My first visit to Jerry and the Mermaid was nothing short of magical. Nestled along the seaside, this charming restaurant boasts not only impeccable food but also a breathtaking setting that instantly transports you to a coastal paradise.From the moment we stepped inside, we were welcomed with warmth and hospitality that made us feel like longtime regulars, despite it being our first time there. Jerry himself checked in on us multiple times, ensuring that every aspect of our dining experience was nothing short of perfection.Despite the bustling Friday crowd during Easter weekend, Jerry’s accommodating nature and honesty about the wait time made our decision to stay worth it. And oh, was it worth it! As we strolled along the docks, soaking in the ocean breeze, anticipation built for what turned out to be a phenomenal experience.The food, oh the food! Each dish was a masterpiece, bursting with flavor and made with the utmost care. From the freshest seafood to delectable appetizers, every bite was a delight to the senses.But it wasn’t just the food that left a lasting impression. The atmosphere of the restaurant, with its cozy yet vibrant ambiance, added an extra layer of charm to the entire experience. Surrounded by the sound of waves and the sight of boats swaying gently in the harbor, we found ourselves lost in the moment, savoring each bite and each precious moment spent at Jerry and the Mermaid.In a world where exceptional dining experiences are rare gems, Jerry and the Mermaid shines brightly as a beacon of excellence. Whether you’re a local or a visitor passing through, do yourself a favor and make a reservation at this seaside paradise. You won’t regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mermaid Combo, Waffle Fries, Hot Lobster Roll, New England Clam Chowder, Jerry's Famous Lobster Roll
Kaitlin Higgins
Food was absolutely phenomenal! Lynn was our waitress she was so great! Friendly, very nice to my son. Great service. I can’t believe we’ve never been here before.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries, Seafood Bisque, Hot Lobster Roll
Barbeque Chef
03/28/24...I dont know why Google doesnt allow a second review... But anyhow, I'll add to my first one..Met a group of 5 people for Lunch.. Service was beyond good.. Our Waitress was not only as professional as could be, she was hlarious!!! As well, the Owner came to our table, and other tables, mulitple times during out meal... You cant ask for more than that !!Our food was, again top notch.. I had the burger, again.. How could I not order it, it one of the best hamburgers in Suffolk County...!! Thanks again for a great experience!!One of my favorite burgers around.The Marinated Angus Burger...It came out medium rare, as I ordered it, and like it..I'm not sure what it's marinated in, but I really enjoy the taste.The bun was meh...didn't add, or subtract from burger. Sometimes I wonder why I even order the bun with it...Force of habit, I guess..I think I've enjoyed only 2 buns in the last year lolThe fries are a different story..They are one of the few restaurants that offer waffle fries. They are THE most potatioest tasting fries out there.(Is that a word). Just lightly salted, and super crisp..Probably my favorite fries on Long Island.The service was great. Linda, our Server was prompt, humorous, and very professional...It's definitely on the top of my Hamburger list for Long Island.There's also parking behind the restaurant, which is an added plus.Riverhead does get crowded, especially with the Aquarium right next door, and the general hub bub, and buzz, of downtown Riverhead, so the parking lot helps..Jerry and the Mermaid, Riverhead.Highly reccomend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon Jozaitis
The food here is excellent. This is my favorite restaurant. Then here, many times the oysters rockefeller is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sabrina Peterson
The food was delicious and the service was great. The Cajun salmon with garlic potatoes and mix veggies was tasty. I enjoyed the cozy atmosphere.
Great restaurant with very good food. Extremely friendly staff. The linguine with white clam sauce is awesome :-)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sheyla Gamez
This was a Michelin star experience! The presentation was exquisite followed by a mouthful of flavor. I stumbled upon this place by coincidence today not expecting much other than a simple lunch and WOW I was wrong, I wished I lived closer but I will be coming back in 2 weeks. Thank you to everyone who made this such a delightful experience and thank you to the chef who greeted us today- your food is literally AMAZING!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New England Clam Chowder
Martin P
We saw chef and manager during our dinner. Food deserves the price. They have reserved parking . View is good too
Christine Starkey
So delicious foods so amazing they're so nice and
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chauncée Ventura
Be careful eating here. My family members ended up in the emergency room from the Oysters they served on 3/9. Be very careful.
We absolutely LOVE it here! The food is amazing and the service is always incredible! Lynne and Tommy are both funny and sweet and soooo attentive! We can’t wait to come back again! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cecile Rollat
Thank you chef! We spent a nice evening there. Everything was very good and awesome service. Keep going! Bravo!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jose Rosario
Impeccable service through and through... Hats off to Jerry and his wonderfully Professional Staff... Food was Cheffed Up With love in every bite..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mermaid Combo, Wild Blue Point Oysters, Lobster Roll Cold, Seafood Bisque, Lobster Roll Warm, Shrimp Scampi Pasta, With Waffle Fries, New England Clam Chowder, Cold Lobster Roll, Steak
Phyllis Montgomery
Waitress wonderful. Food equitably priced. Very lively place for families and all others. Drinks wonderful. Food good, average. We had a good time before the show at the Suffolk theater down the street.Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mary Faley
Surf and turf was on the special tonight. i highly recommend it. My husband said the French onion soup was the best he's ever had, and he's had a lot of French onion soup!! Lynn was our server she was a lot of fun and did a fantastic job.Dietary restrictions: They were accommodating for my sister, who eats gluten-free
My first visit to Jerry and the Mermaid was nothing short of magical. Nestled along the seaside, this charming restaurant boasts not only impeccable food but also a breathtaking setting that instantly transports you to a coastal paradise.From the moment we stepped inside, we were welcomed with warmth and hospitality that made us feel like longtime regulars, despite it being our first time there. Jerry himself checked in on us multiple times, ensuring that every aspect of our dining experience was nothing short of perfection.Despite the bustling Friday crowd during Easter weekend, Jerry’s accommodating nature and honesty about the wait time made our decision to stay worth it. And oh, was it worth it! As we strolled along the docks, soaking in the ocean breeze, anticipation built for what turned out to be a phenomenal experience.The food, oh the food! Each dish was a masterpiece, bursting with flavor and made with the utmost care. From the freshest seafood to delectable appetizers, every bite was a delight to the senses.But it wasn’t just the food that left a lasting impression. The atmosphere of the restaurant, with its cozy yet vibrant ambiance, added an extra layer of charm to the entire experience. Surrounded by the sound of waves and the sight of boats swaying gently in the harbor, we found ourselves lost in the moment, savoring each bite and each precious moment spent at Jerry and the Mermaid.In a world where exceptional dining experiences are rare gems, Jerry and the Mermaid shines brightly as a beacon of excellence. Whether you’re a local or a visitor passing through, do yourself a favor and make a reservation at this seaside paradise. You won’t regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mermaid Combo, Waffle Fries, Hot Lobster Roll, New England Clam Chowder, Jerry's Famous Lobster Roll
Food was absolutely phenomenal! Lynn was our waitress she was so great! Friendly, very nice to my son. Great service. I can’t believe we’ve never been here before.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries, Seafood Bisque, Hot Lobster Roll
03/28/24...I dont know why Google doesnt allow a second review... But anyhow, I'll add to my first one..Met a group of 5 people for Lunch.. Service was beyond good.. Our Waitress was not only as professional as could be, she was hlarious!!! As well, the Owner came to our table, and other tables, mulitple times during out meal... You cant ask for more than that !!Our food was, again top notch.. I had the burger, again.. How could I not order it, it one of the best hamburgers in Suffolk County...!! Thanks again for a great experience!!One of my favorite burgers around.The Marinated Angus Burger...It came out medium rare, as I ordered it, and like it..I'm not sure what it's marinated in, but I really enjoy the taste.The bun was meh...didn't add, or subtract from burger. Sometimes I wonder why I even order the bun with it...Force of habit, I guess..I think I've enjoyed only 2 buns in the last year lolThe fries are a different story..They are one of the few restaurants that offer waffle fries. They are THE most potatioest tasting fries out there.(Is that a word). Just lightly salted, and super crisp..Probably my favorite fries on Long Island.The service was great. Linda, our Server was prompt, humorous, and very professional...It's definitely on the top of my Hamburger list for Long Island.There's also parking behind the restaurant, which is an added plus.Riverhead does get crowded, especially with the Aquarium right next door, and the general hub bub, and buzz, of downtown Riverhead, so the parking lot helps..Jerry and the Mermaid, Riverhead.Highly reccomend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food here is excellent. This is my favorite restaurant. Then here, many times the oysters rockefeller is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was delicious and the service was great. The Cajun salmon with garlic potatoes and mix veggies was tasty. I enjoyed the cozy atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries, Sauce, Jerry's Marinated Angus Cheeseburger Platter
Great restaurant with very good food. Extremely friendly staff. The linguine with white clam sauce is awesome :-)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was a Michelin star experience! The presentation was exquisite followed by a mouthful of flavor. I stumbled upon this place by coincidence today not expecting much other than a simple lunch and WOW I was wrong, I wished I lived closer but I will be coming back in 2 weeks. Thank you to everyone who made this such a delightful experience and thank you to the chef who greeted us today- your food is literally AMAZING!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New England Clam Chowder
We saw chef and manager during our dinner. Food deserves the price. They have reserved parking . View is good too
So delicious foods so amazing they're so nice and
Food: 5
Service: 5
Be careful eating here. My family members ended up in the emergency room from the Oysters they served on 3/9. Be very careful.
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We absolutely LOVE it here! The food is amazing and the service is always incredible! Lynne and Tommy are both funny and sweet and soooo attentive! We can’t wait to come back again! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thank you chef! We spent a nice evening there. Everything was very good and awesome service. Keep going! Bravo!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Impeccable service through and through... Hats off to Jerry and his wonderfully Professional Staff... Food was Cheffed Up With love in every bite..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mermaid Combo, Wild Blue Point Oysters, Lobster Roll Cold, Seafood Bisque, Lobster Roll Warm, Shrimp Scampi Pasta, With Waffle Fries, New England Clam Chowder, Cold Lobster Roll, Steak
Waitress wonderful. Food equitably priced. Very lively place for families and all others. Drinks wonderful. Food good, average. We had a good time before the show at the Suffolk theater down the street.Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Surf and turf was on the special tonight. i highly recommend it. My husband said the French onion soup was the best he's ever had, and he's had a lot of French onion soup!! Lynn was our server she was a lot of fun and did a fantastic job.Dietary restrictions: They were accommodating for my sister, who eats gluten-free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak