's ok to "eat" but not "dine". It's close and better than cooking myself but that and family b'day parties are what bring me there.
Kid-friendliness: Yes, been there with kids
Wheelchair accessibility: Not sure
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
I went twice in one week. A late lunch and a late dinner. Their flatbread pizza was delicious with an eye-pleasing presentation.
Great lighting in the front dining area and appropriate level of light in quiet rear dining. The bar area seems quite inviting. The staff members seemed very nice and very busy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mary's Meatballs, Lasagna
Loading...