My Cookie Dealer Pop-Up
501 Tanger Mall Dr, Riverhead
(631) 591-0688
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Blueberry cheesecake cookie was amazing and didn’t taste too sweet like most cookies. French press coffee great too, happy to stumble across this place. Would add a picture of the cookie but we ate it too fast
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spent $70, fine. I do that for Levain. What I didn't expect was super dry, flavorless cookies. They all tasted the same. And dry, dry, dry. They crumble, even when warmed per instructions (see pics). Moist cookies don't crumble. Save yourself a waste of money and order Levain instead.
Half the cookies were smashed due to packaging. The box was in perfect condition.
I ordered based on reviews, happy other people like them but as a baker, not the quality I was expecting.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tried this at the NPC Universe show! WOW! Amazing cannoli s’mores cookie !
Food: 5
ordered for the first time wanted to try orange Creamsicle and so disappointed taste like nothing no flavor what so ever everyone talking g how good these cookies are and I am yet to see how good they are
Cookies are overrated. Got sold on them by the clerk at the nutrition store. Paid $11.50 for two. They were big but doesn't taste good and looks nothing like the picture on the packaging. It's edible but I wouldn't get them again. The coffee cake I thought it was coffee flav but nah it's just cake you eat with coffee.. it was stale and has barely any flavor. The strawberry one was okay but the center filling looks nothing like the one advertised on the packaging. It's more like dried poptart filling. This is the closest Google listing I can find to give my feedback. Also barely taste any protein in the cookies
Food: 1
Cookies are great, but when you swap one cookie order for another because you ran out of a flavor do check with customer first. I would have preferred a refund to my card.
We have ordered multiple times from here and i have to say this last time was terrible. I love the strawberry pop tart ones. I got them and they were hard as a rock and the jelly did not taste the same. It tasted fake. I used to enjoy these cookies but now they’re not the same anymore. These cookies came so hard and i do not like them warmed up. Like i said the jelly tasted fake, not like real jelly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Funfetti, Stuffed Cookies
It’s really a pain that this is the only store that doesn’t follow Tangers normal hours. I don’t know if the company is broke and doesn’t want to staff more than the 1 girl that works here, but it’s honestly a joke that it’s closed on a Saturday when they’re already closed the first half of the week.I’m done with this place.
I order them to Ohio and they still
Food: 5
I’m putting a one star, because I was ordering from them every time I had a get family get together. My package didn’t arrive and as I explained it to them in my email, they said “it arrived so there’s nothing we can do about it “ The woman handling it could care less that I was a frequent customer, I will no longer buy from them again. And I have found way better cookies for better prices else were. Thanks for nothing
Restaurantji Recommends
Very mid. These cookies are dry, don’t let the photos deceive you.
My all time favorite cookies! The flavors are so unique and there are so many to choose from and they vary by season. I’ve ordered from them many times and the cookies are always fresh and absolutely delicious. I’ve sent cookies to family as well and they loved them. So glad I gave this company a try.
AMAZING, DELICIOUS, I'M OBSESSED!!These cookies are fresh and tons of different flavors to choose from.I ordered a few for my co-workers and immediately they asked "Where can we get them from!!!".Taste and packaging A+These cookies will be the desserts for our Holiday Parties coming up!!You GUYS are amazing!! Sending lots of love xoxo
I am obsessed with these cookies! Hands down the best cookies on the market and the best part is the vast variety of flavors can never get tired of them if you have no tried any do yourself a favor a do so!
These cookies are delicious!!!
Loading...